AdventAI

“A GREAT DISCOVERY.”

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 15., April 13, 1897

THIS name, as all our readers are aware, is the title which is given to a new theory on the Sabbath question, lately introduced by S. W. Gamble, a minister in the South Kansas Conference of the M. E. Church. We have been requested to review briefly his claims, pointing out the error of his premises and the incorrectness of his conclusions. His article appeared first in the Chicago Tribune of Monday, Dec. 28, 1896, from advance sheets of the Christian Endeavor, in which paper it appeared in January, 1897. The whole scheme seemed so utterly fallacious that but little attention was given to it in the REVIEW, on the ground that when brought face to face with the ordinary intelligence of the Christian world, its weakness would be apparent, and it would soon disappear from view. As, however, it seems to be hailed by so many as the long-looked-for evidence on which to set aside the claims of the seventh day, although it utterly demolishes all preceding theories on that side of the question,—theories which have been claimed to rest upon such clear evidence and upon such plain testimony of the Bible,—it may be well to give it further notice, not as a matter of contention or in a spirit of controversy, but simply to show wherein it is contrary to facts, and out of harmony with the sacred record.

In response to the foregoing request, we therefore offer a few additional thoughts upon the subject.

It will be sufficient to examine the three principal propositions embraced in the theory, upon which all the others depend. These are, (1) That the Sabbath was given to the Jews alone to commemorate their deliverance from Egyptian bondage; (2) That the Sabbath was always the 15th of Abib, and the day following was the first day of a new week, thus making the weekly cycle depend on the day of the month, and making the Sabbath come on all the different days of the week successively, in different years; (3) That there was in the year one week of eight days, in which two Sabbaths came together, and the whole calendar was set forward one day.

Let us bestow a few thoughts upon each of these points, in their order:—

1. The Sabbath was not given to Israel to commemorate their deliverance from Egyptian bondage. The reasons for this position are various: (a) The Sabbath was instituted at creation, two thousand years and more before a Jew existed, and twenty-five hundred years before the deliverance from Egypt. How and when the Sabbath was instituted is clearly stated in Gen. 2:2, 3, and reiterated in the fourth commandment; it was at the creation, when God rested upon the first seventh day of time, and then blessed and set apart that day; and for whom it was made, Christ emphatically declares, when he says that the Sabbath was made for man, the whole human family, and not the Jew merely. Mark 2:27. (b) The Passover was given expressly to Israel to commemorate their deliverance from Egypt; and the Lord never gives two memorials of the same event. Such an instance cannot be found. Ex. 12:14. (c) When God declared the Sabbath from Sinai, and gave the reasons for it, in the third month after their departure from Egypt, he said nothing about the deliverance from Egypt, but referred back to the events of creation, in which all the inhabitants of the world have a common interest. Ex. 20:8–11. (d) But did not Moses say, “And remember that thou wast a servant in the land of Egypt, and that the Lord thy God brought thee out thence, through a mighty hand and by a stretched out arm: therefore the Lord thy God commanded thee to keep the Sabbath day”?—Yes; and to this text Mr. Gamble flies with all haste, as every opposer of the seventh day has done before him. But he surpasses all his predecessors, and makes a most surprising declaration, to which we now call the attention of the reader. He says: “The ten commandments copied into the book of Deuteronomy are the real copy of the two tables; for Moses says, ‘These words the Lord spake, . . . and he added no more. And he wrote them in two tables of stone, and delivered them unto me.’ Deut. 5:22. . . . The ten commandments in Exodus 20 were written by Moses before he went up into the mount to get the tables; hence they are not a copy of the tables.” (Italics ours.) This declaration we have never before seen put forth. How Mr. Gamble knows that Moses wrote Exodus 20 before he received the tables,p. 233 at the close of his forty days’ interview with the Lord, he does not tell us. But Moses does undertake to tell us in Exodus 20, just what words the Lord proclaimed from Mount Sinai. Did he make a mistake, and give us something the Lord did not proclaim? Did not the Lord write upon the tables just what he spoke audibly from the mount, no more, no less? and did he speak anything different, more or less, from what is recorded in Ex. 20:2–17? In amazement again we ask, Has Moses given us an imperfect record of that matter? and did the people not know what the tables contained till Moses gave his recital forty years later, as recorded in the book of Deuteronomy?

