THOSE DATES AGAIN

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 4, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THOSE DATES AGAIN.

The reader will perhaps remember that an article entitled, “Are the Dates Correct?” appeared in the REVIEW of January 26, in which the dates of the seventy weeks, the fifteenth year of Tiberius Cæsar (Luke 3 : 1), the date of the crucifixion, the end of the seventy weeks in A. D. 34, and the termination of the whole period of the 2300 days of Dan. 8 : 14, in 1844, were clearly established.
The article was a criticism of the position of the “Millennial Dawn” upon these points, showing it to be incorrect in every particular. The organ of the “Millennial Dawn” people, Zion’s Watch Tower, of April 1, makes an effort to recover its position, which is perfectly natural; for no one likes to be left without any ground to stand upon. The better way for it would be to submit gracefully to the facts, and accept the truth. The article referred to closed with these words, to which, more firmly than ever, if possible, we still adhere: “These dates and eras are absolutely unassailable, and can never be overthrown.”
Nevertheless the Watch Tower endeavors to make a show of trying to overthrow them. It admits that its statements in regard to Dionysius Exiguus and the introduction of the Christian era were errors, caused either by “a slip of the editorial pencil, or by the compositor,” but dismisses that matter on the ground that it “has no bearing whatever on the subject.” It has just this bearing: If on a point so well established as the date when the Christian era was introduced, such glaring misstatements could creep in, it weakens confidence in all its other testimony.
But it falls back on the date of the fifteenth year of the reign of Tiberius Cæsar, and rests its whole case on that. It says: “The editor of the Sabbath Herald finds his dates and reckonings all out of harmony with the testimony of Luke 3 : 1–5,—the only positive date given in connection with our Lord’s birth and ministry by which it can be connected with reliable Roman history.”
Not at all, Brother Watch Tower; on the contrary, Luke 3 : 1–5 is the very scripture to which we appeal in support of our contention for the commencement of Christ’s ministry in A. D. 27. Thus Tiberius was associated with his uncle and stepfather Augustus in A. D. 12, two years before the death of the latter in A. D. 14; and Luke dates his reign from his joint rule with Augustus in A. D. 12, and not from his sole reign on the death of Augustus in A. D. 14. Luke was a Jewish writer; and the Jews were accustomed to reckon the reigns of kings in this manner. A conspicuous illustration of this is found in the case of Nebuchadnezzar. Thus Prideaux (Vol. I, page 98) testifies: “In the third year of Jehoiakim, Nabopollasar, king of Babylon, finding that on Necho’s taking of Carchemish, all Syria and Palestine had revolted to him, and that he, being old and infirm, was unable to march thither himself to reduce them, he took Nebuchadnezzar, his son, into partnership with him in the empire, and sent him with an army into those parts; and from hence the Jewish computation of the years of Nebuchadnezzar’s reign begins; that is, from the end of the third year of Jehoiakim; for it was about the end of that year that this was done; and therefore, according to the Jews, the fourth year of Jehoiakim was the first year of Nebuchadnezzar; but according to the Babylonians, his reign is not reckoned to begin till after his father’s death, which happened two years afterward; and both computations being found in Scripture, it is necessary to say so much here for the reconciling of them.”
Now from A. D. 12 the fifteenth year of Tiberius would be A. D. 27, just where the Scriptures, and consequently we, locate it. This is a point so well understood and so generally admitted that we did not deem it necessary to adduce any great amount of proof to substantiate it. We gave only two quotations—one from Merivale’s “History of the Romans,” and the other from Smith’s Bible Dictionary—on this point. But the editor of the Tower will have the reign of Tiberius begin only on the death of Augustus, A. D. 14. He says: “There is not a shadow of doubt as to when Tiberius began his reign (A. D. 14).” He declares that the proofs offered for the other view “are absurd, and find their only strength in the ignorance” of our readers. Now we are very sorry that Merivale and the editor of Smith’s Bible Dictionary are absurd in their statements, and that our readers are so very ignorant.
