Australian Federal Constitution and the Religious Clause Petitions
By A. G. Daniells
NORTH FITZROY, VICTORIA, May 6, 1897. DEAR BRETHREN: When I wrote you last, the Federal Convention was sitting. The churches of Australia had sent in thousands of petitions, requesting the delegates to insert a religious clause in the constitution to be framed for the new state. The object of this clause was to recognize God in the national constitution, and thus indicate that this is a Christian nation. As soon as we learned that the churches were circulating a petition of that sort, we prepared one, a copy of which you have seen, and put it into the hands of our people for circulation. They took hold of this with good heart, and secured about eight thousand signatures. Our time to work was very short; I think we had only about three weeks. We presented these signatures to the convention, and they were respectfully received, and placed by the side of the petition sent in by the churches. Our petition was, of course, a counter-petition. The committee appointed by the delegates to draft the constitution set aside the petition of the churches, and brought out a constitution in perfect harmony with the petition we sent in. We do not know whether our petition had any influence with them or not. All we know is that the constitution is just what our petition asked for. The constitution sets forth the powers of the federal government; that is, it specifies the subjects on which the federal government shall have the right to legislate. It does not specify religion. Therefore, the government cannot legislate on religious questions. The powers not conferred are reserved. This pertains to the federal government. In defining the powers of the states, the constitution says: “A state shall not make any law prohibiting the free exercise of any religion.” I understand that this constitution is, in this respect, broader and better than the United States Constitution. The latter prohibits the general government from making any law respecting religion, but leaves each State to pass all the religious laws it may choose. This constitution virtually prohibits the general government from touching religion, and it expressly prohibits any state from doing so. I could wish that a few words were inserted in the prohibition respecting the state, but altogether395 I consider it a grand document. I cannot help believing that the hand of the Lord is in this matter. This constitution gives us an immense advantage in the present crisis. Heretofore all the legislation has been against us, and we have had to take an aggressive position; but now we can appeal to the people in defense of the constitution as it now stands. We can heartily approve of and justify the work done by the Federal Convention. You can see that this is better for us than to be working for a change of the constitution. The petition of the churches was almost the very last thing considered in the convention. I think the framers of the constitution anticipated a debate on this, and so deferred it until the last moment. Many of the delegates had then left. Those who remained were anxious to get away. When they came to consider the preamble, a Catholic by the name of Glynn proposed the recognition of God in the preamble, in harmony with the request of the churches. His motion was challenged at once by one of the Tasmanian delegates, but it was warmly seconded by a New South Wales delegate. Mr. Bartin, the leader of the convention, and one of the framers of the constitution, made a short but excellent speech. He requested the mover of the amendment to the preamble not to force a debate. There was a little sharp firing, but a division of the delegates was called for before they had much time to debate. Eleven delegates voted for the religious clause, and seventeen voted against it, so it was lost by six votes. The Tasmanian delegates nearly all went against it. The Victorian Cabinet nearly all voted for it. New South Wales and South Australia divided. Two of the strongest men, Mr. Bartin and Mr. Kingston, are against any recognition of religion in the constitution. They had a leading hand in the framing of the federal bill in 1891, and they are the strongest men in the convention. From all that is being said in conferences and public addresses, I believe that a strong effort will be made by the churches to carry their point, which means religious legislation and persecution. I do not think that they will arouse enough interest to do nearly as much as they might do just now, but the steps they take at this time will create a sentiment that will enable them to do far more when something else comes up. It would seem that if they were all thoroughly aroused, they would carry everything before them. It may be that the Lord prevents them from doing this. He allows just enough to be manifested to show his people what they may expect, and to arouse them to earnest action. I feel that we have made a mistake in the past. You remember that two or three years ago we felt a great burden to have aggressive work carried on continually on religious-liberty lines. We got Brethren Colcord and Corliss over here to assist us. Finally we got the Sentinel started. Sufficient developments manifested themselves just at that time to give meaning to the Sentinel; but when the opposition died down, our energies flagged. We ceased to speak, write, and work on these lines. A couple of years have passed without very much being done. Now we are in the greatest crisis our people have been in since the work was established in this country, and we are very poorly prepared for it. If we had, during the past two years, while matters were quiet, written, and talked, and distributed literature on church and state questions, we might have been much better prepared, and the people might have been better prepared, for this crisis. The words of Christ, “O fools, and slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken,” are specially applicable to us. You will not be surprised to learn that a mournful wail has arisen from the church leaders in all parts of the land. Some swear vengeance on all the politicians who ignored their petition. Others predict all sorts of calamities for the nation. Resolutions are being passed by the Council of Churches in different colonies, Conference Assemblies, Elders’ Associations, National Scripture Education Leagues, etc., etc., expressing deep regret at the decision of the convention, and calling the people everywhere to arms. It is declared that the local parliaments, which are to consider the constitution framed by the