The various events recorded in Exodus,—the proclamation of the law from Sinai, the giving of the tables to Moses, the apostasy of Israel, the breaking of the tables by Moses, the preparation of new tables, the writing upon them by the Lord the same words that were in the first tables, the preparation of the ark for the reception of these tables, the erection of the tabernacle, and the whole orderly arrangement of the worship of Israel,—are all ascribed to the year in which they came out of Egypt.

Forty years elapsed before the rehearsal of their experience by Moses, as recorded in the book of Deuteronomy. Bearing this fact in mind, the language of Deuteronomy 5 becomes very simple and clear. Among other remarkable occurrences in their history he would not fail to mention the giving of the law by the voice of God, which no other people had ever heard. He gives an epitome of the law, largely in the language the Lord himself had employed, but accompanied with exhortations and comments of his own, and repeated reference to the time when the Lord had given them these commandments. It is simply a narrative, and as such could have had no place upon the tables in the form here given. “The Lord talked with you” (verse 4); “I stood between the Lord and you at that time,” etc. Verse 5. Their minds were carried back to the time when God spoke the law in their hearing, as recorded in Exodus 20, with whose words they were familiar to the fullest extent; for Moses was given charge faithfully to teach them. Ex. 24:12. When he comes to the Sabbath commandment, he says, “Keep the Sabbath day to sanctify it, as the Lord thy God hath commanded thee.” Think of these words being on the tables! Whatever was on the tables constituted the supreme law; but here reference is made to something previously commanded, as the reason for this injunction. Imagine, then, a supreme law, referring back for its authority to some antecedent law! It is impossible. These words, from the very nature of the case, could have had no place upon the tables. This is simply a rehearsal by Moses, and the words “hath commanded,” refer to what the Lord had proclaimed in awful majesty from Sinai, forty years before.

Coming down to that part of the commandment which insures the man servant and maid servant rest (verse 15), Moses introduces an independent thought, as shown by the words, “And remember that thou wast a servant in the land of Egypt.” For this cause they had special reason to keep the Sabbath, and give their servants rest, because God had delivered them from the house of bondage by his mighty power. Again, in verse 16, he says, “Honor thy father and thy mother, as the Lord thy God hath commanded thee.” This, then, had been commanded at some previous time. When and where?—On Sinai, forty years before. But does it not say, “Therefore the Lord thy God commanded thee to keep the Sabbath day”?—Very true; but do not overlook the peculiarity of the language, even here. It does not say, “Therefore the Lord thy God now institutes and ordains for you a Sabbath day;” but it only says, “commanded you to keep it.” Then the Sabbath had been made before, and was there for them to keep. Where had it been made and commanded?—At creation; and the commandment reiterated on Sinai to Israel, forty years before, had given the great facts on which the institution itself was based. In Exodus 20 we have the original law, exactly as God spoke it, and exactly as it read on the tables of stone; and all denominations recognize this fact; for they invariably quote from this record when giving a copy of the decalogue.

Should any still persist that the language of Deut. 5:15 gives the only reason for the institution of the Sabbath, and shows that no others were under obligation to keep it except those who had had the experience there recorded, let them remember that they thereby confine all moral obligation to Israel alone; for all the other commandments are spoken of in precisely the same manner. (See Deut. 24:17–22; Lev. 19:35–37.) This latter reference is very comprehensive: “I am the Lord your God, which brought you out of the land of Egypt. Therefore shall ye observe all my statutes, and all my judgments, and do them: I am the Lord.” The same argument that is used on Deut. 5:15 in reference to the Sabbath, applied to this text, would show, if true, that only the Jews were under any moral obligation whatever! But this would be a charge against the government of God, which we trust that none will be reckless enough, or thoughtless enough, to prefer.

It was certainly very consistent and very appropriate that Moses, in his farewell address, rehearsing their wonderful experiences, should appeal to their sense of gratitude to induce them to be faithful to God, and to show that the Lord himself considered that by his special blessings to them, he had placed them under peculiar obligations to be faithful in the observance of the Sabbath, and in keeping all his commandments; and can it be anything less than a perversion of his words to try to show from them that no others were under obligation to him? When Moses said, “These words the Lord spake” (Deut. 5:22), their minds would rest alone on the law which they had heard from Sinai, enough of which he had repeated to make clear to what he referred. Other points will be noticed next week.

U. S.