Merivale says that in A. D. 12 Augustus granted Tiberius a triumph, and clothed him with proconsular powers, which all the people understood as co-sovereignty with Augustus himself. On this the Watch Tower says: “The editor [of the REVIEW] evidently thinks that the words ‘proconsular powers’ will be understood by his readers to mean imperial power—a totally different thing.” O, no, Brother Tower! we only leave our readers free to infer that Merivale told the truth when he said that the act was understood by all the people of that time as equivalent to co-sovereignty with Augustus. Then the editor of the Tower amuses himself by getting down the Standard Dictionary, and giving us the definition of “proconsul” and “proconsular.” We will give him, before we close, some other words to look up in the dictionary.
Again: the Watch Tower, speaking of the statement in Luke 3 : 1–5 that John began his ministry in the fifteenth year of the reign of Tiberius Cæsar, says: “It would be passing strange if he [Luke] would purposely misstate the matter.” Please, Brother Tower, do not here raise a false issue. Nobody questions the correctness of Luke’s statement. It was in the fifteenth year of the reign of Tiberius that John and Christ both commenced their ministries. But the question is, Does Luke date from Tiberius’s joint reign, or from his sole reign? More testimony will be given on this point directly, after one more quotation, as follows: “There is no question in secular histories, as to when ‘the reign of Tiberius Cæsar’ began; the only people to raise a question about it are those who, following the inaccurate records of Josephus, want to twist Luke’s plain statement into harmony with a date two years earlier.”
It strikes us as a bad mark for any theory when it can secure a foothold only by charging some standard author, like Josephus, with inaccuracy, unless there is some clear reason for so doing. In this case this reason does not appear. In our article of January 26, a lengthy quotation was given from the learned Dr. Hales, stating that Josephus was “most competent to procure genuine information” on the dates pertaining to the time of Christ, and that the “critical conformity of both astronomical and historical evidence” established his testimony as correct. This was in reference to the death of Herod, U. C. 750, instead of 753, throwing the birth of Christ between three and four years before A. D. 1, instead of only one year and three months before, as the Watch Tower contends.
Now we will introduce to the reader some of those people whom the editor of the Watch Tower charges with being misled by the inaccuracies of Josephus, and with wanting “to twist Luke’s plain statement into harmony with a date two years earlier;” that is, those who hold that Luke commences the computation of the reign of Tiberius with his association with Augustus in A. D. 12, and not from the beginning of his sole reign in A. D. 14.
The Encyclopedia Britannica, art. Tiberius, says:—
From the beginning of 11, when he celebrated a magnificent triumph, to the time of the emperor’s death in 14, Tiberius remained almost entirely in Italy, and held rather the position of joint emperor than that of expectant heir.
Duruy, in his great “History of Rome,” Vol. IV, page 282, says:—
In the year 13, Augustus, feeling his end approaching, took Tiberius as his colleague. In virtue of a senatus-consultum and a law of the centuries, he shared with his newly appointed colleague, the tribunitian power, the proconsular authority in the provinces, the command of the armies, and the right of making the census.
As the editor of the Watch Tower has taken such pleasure in looking up the meaning of “proconsular powers,” and consoles himself with the thought that that was only a little office, under the emperor, will he now kindly take down his dictionary again, and look up the meaning of “joint emperor,” and “colleague,” and see if he can ascertain what relation between Tiberius and Augustus these terms indicate? To be sure, the Britannica begins with a triumph in A. D. 11, of which Tiberius enjoyed some four within a few years, and Duruy speaks of what transpired in A. D. 13; and this difference would perhaps tend to confirm rather than weaken the intermediate date, A. D. 12, as the time when Tiberius was to be considered as an associate in the empire, which is generally assigned to this year. But however this may be, they utterly demolish the claim of the Watch Tower that Tiberius had no imperial authority till the death of Augustus, A. D. 14.
Lardner, in his “Works,” Vol. 1, page 373, says:—
There seems to be very good reason to conclude, from divers passages of the Roman historians, and the most ancient Christian writers, that there were two different computations of the beginning of Tiberius’s reign,—one from the time he was made colleague with Augustus, and the other from his sole empire, after the death of Augustus. Several very learned men and very eminent chronologists are of the opinion that St. Luke intends the former of these two computations.