convention, must amend it by inserting the religious clause. Pressure must be brought to bear upon all the politicians who are now members of parliament to grant their request. They are also taking a strong position that no man shall be elected to parliament who will not pledge himself to work for religious instruction in the state schools, and for the recognition of God in the federal constitution. This morning’s paper states that the various churches, leagues, and organizations are preparing to have addresses delivered in various parts of the country, and emissaries will question every candidate as to his leaning in regard to these questions. The Protestant ministers are requested to make this theme the subject of special sermons, which will be followed by newspaper correspondence. The league says that it expects to gain great ends from its efforts, and points to the results of the federal elections of New South Wales as an evidence of the power of the clergy to guide public opinion. A meeting to arrange preliminaries is to be held in Melbourne the 20th of May. The situation now is about as follows:— 1. The Federal Convention has framed, for the Australian Commonwealth, a model constitution so far as it pertains to religion and civil government. 2. This constitution is now to be submitted to the various parliaments of Australia for consideration. They will discuss the document, and make such amendments as they can agree upon. 3. In one hundred and twenty days from yesterday the federal delegates will meet again to consider the constitution. They will discuss the amendments proposed, and if possible will agree upon the constitution. When they have ratified it, they will send it to the queen for the royal signature. 4. The church leaders of Australia now propose to bring pressure to bear upon each local parliament to insert a religious clause in the constitution. If they can accomplish this, they feel pretty sure that at the second meeting of the delegates, to be convened in Sydney on the second day of September, they will adopt the amendment suggested by the different parliaments. From now until the constitution is adopted is a supreme hour for our work in Australia. The minds of the people will be agitated. They will do more thinking about church and state matters than they have, perhaps, at any time before. They will be forming opinions and making decisions that they will propose to stand by in the future. Now if we had everything in readiness, we could do much toward getting the message before the people. It is our duty to warn them against worshiping the beast and his image and receiving his mark. This certainly means that we should warn them against making an image to the beast. If this matter were placed before the people in its true light, it would open their minds as well as anything that we could present, to the meaning of our work. I feel very much perplexed to know what to do. Brother Hare is away off in Western Australia, Brother Starr has his hands full at Adelaide, Brother Wilson is in very poor health in Tasmania, and Brother Baker is absorbed with his cares in New South Wales. Queensland has no minister. Elder Haskell is in the school, Elder Colcord is busy with the Echo, and you know where I stand. The mere mention of all these names might lead one who is not acquainted with the field to suggest that we all put our heads together, and carry the work through. We can do this in some of the lines, but we cannot do all that ought to be done. We are widely separated. We could carry on certain lines of detail work if we had the material at hand. What we ought to have is a capable man who could, during the next five months, devote his entire time to speaking and writing on these lines. Public meetings ought to be held in the capitals, and in the most important towns in the colonies. Articles ought to be written for the newspapers in different parts of the country. Tracts and leaflets touching upon the various phases of the question ought to be written and circulated by the thousand. Extra numbers of the Southern Sentinel ought to be printed. I am not fitted to do very good work in these lines; but if there was any one here who could take my work, I would feel it my duty to give myself almost entirely to religious liberty work during this time. If I felt sure that our position would be understood, and a man hastened off by the May boat, I should certainly cable; but I fear that the committee would not understand us, and that they would wait to correspond, and then it would be too late. The crisis would be passed. But I will suggest that you consider the situation in this country. Now I would not have you think that because we have no one who can give his time to this work, and so do much better work than we can, that we shall sit down and do nothing. No; we propose to do all that we can under the circumstances. Our brethren responded to our efforts to obtain signatures to our petition. Brother Colcord and I devoted a little time to the preparation of the number of the Sentinel that was due just at that time. We printed ten thousand copies, and at least seven thousand copies have been sent out. We are doing what we can to have our people push this work. We must and shall do what we can to get out leaflets dealing with different phases of the question. It looks as though we would have to canvass the territory again for signatures to petitions to the local parliaments, asking them not to interfere with the constitution framed at the recent convention. We have now learned where quite a number of the delegates stand on this question. We shall do what we can to write letters to them and supply them with literature. Though we shall do all we can, it grieves me to think how far short we shall come of doing what we ought to do and could do if we had the men here to give their time to the work. We must remember that this is not the last issue that we shall meet. The thing will be up from time to time until the end. Wisdom suggests that we now fully sense the meaning of these things, and make arrangements to devote our energies to this work right along, whether there is any special issue before us or not. The fact is that the issue is always before us. We may not be able to see any special movements on the part of the enemy, but the very fact that we have the message is the best evidence that we can have that we are in a great crisis, and that we ought never to slacken our efforts to warn the people. If we had realized that continually during the past two years, we would be able to make much more of the present crisis than we can possibly do now.