THAT THAT IS DETERMINED SHALL BE DONE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 27, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 17.

Read the full edition

“THAT THAT IS DETERMINED SHALL BE DONE.”

BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
The massacre of the French priests and nobles by the Septemberers was an awful thing; but the end was not yet. Dire vengeance had been wreaked upon individuals; but the church—the institution itself—still remained. Now the church was the real author of all the woes and miseries of France. The church had led the monarchy into its greatest sins. For the sake of the church, and in her name, the civil power had again and again drawn the sword, and shed the blood of thousands upon thousands of the noblest sons and daughters of the land. At the instigation of the church, the finest artisans in the country had been driven across the borders and beyond the seas to more hospitable shores. Thus a flourishing commerce had been ruined, and the nation impoverished. In order to maintain the church in splendor, the people had been taxed, robbed, and plundered. Thousands had starved in order that abbots and bishops might live in rioting and wantonness. Saints’ days had been multiplied to such an extent, and the people forbidden to work on them, that in many instances it was almost impossible to make a living. At last the time of visitation had arrived; the “indignation” was to be “accomplished,”—that which had been “determined” was to “be done.”
Providence had given the time for 1260 years to the papacy. She had fully entered upon her term of office in the year A. D. 538, and now, in 1793, the point at which her rule must expire was drawing on apace. It had been given her to make war with the saints, and to overcome them, and power had been given her over all kindreds, and tongues, and nations. All this was to cease in 1798. This the prophet had foretold, this the Lord had declared.
Now the church was a corporation. It was a corporation possessing immense wealth. The French Revolution was violently hostile to all corporations, clerical as well as secular. Corporations had been monopolies. The one church corporation had possessed a monopoly in the matter of religion. It had raised the price of religion to the highest figure the people would stand. Finally that article of which all men feel the need had been advanced so much in cost by those controlling it, that they struck, and vowed to put an end to the corporation.
It has been said that a book goes before every revolution. The book which did the most to foster the French Revolution was the “Contrat Social,” by Rousseau. This notable work boldly taught that the state would be better off without a church. This extraordinary, but not to be despised, writer openly declared, “Whatever breaks up social unity is worthless;” and then he added, “Nothing is more opposed to the social spirit than Christianity.” This is all only too true of Roman Catholicism; and Rousseau confounded Roman Catholicism with Christianity. He and the revolutionists cannot be blamed for this, because Roman Catholicism had always palmed itself off as being Christianity. True Christianity is not opposed to the “social spirit.” “Christianity,” said Rousseau, “cannot zealously serve the state, being bound by its conscience to support tyrants.” Its law “preaches only servitude and dependence. . . . It is made for a slave,” and never will a citizen be made out of a slave. “Christian republic,” each of these two words excludes the other.”
It is very true that the Catholic religion, by the principles of “servitude and dependence” which it inculcates, does unfit a man for the duties of citizenship in a republic. Independence of thought and action must be stimulated in the hearts and minds of men, in order to make them good, responsible citizens. Now if a man permits his mind to be controlled by a church; if he believes he must, in religious things, stand in a place of servitude and dependence under other men, his mind necessarily becomes dwarfed to a greater or less extent,—it becomes more or less incapable of independent, responsible action in anything. And this is why Roman Catholic republics have been a failure. Free religion in a free state is a good doctrine; but a servile religion is bound to breed a servile state.
Believing, then, that the Christian—i. e., Catholic—religion was a bad thing for the state and the well-being of the state, the revolutionists determined to abolish it. They declared that the church had been given all its privileges in order that it might benefit the state. It had promised to do this, but had failed to keep the promise. It was therefore fitting that the privileges be taken away, the property confiscated, and the corporation dissolved. This was all logical and right. The Catholic Church herself had many times insisted upon the confiscation of the property of the Protestants, and the annihilation of their religion, on the ground that it was a detriment to the state. All that was now proposed was to apply these same principles to the Roman religion.
The old religion had been enforced upon the ground of authority; the new one was to be set up in the name of Reason. So deeply, however, had the spirit of bigotry and intolerance taken possession of men’s hearts, that the worship of Reason was destined to be enforced with as much rigor as had been Catholicism in former days. It was openly stated: “Whoever presumes to state that there is no salvation out of the church must be driven out of the state.” The new faith was described as a “civil religion;” a catechism, “a profession of faith, of which the sovereign has the right to dictate the articles, not exactly as religious dogmas, but as sentiments of social import, without which we cannot be good citizens or loyal subjects.” “Without forcing any one to believe in this creed, whoever does not believe in it must be expelled from the state; it is necessary to banish such persons, not on account of impiety, but as unsociable beings, incapable of sincerely loving law and justice, and, if need be, of giving up life for duty.” “Should any person, after having publicly assented to these dogmas, act as an unbeliever, let him be punished with death. He has committed the greatest of crimes—he has lied before the law.”
The abolition of the old state religion; the public declaration against Christianity, yea, against the very existence of God; and the formal establishment of the worship of Reason, form by far the most interesting chapter in the annals of that most interesting time.