AdventAI

THE FRENCH REVOLUTION.

By P. T. Magan

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 12., March 23, 1897

The Aristocrats and the Church.

BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.

(Battle Creek College.)

My kingdom is not of this world.—Jesus.

During the ancient régime in France, the Roman Catholic Church and the aristocratic government had maintained a close alliance. Bossuet, one of the greatest and most eloquent of the French Roman Catholic divines, had even formulated in a book the maxims of this double despotism. His work was entitled, “Politics Drawn from the Holy Scriptures.”1 The work is described as being a learned catechism, in which a royalty without control, and a clergy without restraint, are taught how, by uniting, they may enslave a nation. Bossuet defines the king as being a god, “whose countenance rejoices his people as the sun, and whose indisputable caprices ought to be received upon their knees.” The people are taught that the sovereign is absolute, and that he reigns by divine right.

Against his despotism there is no appeal, and after a timid remonstrance, his people have only to kiss the dust where his foot has trampled them. There is no right in the face of royal right. I am mistaken — there is the right of the priest, for whom alone Bossuet causes to be heard a haughty claim. All the property of the nation belongs to the king, except that of the Levites, with which he ought to concern himself only to increase it. Moreover, heresy is not to be tolerated in the happy country that he governs.”2

“Those,” says Bossuet, “who do not wish to suffer the prince to use severity in matters of religion, because religion ought to be free, are in an impious error;” and he recalls the oath taken by the very Christian king on the day of his coronation, and the solemn engagement that he takes to exterminate heresy. “All these beautiful theories are supported by passages of Holy Scripture, the true sense of which is completely disfigured. . . . He arrives thus at this double result of causing hatred altogether, both toward monarchy and Christianity, and of surely preparing the most dangerous revolution.”3

At the time when the Revolution broke out, Pius VI was pope.

He took the side of Louis XVI against the people of France, and denounced the Legislative Assembly, and avowed his purpose to maintain all the prerogative rights of the “Holy See.” He accordingly issued an encyclical proclamation, in which he condemned the efforts of the French people to establish a republic, and the Legislative Assembly, in these words: “That Assembly, after abolishing monarchy, which is the most natural form of government, had attributed almost all power to the populace, who follow no wisdom and no counsel, and have no understanding of things.” . . . He declared that “the priesthood and tyranny support each other; and, the one overthrown, the other cannot long subsist.” He denounced the liberty after which France was striving, as tending “to corrupt minds, pervert morals, and overthrow all order in affairs and laws,” and the equality of man as leading to “anarchy,” and the “speedy dissolution of society.”4

It will readily be seen, from the above, why it was that the French Revolution entertained such a violent dislike for the church. The church had been the supporter of that form of government which had ruined the nation. She had, in her unholy alliance with the state, upheld tyranny and despotism. Now tyranny and despotism by kings and nobles were being trampled in the mire, and the church, of course, was made to share in the punishment. More than that, a very great deal of the despotism of the ancient régime was directly chargeable to the church. She it was who instigated the persecutions. It was her extravagance that had brought the people to the lowest depths of poverty. Now the nation was bankrupt, and had nothing to pay, and it was only fair that the church should be forced to disgorge, and compelled to satisfy the creditors.

For many years the clergy had possessed the right of exacting tithes from the people of France for their support. These tithes, however, although a heavy tax, were not taken upon all articles of produce, nor did they usually amount to one tenth of the increase. Sometimes the tithe was compounded for a fixed rent in money; sometimes for a given number of sheaves, or measures of wine, per acre.5 Tithes were also taken of calves, lambs, chickens, and fish.

On the night of Aug. 4, 1789, the National Assembly decreed the abolition of tithes.6 This was a fearful blow to the clerical party. At the same time the Assembly agreed to pay small salaries to the priests, so that they would not be utterly destitute.

The church now began to see that things were going to go hard with her, so she offered voluntarily to make some renunciations. On Sept. 25, 1789, the clergy offered to give up all the gold and silver plate belonging to the church, except what was absolutely necessary to the decency of public worship; and on the 29th inst. the measure was carried. But this did not satisfy.

On October 11 of that same year a formal proposition was made to seize the property of the church, and confiscate it for the enrichment of the state. It was argued that the state had no right to do this; but the revolutionary statesmen replied that the land had originally been given to the priests to support them while they labored to improve the morality of the people. Instead of doing this, these statesmen urged, the clergy had become possessed of worse morals than any other class in the kingdom; “and,” said Pétion, “it is the immense riches of the ecclesiastics which have ruined their morals.” The outcome of the matter was that the enormous property — the vast estates — of the clergy was sold, and sold to pay the public debt. “The Assembly thus destroyed the formidable power of the clergy and the luxury of the high dignitaries of the order, and secured those immense financial resources which so long upheld the Revolution.”7

These lands were transferred in a mass by the general government to the municipalities which purchased them, in order that they might sell them again by degrees in small lots to individuals. Thus was fulfilled the word of Daniel the prophet, spoken so many hundred years before of this very people and this very time: “They shall divide the land for gain.”8

From the moment their land was sold,9 the hatred of the clergy toward the Revolution broke forth. Immediately they everywhere commenced plotting against the new government. This enraged the legislators, and severe acts were soon passed against them. If twenty active citizens denounced a priest, and if the directory of the district approved of the denunciation, the directory of the department pronounced sentence. The condemned priest was obliged to leave the canton in twenty-four hours, the department in three days, and the kingdom in a month.

The priests, poor souls, now began to drink the bitter cup which they had so often held to Protestant lips. They were persecuted and hunted like wild beasts, and driven from their native land. The mills of God had ground slowly, but at last retribution had come. Much of the wealth of the nobles was also confiscated, and they themselves were subjected to the same treatment as the priests. In a remarkable paragraph, Taine parallels their condition and treatment with that which they had bestowed upon the poor Protestants in previous years:—

The treatment of the nobles by the Assembly is the same as the treatment of the Protestants by Louis XIV. In both cases the oppressed are a superior class of men. In both cases France has been made uninhabitable for them. In both cases they are reduced to exile, and they are punished because they exiled themselves. In both cases it ended in a confiscation of their property, and in the penalty of death to all who should harbor them. In both cases, by dint of persecution, they are driven to revolt. The insurrection of La Vendée corresponds with the insurrection of the Cévennes; and the emigrants, like the refugees of former times, will be found under the flags of Prussia and of England. One hundred thousand Frenchmen driven out at the end of the seventeenth century, and one hundred thousand driven out at the end of the eighteenth century! Mark how an intolerant democracy completes the work of an intolerant monarchy. The moral aristocracy was mowed down in the name of uniformity; the social aristocracy is mowed down in the name of equality. For the second time, an absolute principle, and with the same effect, buries its blade in the heart of a living society.10

Thus surely does sin bring its wages; and God punishes churches and nations as certainly as individuals.

Notes

  1. 1“Le Politique tirée de L’Ecriture Sainte.” ↩
  2. 2De Pressensé, “The Church and the French Revolution.” ↩
  3. 3Ibid. ↩
  4. 4Thompson, “Footprints of the Jesuits,” chap. 23, par. 17. ↩
  5. 5Lowell, “Eye of the French Revolution,” chap. 3, par. 3. ↩
  6. 6Thiers, “History of the French Revolution,” Vol. I, pages 82, 83. ↩
  7. 7Ibid., pages 119, 120. ↩
  8. 8Dan. ii : 39. ↩
  9. 9Mignet, “History of the French Revolution.” ↩