BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.
(Battle Creek College.)
I have already shown that the laws enforcing a strict observance of Sunday and the saints’ days were responsible for the establishment of the Republican calendar; for the aim, the object, of this calendar was to do away with Sundays and saints’ days. The property of the clergy had already been confiscated; and everywhere that body, so long accustomed to privileges and immunities, was under the ban of the law. It now remained only to abolish the Catholic religion itself, and to put something else in its place.
Roman Catholicism in France had always posed as Christianity. The people of France had all along been given to understand that it was Christianity. They had now learned to hate it; and of course they thought that in hating the Roman Catholic religion, they were hating Christianity. Roman Catholicism is not Christianity; but the people of France thought that it was, and confounding the two, they inaugurated the reign of atheism.
Two thousand three hundred and twenty-seven years prior to this, God had foretold that Christianity would be abolished in France, and that the people would enter upon a course of atheism. In the book of Daniel the prophet it had been written: “And the king shall do according to his will; and he shall exalt himself, and magnify himself above every god, and shall speak marvelous things against the God of gods, and shall prosper till the indignation be accomplished; for that that is determined shall be done. Neither shall he regard the God of his fathers, nor the desire of women, nor regard any god; for he shall magnify himself above all.”1 Now mark, a power is to arise which shall do the following things:—
- He shall do according to his will.
- He shall exalt himself.
- He shall magnify himself above every god.
- He shall speak marvelous things against the God of gods.
- He shall prosper till the indignation be accomplished.
- Neither shall he regard the God of his fathers.
- Neither shall he regard the desire of women.
- He shall not regard any god.
- He shall magnify himself above all gods.
Now these specifications are literally true of the French people during the Revolution, and they are not true of any other nation that has ever existed upon the face of the earth. The specifications call for absolute atheism. A power which, in religious things, does nothing more than speak marvelous things against the God of gods, will not fulfil the requirements. The power which meets the requirements must do much more than this; he must magnify himself above every god. He is not to regard any god. This power is not to regard the God of heaven; and, added to this, he is not even to regard an idol god, a god of wood or stone. And while discarding God and all the gods, he is to magnify himself above all. I say, again, that nowhere, and at no time in the history of this world, have these specifications been fulfilled save only in the case of France during the Revolution. And now to the history.
The atheistical movement began in the capital of the country, in the city of Paris itself. It originated with three men, Pache, Hébert, and Chaumette, who were the leaders of the municipal government. It must be borne in mind that Paris was then controlled by one of the vilest mobs that ever controlled a city; and these three leaders were among the vilest of the vile. The scene at the city hall, where the municipal council met, is thus described by a noted Frenchman:—
Some stretched out on the benches; and others, leaning on the tables with their elbows, were snoring; others were barefoot, or wearing their shoes slipshod like slippers; almost all were dirty and poorly clad; their clothes were unbuttoned, their hair uncombed, and their faces frightful; they wore pistols in their belts, and sabers, with scarfs turned into shoulder-straps. Bottles, bits of bread, fragments of meat and bones, lay strewn around the floor, and the odor was intolerable.2
Pache, Hébert, and Chaumette had already been engaged in the most atrocious excesses. They had labored hard to have the king, Louis XVI, and his queen, Marie Antoinette, put to death; and their efforts had been successful. Both had perished by the guillotine. But this was not all; to wreak their vengeance upon the living was not enough, they must despoil the tombs of the dead. The sepulchers of those who had been monarchs of France were at Saint Denis. By a decree of the Convention it wasp. 340 ordered that these venerable asylums should be destroyed. A furious mob was turned loose upon them. The tombs of Henry IV, of Francis I, and of Louis XII were ransacked, and their bones scattered in the air. Even the bones of Charles V, the saviour of his country, were dispersed. These acts of violence were immediately followed by a general attack upon the monuments and remains of antiquity throughout France. The sepulchres of the great of past ages, of the barons and generals of feudal days, of the paladins, and of the crusaders, were involved in one undistinguished ruin. It seemed as if the glories of antiquity were forgotten, or as if the people sought to bury them in oblivion. The skulls of monarchs and heroes were tossed about like footballs by the profane multitude; like the grave-diggers in Hamlet, they made a jest of the lips before which nations had trembled.3
