Second and Concluding Paper.
In the further examination of Mr. Gamble’s “Great Discovery” on the Sabbath question, we come now to the second point which it was proposed to consider; namely, “That the 15th of Abib was always the Sabbath, and the day following was the first day of a new week, thus making the weekly cycle depend on the day of the month, and making the Sabbath come on all the different days of the week successively in different years.”
We know that the first thought in the mind of the intelligent reader will be that we must have misquoted Mr. Gamble here; that no man would seriously put forth such a proposition as that. We will therefore let him speak for himself.
In the Christian Endeavorer, January, 1897, page 8, speaking of the count from the wave-sheaf to the Pentecost, as directed in Lev. 23: 15, 16, he says that “the count to begin on ‘the morrow after the Sabbath,’ began on Abib 16; hence Abib 16 was the first day of the week, and Abib 15, ‘the Sabbath,’ and Moses says (Lev. 23: 41), ‘It shall be a statute forever in your generations.’”
Again: same page, Mr. Gamble gives a “general statement” of his views, which we will also quote, that the reader may have no question as to his position:—
The weekly Sabbaths of the Jews commemorated their freedom from Egyptian slavery, which occurred on Abib 15.
Each week contained six days, which were considered secular, although one of them might be a “holy day, or Sabbath.”
Each week contained one or two Sabbaths.
The first day of the week was the day which immediately followed the single or double weekly Sabbath.
The week, including the day of Pentecost, contained eight days. The first six were secular, and the last two were Sabbath days, each.
The first proposition in the foregoing series; namely, that the Sabbath was given to commemorate the deliverance from Egypt, was examined last week. The remainder, we imagine, will strike the reader as a very singular chronological mixture, involving several before-unheard-of mysteries! 1. A week is usually understood to be a period of just seven complete days, independent of all other cycles,—six working days and one Sabbath. How one of the six secular days may be a “holy day, or Sabbath,” does not appear. 2. How there can be two Sabbaths in one week, when, according to the Bible, the weekly Sabbath must follow six days of labor, does not appear. 3. How there can be a week of eight days, when the word “week” means a period of just seven days, does not appear. These three propositions were never before heard of; and if they are true, they are indeed a “great discovery.”
The point on which Mr. Gamble is misled, and which is the source of all his confusion, is very apparent. He takes the word “sabbath” to mean in every instance the weekly Sabbath of the decalogue; whereas every Bible student should know that there were seven days in the year, connected with the Jewish festivals, which, by outward observances were regarded as sabbaths, and were designated by that term. The first and seventh days of the Passover festival were such days. They were marked by a “holy convocation,” or religious gathering, and a total cessation from secular labor. Lev. 23: 7, 8. The Pentecost, fifty days thereafter, was the third day of this kind, observed in the same manner. Verse 21. The first day of the seventh month was the fourth annual sabbath (verses 24, 25); the tenth day of the seventh month was the fifth (verses 27–32); and the first and eighth days of the feast of tabernacles (verses 34, 39), constituted the sixth and seventh of these yearly sabbaths. But these sabbaths had no connection whatever with the weekly Sabbath, which was a Sabbath of a different nature, and rested upon a different basis. So Moses, after enumerating these seven yearly sabbaths, distinctly separates them from the weekly Sabbath, by saying (Lev. 23: 38), “Besides the Sabbaths of the Lord.” These annual sabbaths are the ones which are called her (Jerusalem’s) sabbaths, the cessation of which was predicted by Hosea. Hosea 1: 11. These are the ones which alone were connected with meats, drinks, holy days, and new moons, which the apostle tells us, in Col. 2: 14–17, were the “handwriting of ordinances,” and “shadows of things to come,” and were by Christ nailed to his cross. But all this in no wise affected the weekly Sabbath of the Lord.
Another point of which Mr. Gamble should be aware is that, inasmuch as the Sabbath marks and governs the week, the word “Sabbath” came to be used as a name for the week; and the Jews designated the different days in the week by calling them the first, second, third, etc., days “of the Sabbath.” The leading Hebrew and Greek lexicographers, like Gesenius, Liddell and Scott, Robinson, etc., note this fact. An illustration is found in Luke 18: 12, where the Pharisee says, “I fast twice in the week,” and where the word translated “week” is “Sabbath.”
