The encyclical of Pope Leo XIII to the English Church, in which he invited them back to the fold of Rome, was followed by an examination of the Anglican Church orders. The decision of the especially appointed papal committee was that through some failure in the past, a bishop was not properly ordained, and that therefore the clergy of the Church of England are not real priests, and that the apostolic succession has, as far as the English Church is concerned, been somewhere lost in transit!
The Church of England, as may well be imagined, is exceedingly mortified to be informed by so high an authority that its boasted apostolic succession, which it has flaunted so constantly in the face of Presbyterians, Methodists, and other dissenters, is not a reality, and that it has no more apostolic succession than these other churches. So to prove that it is not so poor as the Catholic Church holds that it is, the Church of England frames a reply, reasserting with great zeal its claim of at least a portion of the apostolic succession; but it commits the very fatal mistake, as a contemporary clearly points out, of making its contention “on the same historical grounds on which Romanists maintain that their priests have sacrificial power, and that their mass is a true sacrifice.”
Again: the English Church does not declare the apostasy of the Roman Catholic Church, and admits that Pope Leo XIII is a “venerable brother.” Such admission is fatal to any successful contention against Rome. If Rome is not apostate as a body; if, as a system it is not foretold by Paul as the “mystery of iniquity” and “that wicked” (2 Thess. 2:7, 8), and by the Revelator described as a persecuting beast, whose final end is captivity (Revelation 13) and the lake of fire (Rev. 19:19, 20), then Protestantism as a whole, and the English Church in particular, have no excuse for existence. There is no use in mincing matters. Protestant Christians should not try to see how much they can endure and endorse of the Romish doctrines, but should square the Romish system by the word of God; and when that word reveals the apostasy of Rome, they should not hesitate to say so. Rome never ceases to cry “heresy” after Protestants, and Protestants should so live that they can say, “Whether it be better to be called a heretic, and follow the Scriptures, or to turn from the Scriptures, and be an apostate, judge ye.”
Finally, a succession of apostolic faith and holiness received by personal contact, by faith, with the living Christ, is of far more account than any fancied succession received through men, many of whom were of very questionable faith and morality. M E K.