AdventAI

On the Question Chair.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 16., April 20, 1897

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

765.—HE AFTERWARD HUNGERED.

Please harmonize the statement on page 7 of “The Sufferings of Christ,” that “for nearly six weeks the Son of God endured the agonies of hunger,” with Luke 4:2, which says that, the forty days being ended, “he afterward hungered.” J. C. P.

Ans.—We understand it to be simply a question of degrees. During the whole forty days, according to the reading, the devil pressed upon Christ his temptations, and during all this time he would feel the pangs of hunger in the natural physical degree; but at last Satan, preparing a temptation upon that very point, would bring all his power to bear upon him to intensify to their fullest extent the pangs of hunger in his exhausted condition; and to this crisis Luke 4:2 doubtless refers. This point is illustrated by the words of Christ to his disciples just before the last supper (Luke 22:15): “And he said unto them, With desire I have desired to eat this Passover with you before I suffer.” This last expression doubtless refers to his crucifixion; but had he not suffered before?—Yes, all through his ministry, having not where to lay his head, and being oftentimes oppressed with weariness, thirst, and hunger. But the garden and the cross so far surpassed all other experiences that they faded out, and this could be spoken of as the time when he should suffer.

766.—THE EIGHTH DAY.

I handed a copy of “How the Sabbath Came to Me,” to a friend, and in reply he referred me to Eze. 43:27. Will you please give a full explanation of that passage? R. B. H.

Ans.—We presume our readers will readily call to mind the statements of the passage in question. It gives the conclusion of a ceremony by which an altar, designed for burnt-offerings, was to be purified and prepared for service. The acts of dedication were to be kept up for seven days; and on the eighth day the altar would be ready for their offerings, and thenceforward would be devoted to its legitimate uses. And this fact is gravely brought forward to prove that the seventh-day Sabbath was sometime to be abolished, and the first day of the week to be put in its place as a day of rest. We have often wondered what could be the mental constitution of a man who could think that such a passage was put into the Bible as evidence of a change of the Sabbath, and what kind of cerebral process was involved in arriving at the conclusion that here is a prophecy of Sunday as a day of rest. The eighth day spoken of is the eighth day of what? Of the week?—No, for a week has only seven days; and the day following the seventh day is not an eighth day of that week; for that has ended, and the day would be the first day of a new week. The idea that a period of only seven days could have an eighth day, is a part of Sunday’s metaphysical museum. Then when it reads, “Upon the eighth day, and so forward,” what do the words “so forward” mean? Do they mean every eighth day after that? Then the week would be changed from seven days to eight days in length. Or does it mean “on the eighth day, and so forward,” every seventh day after that? The whole record is simply a statement that seven days should be occupied in the purification of an altar, no matter where in the week they might begin or end, at some time when the services of the Jewish economy were in force, and on the eighth day, and “so forward,”—that is, every day after that,—the altar could properly be used, and the Lord would accept their sacrifices. It has not the remotest reference to the week or to the Sabbath.

767.—HOW TO ANSWER.

How should we answer: 1. A Catholic when he quotes, “This is my body,” to prove transubstantiation? 2. An infidel when he quotes Isa. 13:16; Hosea 13:16, to pick flaws? 3. A United Presbyterian when he claims that we should use only an inspired psalmody (to wit, the Psalms in meter)? 4. A Disciple when he argues baptism as equally essential as repentance, to the remission of sins? J. F. B.

Ans.—(1) Ask him how the bread which Christ said “is given” (Luke 22:19), or as Paul has it, “is broken” (1 Cor. 11:24), could be the real body of Christ before that body was broken; for Christ had not then been crucified; likewise how could the wine be the real blood of Christ, which he said “is shed,” before his blood had been poured out upon the cross. Moreover, Christ himself sets the matter in the true light when he says, after giving them the cup (Matt. 26:29), “I will not drink henceforth of [what? his blood, or my blood?—No; but] *this fruit of thep. 250 vine.” He could hardly have said more plainly that the bread was bread, but a symbol of his body; and the cup (after he had given thanks and so changed it, if it ever was changed) was “the fruit of the vine,” but a symbol of his blood, which was soon to be shed for mankind. But this is not all. Paul, twenty-eight years afterward (1 Cor. 11:26, 27), rehearsing the institution of the Lord’s Supper, said: “For as often as ye eat [what? the real body of the Lord, made by the blasphemous pretensions of a priest out of bread?—No, but] this bread, and drink [what? the actual blood of Christ made by the same act of presumption out of wine?—No, but] this cup, ye do show the Lord’s death till he come.” This shows that neither Paul nor the Christians of his time had learned that the elements used in the eucharist were anything else but bread and the fruit of the vine*, used, of course, as symbols of the body and blood of Christ. (2) The passages referred to in Isaiah and Hosea are simply a prediction of the dire calamities that were to come upon the people. The Lord did not order them, nor sanction them, and was in no-wise responsible for them; but the calamities were coming, and those terrible acts were to be done, and the Lord simply warned the people by making the fact known to them. But the infidel, with his usual lack of discrimination, tries to throw upon the Lord the blame of everything that he simply foretells. (3) Tell him that you, too, think it would be a good thing; that is, if you do think so, as we see no objection for doing; but if not, you can tell him why. (4) Tell him that you also regard baptism as a very important Christian duty, on no account to be omitted, if circumstances permit. But while a person cannot be saved without repentance, if circumstances are such that he cannot possibly perform the outward ordinance of baptism, that certainly should not debar him from the kingdom. That would be to make his salvation depend on circumstances over which he has no control. “It is accepted according to that a man hath, and not according to that he hath not.” The dying thief repented and was saved; but he was never baptized.

U. S.