So deeply rooted in some minds is the fallacious idea that the Jews are at some time to be restored to Palestine, and have their national existence once more continued, that those who hold this view take much comfort, apparently, in devising plans how it can be done. One plan, much in favor, is for the United States government to buy the land of Palestine and give it to the Jews! Arguing for the propriety and feasibility of this plan, a misguided enthusiast makes the following suggestion:—
We claim originality only for our suggestion of a practical way by which our government might accomplish the end desired; that is, by applying the principle of purchase, by which most of our great accessions of territory have been acquired, to this purpose of restoring the Jews to the Holy Land; in a word, buy it for them from the Turk. Why not? We bought Louisiana from France, and it embraced at the time almost the whole of the great valley of the Mississippi, or the western part of it, at least, to the Rocky Mountains. We bought the territory of Florida from Spain, and a couple of decades ago we bought Alaska from Russia.
It would seem that any one with half an eye could see the difference between the former purchases which our government has made, and which are here alluded to, and the one suggested in regard to the purchase of Palestine. The lands so purchased,—Louisiana, Florida, and Alaska,—were contiguous to our country, and were purchased that they might become a part of our country, not to be given to some one else. Nations are not so generous as to buy great tracts of land to give away. Furthermore, when the United States made those purchases, the countries of whom they were purchased had power to deliver the purchase to the purchaser; but Turkey cannot cede a foot of her territory without the consent of the powers. Taking into consideration the low state of the United States treasury, the exceeding unlikelihood of this government's buying anything to give away, the impossibility of negotiating with the Turk, and the attitude of the powers, it looks exceedingly doubtful whether such a trade could ever be consummated. Of course if any one desires to cherish this theory for his own amusement and gratification, he has a perfect right to do so; the only question is whether he might not be more profitably employed than in pursuing such a phantom.
M. E. K.