Studies in Child Culture No. 5: Truthfulness and the Imagination
By Mrs. S. M. I. Henry
STUDIES IN CHILD CULTURE.—NO. 5.
To assume that a child has told a lie is to take the first step toward making him a liar; and to make him afraid of the consequences of having the truth known, is to finish the work. Sometimes a mother who would be horrified at the thought of what she is doing, will lead the children in an effort to conceal facts which would bring upon them the displeasure of the father if he knew them, and then unhesitatingly punish the same children for some other act of deception with which she happens to have no part, and by and by will break her heart over the fact that she cannot depend on their word. To educate the child in truthfulness, he must be considered and taught as an imaginative being, as well as one with the power of knowing ordinary plain facts. The world of his imagination is just as real to him as is the world of material things; and the lights which play upon it may color everything which he sees, hears, and handles. Paul recognized this reality of the inner sight when he said, “While we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen.” This ability to behold the unseen is very quick in childhood; for, “Heaven lies about us in our infancy.” The innocent child, uncorrupted in his nature by selfishness, and ignorant of the things of sight and sense, lives quite as much in his own world of thought as he ever will in after life. He has his own idea of the objects about him, and being without that experience which can help him to understand the relations which exist between them and the thoughts and imaginations of his own dawning intelligence, he is very much handicapped in meeting the requirement that he shall make clear-cut statements of facts just as they appear to the eyes and understanding of his elders. “What have you been doing all the morning? Where have you been to get so muddy?” asked a mother of a boy of seven, who had just run in for something. “What are you getting out of that closet? and where are you going now?” “I’ve been hunting an elephant in the frog pond, and I’ve got him, too; and I’ve got to have a strong rope to chain him up with, for he’s awful big and strong!” and the boy was off with a bit of cord which he had found, wrapping it around his hand. “I declare,” said the mother, “I don’t know what to do with that child. I am worried to death. Of course I know this is all play, but sometimes I don’t know his play from the real. I am afraid he doesn’t know what truth is.” “You mean that you are afraid that he does not know what you mean by truth.” “I suppose that is it; but truth is truth, you know.” “Yes, truth is truth; but it is very unfortunate that her name has been dragged down to the level of this world of facts and opinions which change as often as the colors and shapes of the kaleidoscope, and that a statement which does not happen to seem correct to you is at once branded as untrue, and the one who makes it as a liar. Now that child has just as good a right to call this creature of his imagination—that stick, or some other boy—an elephant, as had the one who first invented the name for that animal.” “O, I understand that. Of course everybody would know that he is at play now; but just listen to this: He came in yesterday, and told me, just as honestly as any one could have done, that Mrs. Grey was going to have company, and wanted me to let her have a cake; for she was sick and could not bake one. I suspected him at once. I think I always do in these days, and yet it did seem that he must be telling the truth from the way he looked, so I said, ‘Are you sure, Willie, that Mrs. Grey really sent you to ask me for a cake?’ He looked me right in the eye, and said, ‘Yes, mama, and she wants your cake-basket, too.’ ‘Now I am sure you are lying,’ I said, ‘for she would never want that, with all her lovely silver and china.’ ‘But she does, mama,’ he persisted; for her things all got broke when she went away, and left Tige to keep house.’” “Then I was in despair! Such a jumble of things which might possibly have happened, with others which were impossible, I believe nobody but Willie could ever put together. Tige is the dog, of course you understand, and is never allowed in the house. A few evenings before, as Mrs. Grey and I, with several others, including Willie and the Grey children, were talking and laughing about something which had happened, Mrs. Grey, who is a perfect home-hermit, said, in a jocose way, ‘When I go away for a week, I shall leave Tige to keep house.’ That meant that she should never go; and you see Willie caught up that remark, and used it to give himself away with. “But fearing that Mrs. Grey might have wanted something, I ran over to see her about it, and found out that my boy had made the entire thing up out of whole cloth. I am getting so I never know what to do when he speaks. I am almost afraid that he is lying every time.” “Have you tried to find out what was at the bottom of this one instance of untruth?” “No; I just gave up. It was so flagrant that I didn’t have the strength even to slap him.” “I wish you would please call him in, and get him to talk that over with us. You begin it in a tender, sympathetic way, and let us see what comes of it.” “I don’t feel very tender and sympathetic when I think about it; but I will try, if you think any good will come of it.” “No harm can come of it, and we may get some