DISTINCTION OF LAW IN CHRIST'S TEACHINGS.
By M. E. Kellogg
SINCE the Old Testament makes so plain a distinction between the law given directly by God to Israel, and the law given to Israel through Moses, it is natural and reasonable to conclude that the same distinction will be observed in the New Testament; and so it is. Since the Jews as a people failed to come up to the privilege given them by God, and from the time of their final rejection of Christ have ceased to stand in that relation to God that they enjoyed before that time, we shall expect that all that system of law which related to the Jews as a nation will pass away with the passing away of their national existence. Again, in relation to Old-Testament laws and ceremonies of law which had been introduced as illustrating the remedial system, which revealed and enforced no moral principles, but only pointed to some function or work of Christ for man, we may also expect that at some time during Christ's ministry, or the ministry of his inspired apostles, whose words and works were recorded as a guide for the church in succeeding ages, there will be statements depreciating such laws as no longer of use. And further, since moral principles are in their very nature immutable and everlasting, constituting the very foundation of the righteous government of God, we shall expect to find, in the New Testament, evidence that such laws are not abolished by the more perfect development of the gospel which Christ introduced in the world by his incarnation. All these very natural and reasonable expectations are realized as we study the New Testament. Among the first of Christ's public utterances is the sermon on the mount. In that sermon occurs the following statement: “Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in nowise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” Matt. 5:17–19. Upon this scripture the Gospel Advocate says: “While Christ said he came not to destroy the law and the prophets, he did say he came to fulfil them. And it is certain that he did what he came to do. Hence the law was completely fulfilled in all its demands by the Son of God himself, and was then by him taken out of the way.” Notice the claim here made that the law was not destroyed, but taken out of the way! This is certainly a distinction without a difference! For if it is “taken out of the way,” so that it is no longer a rule of life, then it is virtually destroyed. That the law here referred to is the law of ten commandments, which has been shown, in a previous article, to be pre eminently the law of God, there is no doubt; for in immediate connection with the words above quoted, Christ refers to the sins of murder and adultery (verses 21, 27), which well-known sins are condemned by the sixth and seventh precepts of that law. What did Christ do to this law? He certainly kept it himself. By so doing he fulfilled, or filled it full,—he met its full requirement. But did this release those who should afterward believe on him from doing the same? If so, Christ's fulfilment of the law is a permission to his followers to break it,—to do what he did not do. In other words, faith in Christ gives license to sin! That this is not the idea contained in this scripture is proved by the words of Christ in immediate connection. The sixth commandment may be broken by hatred, and the seventh by lustful desires; but if the law forbidding these sins is “taken out of the way,” the absence of law on these points proclaims such actions not sinful; for since “sin is the transgression of the law” (1 John 3:4), there can be no sin without law. In fact, in this very suggestion of Christ that the law can be broken in the heart, the perpetuity of the law, in its most deep and spiritual demands, is taught. A law “taken out of the way” would not still condemn outward violations of it, much less the inward striving of unhallowed desires. What Christ really did to the law, in these words in Matt. 5:17–28, as in much other of his teaching, was to fulfil an ancient prediction made in regard to his work. Here is the prophecy: “The Lord is well pleased for his righteousness’ sake; he will magnify the law, and make it honorable.” Isa. 42:21. What will Christ do to the law? Will he belittle it and take it out of the way?—No, indeed. He will magnify it and make it honorable. Here are some definitions of the word “magnify:” “To increase the apparent size; to exalt in description or praise; extol; glorify.” This is what Christ did to that law of which the sixth and seventh commandments are a part, and these commandments are evidently taken as representative of the whole law. If the fulfilment, or full performance, of a moral requirement by Christ, takes that requirement away, then there are no more requirements remaining; for all such requirements were fulfilled by him. Not only is the Sabbath gone, but all moral requirements are “taken out of the way.” To say that other and exactly similar requirements are introduced in respect to any portion of God's moral law is the height of absurdity. A moral requirement precisely like another moral requirement is not another, but the same thing. That the word “fulfil,” when applied to a moral requirement, does not have the sense of taking it away, is clearly proved by the meaning of the original word translated “fulfil” in Matt. 5:17. Several Greek words, having quite dissimilar meanings are translated in English by the word “fulfil.” Among these are the words anaplero and pleroo, which are different forms196 of the same verb. These words are thus defined: “To fill up; to fill; to make full.” One of these words is used in the following places: Matt. 3:15; 5:17; Rom. 13:8; Col. 4:17. The reader will notice that Matt. 5:17 is in this list. A careful study of all these texts will convince any reasonable person that the word “fulfil,” as so used, cannot mean to take away or to abolish in any way. If so, then righteousness is to be abolished (Matt. 3:15); loving another abolishes the law (Rom. 13:8); and for a minister to carry out in his life the duties of his office, destroys those duties,—takes them out of the way. Col. 4:17. What shall be said, then, of the word “fulfil” in Matt. 5:17? The only thing that can be truthfully said in relation to this point is that Christ truly kept the law of which he was speaking; that he magnified it by his teaching, that it took hold of man's inmost thoughts; and that by his life of perfect obedience to it, he filled it full,—did all that it required of him,—and by his death in the sinner's place, showed that the law could not and cannot be broken with impunity. In all this there is not a hint that he removed, or took away, the law as a convincer of sin, or as a rule of just and loving obedience. The words of Christ in Matt. 19:16–19 also prove that Christ taught the perpetuity of the law of ten commandments. To the young man, Jesus said, “Keep the commandments;” and he indicated the code of law referred to by quoting from the precepts of the law of ten commandments. That he did not here distinctly mention the fourth commandment is no more proof that he did not design it to be observed, than his failure here to mention the commandments relating to idolatry and profanity releases men from these just demands. The word “which,” as used in this connection, probably means which code of law, rather than which precept of the ten-commandment law; and the reference by Christ to the precepts of the ten-commandment law that the young man was the most liable to break, was an authoritative expression of Christ's mind in reference to the law of which the Sabbath is a part. The young man had not really kept these commandments, as was evinced by his failure to stand the test in regard to the law against covetousness, which Christ brought to bear upon him.