THE FRENCH REVOLUTION

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 16, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 11.

Read the full edition

THE FRENCH REVOLUTION.

The Aristocrats and the Church.

BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek College.)
Yet a little while is the light with you. Walk while ye have the light, lest darkness come upon you: for he that walketh in darkness knoweth not whither he goeth. While ye have light, believe in the light, that ye may be the children of light.—The Master.
I stated in my last paper that every new ray of light and truth on the word of God, which a man rejects, necessarily weakens his faith in those portions of the word which he has hitherto and heretofore believed. Therefore when a man rejects one Bible truth, he sows the seed, he opens the way, for the relinquishing of every ray of truth he has ever known and cherished. Hence the harm which the soul incurs in pursuing such a course lies not alone in the injury to his spiritual life, which follows from the rejection of one specific particle of truth. Of vastly more importance than that is the fact that it leads to the ultimate rejection of the whole word of God, of Christianity, of Jesus Christ, and of salvation itself. And when this last condition is reached, a man is an atheist; his religion is atheism.
Now atheism was the real condition of the aristocrats and clergy in France at the time when the Revolution broke out. They did not call themselves atheists; but nevertheless that is, in short, all they were. Moreover, like prince like people, and like priest like people. From the princes and the priests the people had learned the same dire creed, and soon they were to manifest their faith in it, in the destruction of everything good.
Avowed skepticism had been growing in France for many a long year. It first began to be perceptible during the reign of Louis XIV, who persecuted the Protestants so relentlessly. In 1698 the Palatine, the mother of the Regent, wrote: “We scarcely meet a young man now who is not ambitious of being an atheist.” In 1722 unbelief became so prominent that this lady wrote again: “I doubt if, in all Paris, a hundred individuals can be found, either ecclesiastics or laymen, who have any true faith, or even believe in our Lord. It makes me tremble.” Soon the position of an ecclesiastic in society began to be difficult. “The moment we appear,” says one of them, “we are forced into discussion. We are called upon to prove, for example, the utility of prayer to an unbeliever in God, and the necessity of fasting to a man who has all his life denied the immortality of the soul: the effort is very irksome while those who laugh are not on our side.”
But where lay the root of all this trouble? The priests had forced men to pray who did not believe in God. Was there any good in it?—Obviously not; for, “Whatsoever is not of faith is sin.” Now the Reformation had brought the light that “whatsoever is not of faith is sin.” Therefore, in rejecting the Reformation, and in forcing men to pray who did not want to pray, the priests had sown the seed which now sprang up into ridicule against themselves. A little later on, in 1751, Barbier wrote: “There is danger that this [the lack of interest in the Roman Catholic religion] may end seriously; we may some day see a revolution in this country in favor of Protestantism.” Barbier was right. A revolution was sure to come. There was going to be a revolution against Romanism, but not in favor of Protestantism. For this there were reasons a plenty.
It was the Saviour who said, in that memorable prayer in the garden: “I in them, and thou in me, that they may be made perfect in one; and that the world may know that thou hast sent me, and hast loved them, as thou hast loved me.” The world does not read the Bible, and hence all the world sees of Jesus Christ is what it sees in the lives of his followers. When, therefore, men profess to have Jesus Christ dwelling within, and do not really have him at all, they are misrepresenting Christ to the world; consequently the world, instead of learning to know Christ through these so-called followers of his, are really learning to know everything else but Christ. Instead of becoming Christians, they are becoming atheists. Now, when the revolution came of which Barbier prophesied, it was against Catholicism; but it was not “in favor of Protestantism.” Protestantism had been crushed out at the time of the Reformation; Catholicism only was left, and it was forced upon everybody by law. When, therefore, the people rose against Catholicism, they rose against what they thought was Christianity; for Catholicism had always been placed before them as Christianity. The light of Protestantism had been with them only “a little while,” then it had been withdrawn from a nation which spurned it. Hence it was impossible for the Revolution to be in favor of Protestantism; and since it was against Catholicism, there was nothing left, in the nature of things, for it to be in favor of but atheism. And this is precisely the way it was.
Said D’Argenson, writing in 1753: “As our nation and our century are quite otherwise enlightened [than in the time of Luther], it will be carried far enough; they will expel the priests, abolish the priesthood, and get rid of all revelation and mystery.” Exactly. Had France accepted the Reformation, in the time of Luther, the priests might have been expelled and the Roman Catholic priesthood system abolished; but revelation, a belief in God and the divine word of God, would not have been “got rid of.” Luther and the Reformers believed in revelation. But, as D’Argenson says, the eighteenth century was “otherwise enlightened.” It did not believe in “revelation.” And this was the logical result of rejecting the Reformation. The French had rejected a part of “revelation” then, and this had brought them to the place in the eighteenth century where they rejected the whole revelation of God,—the whole Bible,—and became veritable atheists.
Toward the end of the eighteenth century it was written: “We see young persons openly pluming themselves on their irreligion.” “The fashionable world,” said Mercier, in 1783, “has not attended mass for ten years past. People go only on Sundays, so as not to scandalize their servants, while the servants well know that it is on their account.”
Said Taine:—
The Duc de Coigny, on his estate near Amiens, refuses to be prayed for, and threatens his curate, if he takes that liberty, to have him cast out of his pulpit; his son becomes ill, and he prohibits the administration of the sacraments; the son dies, and he opposes the usual obsequies, burying the body in his garden; becoming ill himself, he closes his door against the bishop of Amiens, who comes to see him twelve times, and dies as he had lived. A scandal of this kind is doubtless notorious, and, therefore, rare. Almost everybody, male and female, “ally with freedom of ideas a proper observance of forms.” When a maid appears, and says to her mistress, “Madam la Duchesse, the Host (le bon Dieu) is outside, will you allow him to enter? He desires to have the honor of administering to you,” appearances are kept up. Society was never more detached from Christianity. In its eyes a positive religion is only a popular superstition, good enough for children and innocents, but not for “sensible people” and the great. It is your duty to raise your hat to the Host as it passes, but your duty is only to raise your hat.
A plain priest, a curate, must have a little faith, otherwise he would be found a hypocrite; at the same time, he must not be too well satisfied; for he would be found intolerant. On the contrary, the grand vicar may smile at an expression against religion, the bishop may laugh outright, and the cardinal may add something of his own to it. “A little while ago,” a chronicle narrates, “some one put this question to one of the most respectable curates in Paris: Do you think that the bishops who insist so strenuously on religion have much of it themselves? The worthy pastor replied, after a moment’s hesitation, ‘There may be four or five among them who still believe.’”
In 1744, says the bookseller Hardy, during the king’s illness at Metz, private individuals cause six thousand masses to be said for his recovery, and pay for them at the sacristy of Notre Dame; in 1757, after Damiens’s attempt on the king’s life, the number of masses demanded is only six hundred; in 1774, during the malady which carries him off, the number falls down to three.
Now it will be clear from all this, that all there was to the Catholic religion in France at the time of the Revolution, was a “form of godliness;” and in many cases there was not even much form left. The rejection of the Reformation had borne its fruit—the rejection of all faith in every part of God’s word, and even in the ritual of the religion itself. It only remained now for a wilder element to throw off the form, and openly declare for atheism.
In another paper the parallel to all this in the present time may justly claim consideration.