AdventAI

In the Question Chair.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 14., April 6, 1897

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

760.—THE GIFT OF ETERNAL LIFE — TRANSUBSTANTIATION.

1. Is the gift of eternal life bestowed upon the righteous in this probationary state, or not until the resurrection? 2. Do the bread and wine at the Lord’s Supper undergo a change so that they become truly to the believer, the flesh and blood of the Saviour? M. S. W.

Ans.—(1) That depends upon what one means by eternal life. Eternal life, in its absolute sense, is life eternal; that is, a life which has no end, and is subject to no interruptions. But such a life no one in our present state of being possesses; for all are subject to death. We have in this state eternal life only as we have Christ; and we have him by his Spirit which dwelleth in us (Rom. 8:10, 11), by the new man, the new nature, which we receive by the regeneration of the Holy Spirit (Eph. 4:22-24), by Christ in us the hope of glory (Col. 1:27), and by an abiding faith in him. Gal. 2:20. But all this we may at any time lose by apostasy, and so the continuity of this condition be broken, and in many cases absolutely lost. But while we have the life of the Son, so long as we have, and in the same sense that we have, the Son himself, this being conditional on our part, the eternity of this life is in the Son alone, till we pass our probation and are confirmed therein by the bestowment of immortality. Let John explain in his first epistle the expressions he makes on this subject in his gospel. He says: “And this is the record, that God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son. He that hath the Son hath life, and he that hath not the Son of God hath not life.” 1 John 5:11, 12. This is a plain and simple proposition, and one that ought not to be misunderstood. So Paul says that if we, by patient continuance in well-doing, seek for glory and honor and immortality, God will render eternal life (Rom. 2:6, 7), or will confirm us in a never-ending existence, as we are not confirmed, while as sincere Christians we are seeking for it, in this, our probationary state. The danger of the view some are adopting on this subject is already seen in a communication received at this Office, suggesting that the eternal life which we have now does not cease at the death of the body, but is the life which sleeps in the grave, and the one which will hear the voice of the Son of God, and awake in the resurrection. The very next step in this direction will be the view that this life does not sleep at all, but that the dead are conscious. Then alas for the darkness and deceptions to which such will be exposed! (2) No. If the doctrine of transubstantiation is true, we might as well go over to Romanism at once. We eat Christ’s flesh and drink his blood by living hisp. 218 life here among men, more than by partaking of the emblems, though this is a good figure of it. All the expressions of Christ, such as, “This is my body which is broken for you,” and, “This is my blood, which is shed for many,”—expressions which refer to his death on the cross,—were spoken before he had yet died on the cross, showing that they were used symbolically. So Paul sets the matter forth in its true light in 1 Cor. 11:26, when he says: “For as often as ye eat [not the flesh of Christ, but] this bread, and drink [not the actual blood of Christ, but] this cup, ye do show the Lord’s death till he come.” Then what we eat is bread, and what we drink is the cup (or the fruit of the vine in the cup), not the actual flesh and blood of Christ. And by this we show (katanggello, “announce,” “proclaim”) the Lord’s death (or our faith in his sufferings and death and the glory that is to follow, 1 Peter 1:11) till he come.

761.—BUYING A SWORD.

What was our Saviour’s meaning, or what principle did he wish to inculcate by the words recorded in Luke 22:36: “He that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one”? O. W.

Ans.—The reference was undoubtedly to the changed condition into which the disciples would enter when he should be taken away from them. Understanding him to speak of literal swords, they immediately replied, “Lord, behold, here are two swords. And he said unto them, It is enough.” This shows that he had no reference to literal swords, and not the slightest intention to advise his people to use carnal weapons in self-defense; for in such case only two swords would have amounted to nothing. But he could very fittingly use the purse and scrip and sword as symbols of the preparation of heart they would need, to stand in scenes of neglect and opposition into which they were soon to enter. Had they understood his words, they would undoubtedly have read in them this lesson: You will now need to be as well fortified spiritually for your work as a man in ordinary life would be literally by providing a purse and scrip for his support, and a sword for his defense.

762.—ISAIAH 61:5.

This passage reads: “And strangers shall stand and feed your flocks, and the sons of the alien shall be your plowmen and your vinedressers.” We learn from Eph. 2:12 who the strangers and aliens are. When, therefore, does Isa. 61:5 have its application? H. B. F.

Ans.—This was written ninety-two years before the beginning of the seventy years’ captivity, and one hundred and sixty-two years before its close. The most natural application would be to consider it a promise of the wonderful prosperity that should attend Israel after their deliverance. Instead of themselves serving the Gentiles as they did during the seventy years’ captivity, the tables would be turned, and Gentiles should be their servants. As to their being allowed to work upon the Sabbath, the commandment especially specifies that the stranger within thy gates shall rest as well as thou.

763.—THE BOOK OF MORMON.

Isa. 29:11-14 and Eze. 37:16-22 are claimed by Mormons as prophecies of the Book of Mormon. Will you please notice these scriptures in the Question Chair? T. L. S.

Ans.—There is no end to the follies of fanaticism; and unbalanced minds are ever prone to wander off into such vagaries. The scriptures referred to could just as well be applied to the Koran or the books of any other false movement that has ever arisen. The passage first quoted is evidently a prophecy of how Israel in their apostasy would treat the word of the Lord; and the last foretells the union the Lord will finally cause to exist among his people, symbolized by two sticks, each containing the name of one division, being joined together in one. There is just as much reason to apply the passages to the witch-doctors of Africa as to the Mormons. If any are anxious for some prophecies applying to Mormonism, they will find them in such scriptures as Matt. 7:22 and 24:26. U. S.