Had Mr. Gamble kept this fact in mind, he would not have been misled as he has been by the language of Lev. 23: 15, in regard to the Pentecost. The “seven sabbaths” to be counted from the wave-sheaf to the Pentecost, do not mean seven weekly sabbaths at all, but only seven weeks. On the morrow after the seventh complete week, came the Pentecost, being the fiftieth day from the offering of the wave-sheaf. Thus, on the 14th of Abib the Passover lamb was slain; the 15th of Abib was the first Sabbath of the Passover festival, no matter on what day of the week it might fall. It was not the weekly Sabbath at all, but only the Passover sabbath. The weekly Sabbath and the Passover sabbath would, of course, once in about every seven years, both fall on the same day, as they did when Christ lay in the tomb, constituting that day “an high day.” John 19: 31.
The “morrow after the sabbath,” mentioned in Lev. 23: 11, was the 16th of Abib, the day following the Passover sabbath of the 15th; and on this day the sheaf was waved, whatever day of the week it might fall upon. It had nothing to do with the weekly Sabbath, nor in determining the days of the week, but was only an annual ceremony, and fell on different days of the week in different years.
Taking that day as a starting-point, seven complete weeks were to be numbered off, and the day following the seventh complete week was the Pentecost, no matter on what day of the week it might fall. Of course it would always fall on the same day of the week as that on which the sheaf had been waved, seven weeks before. The wave-sheaf was a type of the resurrection of Christ, “the first-fruits [wave-sheaf] of them that slept.” 1 Cor. 15: 20. And as this took place on the first day of the week, the Pentecost also fell, that year, on the first day of the week. But that festival conferred no honor on the day, as a day of the week; for it came consecutively on all days in different years.
The reader can now see the difficulty that Mr. Gamble runs into by his theory, at Pentecost, and why he is obliged to claim that there was one week in the year which had eight days in it, in which two Sabbaths, which ought to be seven days apart, came together. The 15th of Abib, he claims, was always the weekly Sabbath; and “the morrow after the Sabbath,” was always “the first day of the week,” because, as he claims, that expression determined the beginning of the week. So between the 15th of Abib and the Pentecost, the first day of the week was the regular seventh day from the wave-sheaf on the 16th, till the fiftieth day was reached, which was the Pentecost. But this was the first day of the week from the wave-sheaf, the weekly Sabbath, according to his count, coming the day before. So this day was also “the morrow after the Sabbath;” but lo! the Pentecost itself was just as much a Sabbath as Abib 15, and so on to that time. Hence “the morrow after the Sabbath” here becomes another Sabbath, and the morrow after this Sabbath becomes the first day of a new week; and the whole weekly calendar is set one day ahead for the remainder of the year. Thus he finds himself in a quandary what to do with Pentecost; for a week was complete the day before it, and a new week begins the day after it! But it will not do to blot that day out of the year; so he resorts to the daring expedient of joining it to the preceding week, calling that a week of eight days! and as he is obliged to claim that the Pentecost was just as much a Sabbath as the day before, he has no alternative but to say that at that point every year, two Sabbaths came together! Such absurdities, it would seem, ought to be sufficient to lead any man to abandon the theory which makes them necessary.
Under this theory any one can at once see that it would be impossible to keep the Sabbath law. That law says, “Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work: but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” etc. Six days of labor, or time set apart for labor, must therefore precede every Sabbath; but according to this new “discovery,” every year, as the Sabbath changed to another day, the laboring period must be cut short of the six days; and at another point in the year the laboring period before the Sabbath is entirely thrown out, and two Sabbaths come together! God is not the author of confusion.
Again: as Mr. Gamble has the Sabbath inseparably connected with the Jewish festivals, we ask what evidence there is to show that every seventh day in succession should be kept at any time in the year, except at the festivals themselves and between the Passover and Pentecost.
The whole trouble in the theory under examination lies in the fact that Mr. Gamble confoundsp. 249 the weekly Sabbath of the Lord with the ceremonial and annual sabbaths of the Jews. Overlooking this plain Bible distinction, he is obliged to locate the Sabbath by the moon, and make the week conform to the mutations of the month, and then thinks he has made “a great discovery.” But does he believe that any large proportion of intelligent people are going to believe, in the face of all history, that the week has been a variable and shiftable cycle, depending on the changes of the moon? that God gave a command for a Sabbath so ordained that no one could obey the law? and that the week has now become an established cycle by some chronological jugglery, nobody can tell when nor how nor where? Rather, he will find it to be the fact that those who will give his scheme sufficient thought, will soon themselves make “a great discovery;” and that is that this theory is one of the most groundless and preposterous propositions that was ever sprung upon the religious world. U. S.