As we had anticipated, a very few have written of the impressions caused by the articles on circumcision which appeared in these columns some weeks since. We only wish to repeat that in its present discussion, the question is taken entirely out of the realm of religious usage, and is presented from the standpoint of hygiene and morality. No attempt is made to show the binding force of the ceremonial law. The author of the article which advocated the practise is a Christian lady of advanced years; a mother, a teacher, and a student of broad experience. She has taught these principles for many years in the public press and forum.
There is no wish upon the part of any one to urge the question, pro or con, by way of controversy. In deference to our interested readers we asked the opinion of one who is universally esteemed in the medical profession and as a philanthropist, and he has replied as below. With this we leave the question with the intelligent and thoughtful readers. Upon the question of circumcision as a religious duty, the REVIEW stands where it ever has stood; and now that the moral and hygienic features of the practise have been mentioned, we believe that all can intelligently seek their own conclusions.
To the Editor of the Review:—
My attention has recently been called to articles which have recently appeared in the REVIEW relating to the subject of circumcision; and as my opinion respecting the matter has been asked, I will say simply that I have many times been required to perform this operation as a necessary means for correcting morbid conditions, both physical and moral; and while I never have taken the position that the operation was so essential to physical and moral health that its universal application is a duty from a hygienic standpoint, I am certain that an immense amount of good would result from its universal application, and, so far as I know, there could be no evil results.
I think I have had an unusually large experience with cases in which the principle referred to applies, and yet the above statement is not based upon my own experience alone, but is abundantly supported by the most eminent and renowned medical authorities. It is very clear to my mind that the rite of circumcision was of immense hygienic value to the ancient Jews, and I cannot believe that this was purely accidental, either, since I have long been fully persuaded that God makes no purely arbitrary or formal requirements of his creatures, but in all the requirements which he has ever made of his people, either ancient or modern, there is beneficence alone, physical, mental, and moral.
J. H. KELLOGG.