light for you.” “Well, light is what I want, that is sure.” After a moment of silence, in which she was evidently trying to bring herself into a proper temper, this mother arose, and going to the door, called the child, who came quickly bounding in, a bright, beautiful boy. He and I were good friends, so that I had only to hold out my hand to have him come within my arm clasp, where he stood playing with my watch-guard, and waiting to see what it all meant. “O Willie,” began his mother, bravely, “what about that cake for Mrs. Grey? What company is she going to have? and when is it to be?” “O can we have it, mama?” And how his eyes sparkled. “‘Cause if we can, I must go and build up the house quick, where Tige broke it down, you know, and I must run and tell her; for I am her company, you see.” That was all the mother could say for at least a minute. Light had broken in. But at last she asked, almost indignantly, “Willie, why could you not have told me that you were playing, and that Mrs. Grey was Nelly?” “’Cause I wasn’t playing, mama. It was ‘honest Injun,’ and she is just Mrs. Grey. Nelly is gone.” “O, to Europe, I guess, where children is before they’s born.” “Indeed! I thought you were company.” “Yes, I am Mrs. Grey’s company, and my train is awful slow. Toot! toot! toot! Say, mama, can’t I have some of that chocolate cake?” “Yes, dear; mama will put you up a nice dinner to take home to Mrs. Grey. So you are a traveling man, and just getting home, are you? Mama is very glad that she understands you at last.” The child in his eagerness had slipped out to the commissary department, and the mother said, in a husky voice, “Just to think that I accused him of lying! But he seems to have forgotten it.” “Ask him please, my dear, if he has. See what he thought about that.” “I’ll ask his pardon,” she replied. So she called him back, saying, “Come here to mama, dear,” and she drew him closely to her. “When you told me about Mrs. Grey yesterday, I could not understand you, Willie, and I told you that you were lying. I am very sorry.” The child turned his face up and looked at her. Her eyes were full of tears. He did not like tears. The tone which she had, used as well as the words, was very perplexing, so he began to wriggle out of her arms. “What does lying mean?” I ventured to ask. “O, that mama has a headache, I guess.” “And what is a headache?” “O, I don’t know. Just some nasty old thing that makes folks not want to do things.” Then we laughed, while tears that would come fell over our cheeks. Willie looked from one to the other for a perplexed moment or two, and then, with a long, loud “toot! toot!” called out, in his biggest voice, “Chicago! Union Depot!” Need I add that a few moments later the little man was on his way “home” to repair the ruin which Tige had wrought by his housekeeping, and happy with the cake-basket well filled for “Mrs. Grey,” while his mother, for the first time in her life, began to see that child study was a necessary preliminary to child culture. The next thing in this case was to teach the child the necessity of so stating facts and fancies that he should be understood by older people. “You see, Willie,” the lesson ran, “when you said ‘Mrs. Grey,’ mama, of course, thought you meant the real one, who is always Mrs. Grey; and mama knew that Mrs. Grey never allowed Tige in the house, that she would never leave him to keep house, and so mama thought it was all something that had never happened, and that you were telling a naughty story,—a lie about the cake and all,—and it made mama feel very discouraged. If you had just told her at first that you were playing that Nelly was Mrs. Grey,—” “But, mama,” broke in the child, with a plaintive persistence in his tone, “we was not playing that time; sometimes we is, but we said first thing that this was all truly, and not play.405 She was Mrs. Grey, and I was Mr. Grey for sure.” “Well, you see that you will be obliged to say it so that others will understand you, if you expect to be heard, and get what you want; for when it comes to truly, truly, you are not Mr. Grey, and Nelly is not Mrs. Grey. Now try to see if you can’t fix that some way so that it will be all straight as you mean it, and so that mama can know what you mean.” The child thought a moment, and then said: “I can’t fix it anyhow. That’s the way ’tis,—just Mrs. Grey.” “Well, all right; let it go until you really want something.” It was not long; for the two children were very busy in their play world. Soon Willie came rushing in to his mother, calling, in great eagerness, “Doctor! doctor! you must come quick. Mrs. Grey has broken her arm.” This appeal brought no reply, and he repeated it, pulling at his mother’s hand. “What are you doing, Willie?” she asked, at last; “there is no doctor here, and Dr. Smith is always called to the Greys.” “O, I forgot. It is my little Mrs. Grey, mama, and you is the doctor. I’s playing truly. Now do you understand me, mama?” “Yes, dear, you have done bravely. Now what would you like?” “You to come, for she’s truly hurted. She fell off the top of our house,—I mean she hit her toe and fell down,—the truly top is the sky, I guess.” This little story is sufficient, I think, to indicate the beginnings of instruction by which a child may be taught to discriminate between the literal and the symbolic in speech. This is a lesson which cannot be too early taught, especially to a child who has a quick imagination, and is full of “play.”