JUSTICE VS. SENTIMENT

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 23, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 12.

Read the full edition

JUSTICE VS. SENTIMENT.

The morbid sentimentality which seeks to avert justice from falling where it belongs is particularly active in the cases of the young men Jackson and Walling, sentenced to be hanged at Frankfort, Ky., for the murder of Pearl Bryan. This was one of the most atrocious murders ever known, in which two educated young scapegraces murdered a young girl who had confided in them, for the purpose of hiding a crime committed by one of them. There are no extenuating circumstances. The whole transaction shows that they had descended to the very lowest depths of human depravity, and were ready to do murder to save themselves from a little unpleasant notoriety. Since the crime was proved against them, they have mutually incriminated each other, each endeavoring to shield himself.
As before remarked, they have no claim for mercy; but a morbid and sickly sentimentalism is endeavoring to throw the mantle of executive clemency over them. As the day fixed for the execution draws near, the governor of Kentucky is actually flooded with telegrams and letters begging him to spare the lives of these young murderers. Of course it is very painful to tear these young men from their mothers’ arms and execute them; but the fact that they are educated, and are members of “good families,” is no reason to justify executive clemency in their behalf. Why should educated young men of the highest families be held less responsible for their deeds than those whose training has not been so good? To exempt men, when fairly convicted of crime, from the penalties of just laws, is always a very dangerous expedient. It tends to bring law into contempt, increases the violations of law, causes people to doubt the efficacy of the law to punish crime, and leads them to resort to irregular means for its punishment. We need more strict justice, administered alike to rich and poor, allowing mercy to be exercised toward proper objects of mercy; and we need less of that silly weakness which seeks to cover the crimes of the educated and refined, while denying it to the uneducated, the ignorant, and the friendless. M. E. K.
The prize-fight at Carson City, Nev., between Bob Fitzsimmons and James Corbett, which has attracted more attention in this country than any other similar event, came off on March 17, Fitzsimmons winning. Never was there a more brutal exhibition, both men being intensely mad at each other, and the whole immense audience a howling mob. Fitzsimmons’s wife, wrought up to the highest pitch of feminine frenzy, stood in a conspicuous place, encouraging her husband to fight, applying the most indecent epithets to his antagonist, and calling on her husband to “kill him!” When Corbett was finally defeated, she rushed at him, screaming that she would kill him, and nothing but her lack of weapons and the presence of friends of Corbett prevented her doing so. Take it altogether, it was a scene to make fiends rejoice, and puts an indelible stain upon the State of Nevada. M. E. K.