BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek College.)
In the two articles preceding this one, the status of Sunday during the ancient régime, but before the great Reformation of the sixteenth century, has been shown. From the documents which were cited, it is very evident that the Roman Catholics of the Middle Ages endeavored to enforce the observance of Sunday, along much the same lines as the Pharisees endeavored to enforce the worship of the seventh-day Sabbath at the time of the first advent of Christ. Every imaginable law, besides innumerable ordinances, had been passed to guard its sanctity. But all these were of no avail; they only made matters worse. There were so many of them, and they were so minute in their requirements, that men had become discouraged, and had given up all hope of ever being able to learn how to keep the day to suit the bishops. Hessey puts it that men were “thoroughly entangled” in this network of Sunday laws, “and if they tried to carry them out (to live them, so to speak), they were hampered at every turn.” Then he adds: “So far, however, as practise went, the strictness of the provisions supplied produced an effect the reverse of what was intended. Human nature rebelled against it.”1
All these laws, then, were a miserable failure. They served rather to discourage men from trying to keep Sunday than to aid them in their efforts. To keep Sunday according to law was an act of righteousness, so the bishops said. Hence they tried to make men righteous by law. But this is impossible. Men cannot be made righteous by law,—no, not even by the law of God. Righteousness comes not by the law, but by faith in Jesus Christ. There is no righteousness but the righteousness of the faith which is in Jesus Christ.
Furthermore, Sunday-keeping is not commanded in the word of God. There is no precept in Sacred Writ which says that this day should be kept holy. If there had been, the day could have been kept holy by faith. But since there was and is no such command, it is impossible to keep the day, even by faith. This must be so; for, “Faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.”2 But if the thing to be kept is not in the word of God, how can it be kept by faith, which cometh by hearing the word of God? The thing is utterly and entirely impossible. God only can make holy. Man cannot make holy. God has never made Sunday holy, and it is impossible to keep that holy which is not holy.
It was reserved for the great Reformation of the sixteenth century to make the first general protest against the Church of Rome, both against these Sunday laws and against countless other matters which need not be entered upon here. The Reformers declaimed in no uncertain tones against those “vexatious restrictions” with which men had “loaded Sunday.”3
The popes and the councils had held that Sunday was the successor of the Sabbath, and that it was entitled to the same degree of respect. With one blow, as it were, and with one consent, the continental Reformers rejected the legal, or Jewish, title which had been set up for Sunday; the more than Jewish ceremonies and restrictions by which, in theory, it had been encumbered; and the army of holy days of obligation by which it had been surrounded. “But they did more. They left standing no sanction for the day itself which could commend itself powerfully to men’s consciences.” The Reformers did leave standing no sanction for the keeping of the day, such as could commend it to the consciences of men. They took the word of God for their rule of life and conduct. They did not find any command for Sunday keeping in the Bible. They did not find it for the simple reason that there is none there. Hence they told the people that they need not keep Sunday. They told them that God would not be angry with them if they did not keep it; and in telling them this, they told them the exact truth. This is what Martin Luther said: “If anywhere the day is made holy for the mere day’s sake,—if anywhere any one sets up its observance on a Jewish foundation,—then I order you to work on it, to ride on it, to dance on it, to feast on it, to do anything that shall remove this encroachment on Christian liberty.”4 And Richard Baxter said, in his quaint way, that it was “the papists’ ceremoniousness, and their multitude of festivals, that stood altogether in the Reformers’ eye.”5
While the Reformers saw that Sunday was not of the Bible, they did not see that the seventh-day Sabbath is of the Bible, and that it is binding on Christians. Their position on the whole matter is made fairly clear by Luther in his “Larger Catechism.” In this work, speaking of the fourth commandment, he says:—
This precept, so far as its outward and carnal meaning is concerned, does not apply to us Christians. The Sabbath is an outward thing, like the other ordinances of the Old Testament, which were bound to certain modes, and persons, and times, and places, but are now all of them made free by Christ. But still, in order that we may gather for simple people some Christian meaning from this precept, understand what God requires of us therein in the following manner: We celebrate festivals, not for the sake of intelligent and instructed Christians (for these have no need of them), but, first, even for the sake of the body. Nature herself teaches the lesson that the working classes, servants, and maids are to be considered; they have spent the whole week in laborious employment, and require a day on which they may take breath from their work, and refresh themselves, and restore their exhausted frames by repose. The second reason, and indeed the chief one, is this,—that on such day of rest (an dem solchem Ruhetage—die Sabbat), leisure and time may be obtained for divine worship,—a duty for which, otherwise, no opportunity could be found,—so that we may come together to hear and handle the word of God; and, further, that we may glorify God with hymns and psalms, with songs and prayers.