Scott, on Luke 3 : 1, says:—
Augustus Cæsar, having admitted his nephew, Tiberius, to a share in the imperial authority, died about three years after; and Tiberius was at that time [the ministry of John] in the fifteenth year of his reign from his appointment as the colleague of Augustus.
Dr. Clarke, on the same passage, says:—
Verse 1. Fifteenth year.] This was the fifteenth of his principality, and thirteenth of his monarchy; for he was two years joint emperor, previously to the death of Augustus.
Lange, on Luke 3 : 1, says:—
The fifteenth year of the reign of Tiberius Cæsar is easily ascertained. Augustus died A. U. C. 767, which, taking this event as the terminus a quo, gives the year 782 [as the fifteenth year of Tiberius]. It seems, however, probable that our computation must be made from the time when Tiberius was associated with Augustus in the government of the empire, two years earlier, which would give us the year 780 [as Tiberius’s fifteenth year]. The reigning years of a Roman emperor were, indeed, commonly dated from the time when he governed alone; but as Luke is here speaking of ἡγεμονία, and not of μοναρχία or βασιλεία, he seems to include the two preceding years, in which Tiberius, indeed, possessed a power no way inferior to that of Augustus.
Meyer, in his commentary on the same passage says:—
Accordingly it might appear doubtful whether Luke reckons the year 767 or 768 as the first; similarly, as Tiberius became co-regent at the end of 764, or in January, 765, whether Luke begins to reckon from the co-regency, or of the sole government.
As authorities who date Tiberius’s reign from the co-regency, Meyer names the following: “Ussher, Voss, Pagius, Clericus, Sepp, Lichtenstein, Tischendorf, and others.” For the year 765 as the date of the co-regency, a foot-note gives the following authorities: “Tacitus, Ann. i, 3; Suetonius, Tib. 20 f.; Velleius Paterculus ii, 121.” A note by the American editor on the foregoing comment by Meyer reads: “That the reckoning may be made from the joint reign, appears from the citations in Zumpt, das Geburtsjahr Christi, pages 293–296, and Wieseler, Beitrage, viii, page 193. So Weiss ed. Mey., Godet, and many others.” Another note subsequently adds: “The chronological question is much simplified by reckoning ‘the fifteenth year’ (verse 1) from the beginning of the joint reign of Tiberius.”
But more fatal than all these testimonies to the position of the Watch Tower, is the fact that it is out of harmony with the declarations of prophecy on this subject from beginning to end. It is useless to appeal to the commission of Artaxerxes to Nehemiah for the beginning of the seventy weeks of Dan. 9 : 24, 25. That was in no sense whatever a “commandment to restore and build Jerusalem,” as was that given to Ezra thirteen years before. It is wrong to date Nehemiah’s commission B. C. 445 instead of 444, and then change it nine years from that date. And then all the following events—the building of Jerusalem, the birth of Christ, the baptism of Christ, the crucifixion, and the end of the seventy weeks—are all disarranged, and fall at times when there was absolutely nothing to mark them.
Involved in such inconsistencies, it is no wonder the editor of the Tower tries to cover his tracks by claiming that the whole prophecy is too obscure to be understood. He says: “The beginning of the seventy weeks (490 years) of Israel’s favor (Dan. 9 : 24) was so obscure and indefinite that the Jews could not and did not know positively when to expect Messiah. No doubt this was of divine intention.” On the contrary, there is no clearer and more definite prophecy in all the Bible than that of the seventy weeks. The event with which they begin is minutely described; the date is well established; and the terminal and intermediate events are plainly defined, and answer to the prophecy, when rightly interpreted, as the glove fits the hand. The Jews ought to have understood the matter. They had no excuse for not understanding it; and Christ upbraided and condemned them because they did not know the time of their visitation. Luke 19 : 41–44. While God does not set forth the prophecies in a way to compel belief, he nevertheless makes them so plain that they may be easily understood.
U. S.