They did all this because they hated kings. Kings had been tyrannical; kings had taxed them till they had not had bread to give their children to eat; kings had lived in wantonness and rioting; and now they had learned that they could get along without kings, yea, even that they were much better off without them. They had abolished the kingly office, and they had founded a republic. But the dignitaries of the Catholic Church had always represented the God of heaven as a king, and as a king just as arbitrary and despotic as were the kings of France. So the Revolutionists reasoned this way: A republic is a far better form of government than a monarchy. If this is true of earth, why is it not equally true of heaven? Why should there be a king there any more than here? We don’t believe in kings at all. We don’t believe in them for heaven a bit more than for earth. Sunday was the day of rest of this King of heaven. He made us keep it whether we liked it or not. He loaded it with “vexatious restrictions,” and said that he would open the windows of heaven, and deluge us with stones and hot water if we did not keep the day. Now it is our duty to “dethrone the King of heaven as well as the monarchs of the earth.”4
That these were the ideas they entertained about God are clear from a speech by Robespierre. Here are his words:—
What is there in common between the priests and God? The priests are to morality what quacks are to medicine. How different is the God of nature from the God of the priests! I know nothing that so nearly resembles atheism as the religions which they have framed. By grossly misrepresenting the Supreme Being, they have annihilated belief in him, as far as lay in their power. They made him at one time a globe of fire; at another, an ox; sometimes a tree, sometimes a man, sometimes a king. The priests have created a god after their own image; they have made him jealous, capricious, greedy, cruel, and implacable; they have treated him as the mayors of the palace formerly treated the descendants of Clovis, in order to reign in his name, and put themselves in his place; they have confined him in heaven as in a palace, and have called him to earth only to demand of him, for their own interest, tithes, wealth, honors, pleasures, and powers.5
Chaumette took the initiative, and began by launching out in the municipality against the publicity of Catholic worship. He insisted that this was a privilege which that communion ought no more to enjoy than any other; and that if each sect was granted the same privilege, the streets and public places would soon become the theater of the most ridiculous farces. As the municipal government had charge of the local police, he obtained a resolution on Oct. 14, 1793, that no ministers of religion should be allowed to exercise their worship out of the temples appropriated to it. It was then ordered that new funeral ceremonies for the purpose of paying the last respects to the dead be instituted. The relatives and friends alone were to accompany the coffin. All the religious signs were to be suppressed in the ceremonies. They were to be replaced by a statue of sleep, and death itself was declared to be a perpetual sleep. Instead of cypress and doleful shrubs, the burial-grounds were to be planted with such as were more cheerful and fragrant. “Let the beauty and the perfume of flowers,” said Chaumette, “excite more soothing ideas. I would fain, if it were possible, be able to inhale, in the scent of the rose, the spirit of my father.”6
The next step was to abolish the outward signs of the Catholic religion. It was further decreed that there should not be sold in the streets “any kind of jugglery, such as holy napkins, St. Veronica handkerchiefs, Ecce Homos, crosses, Agnus Deis, virgins, bodies and rings of St. Hubert, or any powders, medicinal waters, or other adulterated drugs.”6 The image of the Virgin was everywhere suppressed, and all the madonnas in niches at the corners of streets were taken down to make room for busts of Marat and Lepelletier.
The next move was to capture the National Convention. This body was presided over by a man named Laloi, who was in perfect agreement with the ringleaders of the municipal council of Paris. On Nov. 7, 1793, the matter was introduced into the Convention by the reading of a letter from a parish priest of the name of Parens, who said that he was ready to abjure his faith provided that his subsistence was guaranteed to him by a pension. “I am a vicar,” said he; “I am a parish priest; that is to say, a charlatan. Hitherto an honest charlatan, I have deceived only because I was myself deceived. Now that I am disabused, I confess to you that I should not wish to be a dishonest charlatan. Nevertheless, poverty might constrain me to it. It seems to me that it would be well to assure the necessary subsistence to those who wish to render justice to truth.”7 This piece of baseness was greeted by loud applause all over the house.