It is, however, to be observed, that with us this is not so tied to certain times as it was with the Jews, so that this or that day in particular should be (enderdemor) enjoined for it. No day is better or more excellent than another. These duties ought to be performed every day. But the majority of mankind are so encumbered with business that they could not be present at such assemblies. Some one day, therefore, at least, must be selected in each week for attention to these matters. And seeing that those who preceded us chose the Lord’s day for them, this harmless and admitted custom must not be changed readily; our objects in retaining it, are, the securing of unanimity and consent of arrangement, and the avoidance of the general confusion which would result from individual and unnecessary innovation.6
Chemnitz, who was born in 1522, and who has deservedly obtained a place among the more eminent followers of Luther, charged the Romanists with superstition, because they taught an inherent sanctity in the Lord’s day,—that is, Sunday,—and in other festivals.7
Bucer, another eminent Reformer, wrote thus: “To think that working on Sunday is, in itself, a sin, is a superstition and a denying of the grace of Christ.”8
Again: even Calvin himself, the most strict and despotic of all the Reformers, took much the same position. With him, Sunday-keeping was a matter of indifference. Once upon a time, John Knox paid Calvin a visit on a Sunday afternoon, and found him playing ball. Concerning Calvin, Hessey says:—
He is particularly severe on those who, in former times, had imbued mankind with Jewish ideas, such as developed themselves with the assertion that, while the ceremonial part of the command, that is, the observance of the seventh day, was abolished, its moral part, which they stated to be the observance of one day in seven, remained. “What is this,” he says, “but to insult the Jews by changing the day, while they imitate the Jews by observing one which they invest with thep. 307 same sanctity? The result of their doctrine is that they have gone thrice as far as the Jews themselves in a gross and carnal Sabbatism, and deserve Isaiah’s reproaches on that subject even more than the Jews deserved them.”9
Tyndale, the first translator of the Scriptures into modern English, and his friend and fellow sufferer, John Fryth, were of much the same opinion. Says the former:—
As for the Sabbath, we be lords over the Sabbath, and may change it into Monday, or into any other day as we see need, or may make every tenth day holy day only, if we see cause why. Neither was there any cause to change it from the Saturday, but to put a difference between ourselves and the Jews; neither need we any holy day at all, if the people might be taught without it.10
Fryth is even more explicit than Tyndale. He said that those who superstitiously observed Sunday were “much madder” than the Jews who superstitiously observed Saturday. “The Jews have the word of God for their Saturday, sith it is the seventh day, and they were commanded to keep the seventh day solemn. But we have not the word of God for us, but rather against us; for we keep not the seventh day, as the Jews do, but the first, which is not commanded by God’s law.”11
And now, perhaps, we are in a position to sum up the views of the Reformers of the sixteenth century on the subject before us. These men were not Sabbatarians. In no sense did they believe in the literal application of the fourth commandment to people living under the Christian dispensation. They scarcely ever refer to that commandment, except to try to prove that it is not binding upon Christians. But while they did not see that the claims of the seventh-day Sabbath were binding upon them, they did see that Sunday was not of the Bible. They therefore repudiated Sunday as a day which must be kept holy. In their eyes it was not and could not be holy, because it was not enjoined by the Bible. They never kept it as a Sabbath. They went to church on Sunday simply as a matter of convenience. If the people could have come just as well on Monday, Monday would have done just as well. The day was not holy, it was not to be considered as a day of sacred rest. Men and maid servants could get off from their work on that day, therefore they made it the day for their weekly meetings. Nevertheless the people were not prohibited from laboring nor yet from playing. These things, in the eyes of the Reformers, were just as proper on Sunday as on any other day. The Reformers saw half the light, and only half the light. They saw that Sunday was not the Sabbath; but they did not see that Saturday, the seventh day, was the Sabbath.
But France rejected the Reformation altogether; and, with the Reformation, she rejected also the view which the Reformers held concerning Sunday. France kept enforcing Sunday more and more strictly. Had France accepted the Reformation, what would have been the result as far as the matter of Sunday was concerned?—Simply this,—those who became Protestants would have disregarded Sunday; and those who continued Catholics would have gone on observing it; but not with the same strictness as heretofore. This the prelates of France must have seen, but evidently they were not satisfied with such an adjustment of the matter. So they went ahead, and pushed their Sunday laws harder than ever. They persecuted the Huguenots who worked on Sundays and holy days. The Protestant Huguenots did work upon these days, and of course by so doing gained a better livelihood than the Catholics. They became more deft in their crafts, and consequently had a better hold upon the markets than their Catholic neighbors. This of course caused trouble immediately and at length produced persecution. But Sunday laws must be enforced at any cost, and they were enforced clear up to the time of the Revolution. By that time men had stood them long enough, and so they rose, and inaugurated the Republican calendar for the purpose of abolishing Sunday and the saints’ days forever from France. How much better would it have been for the French prelates if they had opened their hearts to the Reformation! How much better for them would it have been, if, indeed, while they received not the Reformation, they had let others receive it; for then, through the influence of these others, the “vexatious restrictions” with which Sunday was “loaded” would have been, in large degree, removed! Sunday itself, at least, would have been left, but by the Republican calendar it was swept away, and the Republican tenth day put in its place.