How to Study the Child: Discipline and Consequences
By Mrs. S. M. I. Henry
HOW TO STUDY THE CHILD.—NO. 4.
BY MRS. S. M. I. HENRY.
(Sanitarium.)
As long as sin exists, there will be disobedience, and the necessity of maintaining authority, but whose authority? There must be government, but who shall govern? There must be discipline, by punishment and reward, but by whom? The solution of the problem turns on the answer to these questions. No two children can be justly treated alike as to rewards and punishment. In the government of God there are diversities of consequences as well as of gifts. One man can be made to suffer only231through the mind, another through the body, until from this suffering the whole being has become sensitive and responsive. I have seen a drunkard who cared nothing for shame and dishonor in the sight of men, but only for the painful physical reaction from a debauch. Just as soon as he became sick, he wanted help to reform,—until the next time,—while another would be so burdened with mental anguish at the thought of his degradation, that he would suffer alone in some back alley, field, or any hiding-place, until it was over. Little is to be hoped of either class until the whole man, body, soul, and spirit, shall come under the pain of consequences, as God has foreordained them, and so work toward true repentance and faith.
Those to whom God has entrusted the care of children cannot afford to allow personal feelings to prevent the attainment of the desired result in discipline. This desired result is character, and the only process by which it can be obtained is self-government. Self-government is a science, which must be carefully taught, and as carefully acquired by the most constant practise. The father and mother should, under God, be the instructors, themselves taught of him hour by hour, that they may be able, by well-ordered lives, as well as by the word of God, to teach and lead the children.
A system of rewards and punishments is necessarily a constituent part of any plan of government, and is of such a nature that it must be kept in the hand of the ruling power. Parents under the government of God are appointed to administer for him, never for themselves; and so must learn the divine method, which is so different from man’s that it is not easily comprehended. Rewards are always out of proportion to punishments. God as a ruler abounds in rewards; man, in penalties. God bestows larger and better than merit calls for; man, more and sharper severity. To know how, and in what proportion, to distribute both, is a study worthy of a statesman, and more necessary in the family than in the state.
As a rule, discipline by suitable reward is more effective than by penalty, especially if the beginnings have been right between parent and child. To cultivate all that is kindly, pure, and sweet in mind and heart, is of the greatest importance; but this alone will not meet the emergency. Since the seeds of sin are there, they will appear in some ugly form, in spite of all that can be done, until by his own consecration and acceptance of Christ, the child shall be born again to newness of life; and some provision must be made to meet probable wrong-doing, so that a crisis shall find the parents agreed, and at one with God. Penalty should follow such wrong-doing in the case of the young child as quickly as possible; for his memory is not able to hold the relation of cause and effect, and if this connection is lost sight of by him, it will be worse than useless for him to suffer for his act. If the parent is angry, he is in no condition even to notice the act without danger. Anger cuts him off from God, who only can teach him how to meet the need of the hour.
Punishment should never be administered by the parent; that is not his prerogative. God does not allow it, and will only bring good out of it through crucifixion and needless loss. “Vengeance belongeth unto me,” says the Lord. Man is not capable of punishing justly; and injustice is the most cruel wrong. One human being has no more right to punish another than has one child in a family to punish his fellow. Failure to recognize this is the point at which all failure begins. There can be no success in the home without the blessing of God, and no one who crowds himself into the seat of authority, and so seeks to crowd God out, can expect him to crown this usurpation with salvation, much less if the usurper professes to be a follower of Christ. God will forbear much more with those who are wholly in the dark than with those who are known as light-bearers. Instead of punishment by any human power, the penalty which God made inevitable should be taught the children, and then they should be left to him alone. We must do this sometime, and the sooner the better.
Sin tends to desolation. As we count duration, it seems a long while coming; but though it tarry, such is its ultimate end. Let the disobedient child find what this means as soon as possible, before he is old enough to despair and become reckless. Do not shut him up alone to make him sense this desolation. That is to treat him like a criminal. In an extreme case it may be necessary; but leave that treatment for the extremest case of rebellion. First try to understand the motive of the act. You may find that while the act is all wrong, the motive was perfectly pure and true. In that case it is only necessary to teach him how to do properly that which he had in mind. Correct the fault with the utmost tenderness and love, showing him the wrong clearly, but making him feel that the eyes of your love can read the intention which lies back of the error, and appreciate it for all it is worth. Think of angrily slapping a child for pulling up a plant, however rare and costly, that he might bring it to the mother! See him with his two little hands holding it carefully, his face beaming with joy, because he has found such a beautiful gift for her. See the mother’s angry face, hear the blow, and then cease to wonder if the child grows up hateful and wayward. Much of human punishment is more or less after this unfortunate order. What seems to be an overt act of disobedience, aggravated by impudence, may be simply a reproduction of some scene which the parents have enacted before the child. A disagreement which he re-enacted with vivid impersonations has brought many an innocent little student of life into trouble. He has received punishment for doing the very things, saying the very words, in the very same tone, which he had heard from those of whom he must learn his lessons in living.
In any case let the child have a chance to explain without fear. You should be able to study the reason for his conduct, because the results may be tremendous. He may be stubborn, or for some cause unable to explain at once; give him time. Win his confidence, and when he has explained as well as he can, or if he refuses, and you have become sure that his conduct must be visited with penalty, come away and leave him alone. He may follow you; do not notice it,—this is his privilege,—but take your work and the other children, and leave him again, and again, and again, if it takes a whole day, or if it takes a week, and you have to travel over the whole house, and if the work has to be neglected. Teach him once thoroughly that if he will refuse to come into harmony with the true life, he must sooner or later live alone. If you begin early enough, a few moments will suffice so to enforce this truth that it will take root, and bear the peaceable fruits of right-doing; especially if you are wise and true enough to teach it from God’s word, in connection with the blessed gospel, which is sweet with the fellowship of Christ. A mischievous boy, who was always provoking quarrels by meddling and annoying the other children, was cured by this process in a short time. No child likes loneliness. Homesickness is deadly; and as a penalty, being God’s own institution, is unequaled.
Every child must learn for himself where danger lies, and how to avoid it. Your experience will not even warn him; he must learn by his own.
In a certain home there was an open fire and a baby girl. It was before the days of fire-screens. The coals were continually popping out onto the hearth, and the child would always run to try to pick them up, while some one else would run to snatch her away, crying, “Burnie! burnie!” which was to her simply another way of playing and caressing, until one morning the father said, “Let her alone. She must learn to protect herself.” So she was allowed to go on toward the fire. She lifted her little hand to her face as she felt the heat, but did not much more than pause. The opportunity was hers at last; she would improve it, and get the desire of her eyes. On she went, and seized the coveted jewel that lay crackling and sparkling on the hearth. Just an instant of surprise,—then a bitter cry, and a fall into the arms that were waiting to close about her and comfort her. It was severe, but the lesson was fastened, as with nails, in a sure place.
A wilful child cried in anger, “I will run away; I don’t love you any more.”
He went unhindered, but followed by watchful, loving eyes. Messages to neighbors closed all doors against him. He wandered about, until, weary and homesick, he lay down beside the fence, and fell asleep. When he awoke, he found himself in the world alone, with nothing left to do but repent and return to his father’s house.
If a child has the heart of a prodigal within him, it is well that he find it, as well as its cure, as early as possible, before his legs grow long and strong enough to carry him so far that he will never find his way back.