The president then announced to the Convention that the constituted authorities of the department and of the municipality, with Gobel, the constitutional bishop of Paris, his vicars, and several priests, wished to present themselves at the bar. Momoro pompously exclaimed that these citizens demanded to be regenerated, and to become men. “Led by reason,” said he, “they are come to strip themselves of the character which superstition has conferred upon them. Thus the French Republic will soon have no other worship than that of liberty, equality, and eternal truth.” The Parisian authorities, and Bishop Gobel and his priests were admitted to the bar of the Assembly. Along with them came a most disgraceful rabble. Crowds of drunken artisans and shameless prostitutes crowded to the bar, and trampled under their feet the sacred vases, consecrated for ages to the purposes of religion.8
In the midst of frantic applause Gobel rose, and thus addressed the assembly: “Born a plebeian, curé of Porrentruy, sent by the clergy to the first Assembly, then raised to the archbishopric of Paris, I have never ceased to obey the people. I accepted the functions which that people bestowed upon me, and now, in obedience to it, I am come to resign them. I suffered myself to be made a bishop when the people wanted bishops. I cease to be so now, when the people no longer desire any.”9 He then added that all his clergy charged him to make a like declaration for them. As he finished speaking, he laid down his miter, his crozier, and his ring. His clergy, who were with him, then ratified his decision. Tumultuous applause greeted the speech of Gobel and the ratification of his clergy.
The president of the Convention then arose, and addressed Gobel and the priests: “Citizens, who have just sacrificed on the altar of the country these Gothic children’s toys, you are worthy of the republic.” The president then threw his arms around Gobel’s neck, and gave him the fraternal embrace. In place of his clerical garments the bishop donned the red cap of the Jacobins. Bishop Lindet then came forward, and pretended that he had accepted the episcopate only to save his country, and that he had never been a charlatan. It was then very easy for him to abandon what he had never truly had.
It was not possible that in the midst of all this baseness, the Christian conscience should remain without a witness. Its inflexible language was heard at this profane tribune, and despite the cries of rage with which they endeavored to stifle its voice, its appearance was sufficient to chastise, by violent contrast, all the cowardice which had just been witnessed. It was Gregoire, bishop of Blois, who gave this grand spectacle to his country. Of an ardent, generous disposition, he had more than once carried enthusiasm even to imprudence; and although he had not voted the death of the king, he was guilty of the wrong of insulting him in his fall, in a moment of excitement forever to be regretted; he was, nevertheless, a sincere Christian and an intrepid soul. Never had he abjured a single one of his convictions, still less his God. He still wore the ecclesiastical costume, which was an act of courage at that period. Called to sit at this hour in the committee of public instruction, he was ignorant of what was passing in the hall of the Assembly. Scarcely had he entered when he was surrounded by a troop of mountain deputies, who urged him by furious gestures to follow the good example of Gobel. It was said to him, on all sides, “Thou must mount the tribune.” “For what?” “To renounce thy episcopate, thy religious charlatanism.” “Miserable blasphemers,” replied he, “I never was a charlatan. Attached to my religion, I have preached the truth; I shall be faithful to it.”
Hoping to constrain him to follow the current, the president gave him permission to speak, which he had not asked. He rushed to the tribune; a great silence succeeded the tumult. “I enter here,” said he, “having only very vague notions of what has passed before my arrival. They talk to me of sacrificing to the country; I am accustomed to it. Is the question of attachment to the cause of liberty? I have given my proof. Is the question of the revenue attached to the title of bishop? I abandon it to you without regret. Is it a question of religion? This subject is beyond your domain, and you have not the right to attack it. I hear talk about fanaticism and superstition. I have always combatedp. 341 them. But let these words be defined, and it will be seen that fanaticism and superstition are directly opposed to religion. As for me, Catholic through conviction and sentiment, priest through choice, I have been appointed by the people to be bishop; but it is neither from them nor from you that I hold my mission. I have consented to carry the burden of the episcopate in a time in which it was surrounded with penalties. They have tormented me to accept it, they torment me to-day to make an abdication which they shall not tear from me. I have endeavored to do good in my diocese, acting according to the sacred principles which are dear to me, and of which I defy you to rob me; I remain bishop in order still to act in the same manner. I appeal to religious liberty.”10
This last speech from Gregoire was a good plea for religious liberty. Undoubtedly the man was honest and sincere; but the plea ill befitted the Roman Catholic creed. It was true that the Convention was beyond its domain, and that it had no right to touch the subject of religion. But it was no more beyond its domain than the despotic monarchy of the ancient régime had been in enforcing the Catholic religion. The Convention was doing just what the old monarchy had done for hundreds of years. It was not a whit more culpable. It was making Catholics abjure their faith. Had not the church sanctioned this times out of number when the old government had endeavored to compel those who had left the communion of the holy mother to return to their allegiance by renouncing the new tenets which they had accepted? The whole scene, so far as the Convention was concerned, was perfectly proper; it was perfectly in place, and no Catholic had any business whatever to complain of it.