AdventAI

In the Question Chair.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 12., March 23, 1897

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

752.—WERE THEY ANGELS?

Will you please give your views as to who were the “sons of God” who are mentioned in Gen. 6:4? Were they angels, as is sometimes claimed? D. W. B.

Ans.—It appears, from John 10:35, that men “unto whom the word of God came” were sometimes called gods. Christ quotes the words from Ps. 82:6, which reads: “I have said, Ye are gods; and all of you are children of the Most High.” Another expression for “children of the Most High” would be, very properly, “sons of God,” as in Gen. 6:4. In Gen. 4:26 it is stated that in the days of Seth, men began “to call upon the name of the Lord;” or, as the margin reads, “to call themselves by the name of the Lord.” That is, the followers of the Lord assumed his name to distinguish themselves from the wicked around them. But these all went into apostasy, so that at the time of the flood, Noah and his family alone were found righteous. Thus apostatizing, these “sons of God” formed corrupt alliances with the fair and proud daughters of men, or of the wicked; and being, as may well be supposed, men in the perfection of physical development and vigor, their children became men of renown. It is altogether insupposable that angels, who are of a different constitution and nature from human beings (Heb. 2:16), have ever formed any matrimonial alliance with the daughters of men. The text speaks of only two classes of persons in this world, and shows how fast the work of apostasy was progressing among the good.

753.—CASTING LOTS.

Frequent mention is made in the Bible of casting lots to decide certain questions. Are we to understand that this is God’s prescribed plan for deciding matters of business or religion? Was the use of the Urim and Thummim a form of casting lots? P. H.

Ans.—So far as the New-Testament record is concerned (which, on such a question as this, is all that we need concern ourselves with), there is not even proof of any custom in this matter, much less any command or direction to decide questions in this way. The one instance recorded of what is understood to be casting lots, is given in Acts 1:26. This had reference to choosing some one to take the place of Judas on the board of the twelve apostles. It was a very special and important matter. The disciples understood that they were under obligation to supply this vacancy, from what David had said in Ps. 69:25; 109:8. Their minds rested upon two individuals for the place; namely, Justus and Matthias. They were sure that one of these two was the person the Lord designed to take the place of Judas; but they were unable to decide which. Under these circumstances, inasmuch asp. 188 the Lord had pointed out in prophecy that some choice should be made, it would seem quite appropriate that the decision should be submitted in the way it was. But the circumstances were peculiar, and different from any that have existed since, or that can exist now; and hence this case furnishes no precedent to govern the action of the church at the present time. However, Meyer and some other commentators think the expression in Acts 1:26, “And they gave forth their lots,” is not such as can possibly apply to putting the two names into an urn, and then drawing out one, as would be the procedure in the ordinary method of casting lots. They therefore hold that the “appointment” named in verse 23, simply means their “nomination,” and the giving forth of their lots in verse 26, means casting their ballots respectively for the one they preferred; and a majority being led by the Lord to favor Matthias, he was chosen to the place. In this case there was nothing about that transaction of the nature of casting lots, in the ordinary acceptation of that term. The use of the Urim and Thummim had no connection with the casting of lots. These were precious stones, which gave forth preternatural light to indicate the Lord’s answer to questions asked through them.

754.—ANGEL VS. HOLY SPIRIT.

1. Is the angel of Rev. 18:1 a literal angel? If so, is it the personal appearance of the Holy Spirit, in conjunction with the third angel of chapter 14? 2. If not, does it, like the third angel, represent the people who receive its warning, and carry the message to the world? If so, does it signify simply an increase of the Adventist body under the third angel? or is it a separate movement? P. E.

Ans.—All the movements symbolized by angels would most naturally be supposed to be under the direction, or control, of some one or more of those heavenly beings who have such power, and are so much interested in the welfare of men. Matt. 28:3, 4; Heb. 1:14. The message of Rev. 18:1 is supplementary to that of Rev. 14:8, but is evidently given after quite a lapse of time from the announcement of the latter, giving opportunity for the changes to occur in Babylon indicated in Rev. 18:2. But the third angel immediately follows the message of Rev. 14:8, and continues till the Lord comes. Verses 9–14. Therefore the movement indicated in Rev. 18:1–4 must be contemporaneous with the closing work of the third message of chapter 14; and as the messages of this chapter are undoubtedly directed by literal angels, there seems to be no reason why the movement of Rev. 18:1–4 should not be the same, the view indicating not a separate movement, but a great increase in the power and strength and practical results of the third message, with which it unites. It cannot be the Holy Spirit appearing personally among men; for there is no evidence that it is so to appear; and when it has appeared in bodily form, it has been under different symbols, as tongues of fire (Acts 2:3), a dove (John 1:32), and lamps of fire (Rev. 4:5), showing that it has no uniform personality, as otherwise the form would always be the same. If it is said that these are symbols, as a lion and a lamb symbolize Christ in Rev. 5:5, 6, then it follows that no bodily appearance of the Spirit itself has ever been given, which would show that it has no visible form. And there are various expressions concerning the Holy Spirit which would indicate that it could not be properly considered as a person, such as its being “shed abroad” in the heart, and “poured out upon all flesh.” U. S.