WHO IS MISTAKEN?

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 16, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 11.

Read the full edition

WHO IS MISTAKEN?

A WRITER in the World's Crisis of February 10, discussing the subject of the Sabbath, says: “We think there is some mistake about God’s instituting the Sabbath at creation. In Neh. 9:14 we read that it was made known by Moses. Moses lived twenty-five hundred years this side of creation. You should remember Moses wrote the book of Genesis after he had received the law at Sinai, and in his account of creation he tells us how God blessed and sanctified the seventh day; i. e., set it apart to a holy use; not at creation, but in the fourth commandment. Hence Neh. 9:14 is true.”
The above statement should be given to Ingersoll to add to his list of the “mistakes of Moses;” for it is here coolly asserted that Moses made a mistake, and had the Sabbath instituted at the wrong time, even twenty-five hundred years before he should have mentioned it in that way! To prove that Moses was mistaken, the attempt is made to involve Moses and Nehemiah in a contradiction of each other! But if Nehemiah is really against Moses, why may not Nehemiah be mistaken? God talked with Moses face to face, as a man talks with his friend. Surely he would make no mistake. Furthermore, we do not read in Nehemiah that the Sabbath was made known by Moses. Nehemiah, speaking in prayer, says, “Thou . . . madest known unto them thy holy Sabbath.” It was God who made the Sabbath known. Notice also that he did not make the Sabbath at this time, but he made it known. It must have been in existence before, or he could not have made it known then. God declared by his servant Ezekiel concerning Israel, “I will make myself known among them” (Eze. 35:11); but was he not existing and known before among them?
One more thought! When God spoke the ten commandments on Mount Sinai, in commanding the observance of the seventh day, he referred to the creation for the reason for the commandment. Then the reason for seventh-day Sabbath-keeping had been in existence for twenty-five hundred years. Does not this, of itself, argue that the Sabbath was also in existence? Is not the Sabbath coexistent with the reason for it? Otherwise Moses, and—alas for the conclusion!—the Lord, too, made “a mistake” in referring to creation as the time when the Sabbath originated! There surely is “a mistake” somewhere; but we are willing to leave it to the reader—yes, to every candid reader of the Bible—to decide who is mistaken, whether Nehemiah, Moses, the Lord, or the writer in the Crisis.
M. E. K.