THE CENTER OF INTERNATIONAL DISTURBANCE.
The following analysis of the czar’s proposal as to the disarmament of the nations is by the London correspondent of Harper’s Weekly, one of the soundest thinkers on international matters. There can be no doubt that it presents the true view of the situation:— “Russia has always posed as the advocate of humanity; and the strange emotionalism of the Slav nature constantly lends itself to enthusiastic support of misty generalities, which Russians are not prepared to apply to their own persons and interests. “There is no reason to suppose that the young czar is insincere in his impulsive appeal to the powers to forget the lessons of Russian deeds, and accept the counsels of Russian words. History suggests caution. In 1874 the rules of civilized warfare were revised, and rendered more stringent, at the instance of Czar Alexander II. The message read on that occasion by Baron Jomini to the delegates at Brussels declared that the object of His Majesty ‘is, above everything, an object of humanity,’ and included such phrases as the following: ‘It is to be hoped that the progress of enlightenment and of manners will render war more and more rare. . . . No government would to-day undertake it lightly. . . . War can not be the normal state of nations. . . . It is only a painful exception. . . . The rule is pacific relations, which soften the manners by uniting the interests of nations.’ The convention was signed. Russia’s humanitarian aspirations were satisfied on paper. But a few months later she was massacring the Yomud Turkomans, the Russian commander having instructions to spare neither age nor sex. The reason for the massacre was that the Turkomans could not raise three hundred thousand rubles within a fortnight. Baron Jomini’s phrases did not apply to the Turkomans. Since then Russia has reduced six million of her Jewish population to the extremity of misery and despair. As I write these lines, the British government is allowing Cyprus to be used as a sanctuary and an asylum for the Russian Doukhobortsi, a sect of blameless and humane people, whose crime is that they resemble, in their hatred of war, the followers of the founder of Pennsylvania. “The czar admits that the armaments of Europe are defensive, and that the outlay he stigmatizes as frightful arises from a sense of self-preservation. Where is the aggressor? What nation is the notorious cause of Europe’s being an armed camp? America is not the malcontent. Her army is insufficient to police her possessions beyond the sea. Her navy is unequal to the requirements of an imperial power. England is not the firebrand. The real charge against John Bull is that he is too indolent and obese to stir on his own behalf. Germany covets no territory in Europe belonging to her neighbors. To Austria, war could only spell ruin. Spain has had as much fighting as she can digest for some time to come. Turkey asks only to be let alone. Italy is more intent on the demands of her creditors than on the extension of frontiers which are delimited by nature. “Only two powers remain. One is ruled by the czar ‘peacemaker,’ with an army which, on a peace footing, numbers over a million of men, and a navy avowedly aggressive. Without colonies, vulnerable coast-line, or over-sea trade, Russian sea power is incompatible with her professions of peace. With this navy and this army, Russia not only violates treaties, but makes treaties to violate them. Russia has imposed on England the burden of her own militarism by compelling us to add tens of millions of pounds to our annual expenditure, in order to provide force to repel the attacks of a power whose international conduct places her on the circumference, if not outside, of the circle of civilization. Russia has encouraged France in her dream of reconquest. Russia came to an agreement with Austria regarding the condition of the small states in the Balkan Peninsula, and broke her pledge before the ink was dry. The last public act of this peace-loving Russia was to send ship-loads of rifles and cartridges to the Montenegrins. This is the power that invites the nations of the world to abate their armaments! The fox in the fable made the same proposals to the lion and the tiger. If Æsop had survived to bring his work up to date, he would have changed his fox into a bear. “Nobody threatens Russia. She is safe in Europe behind the guns and torpedoes of Kronstadt and the Black Sea. Russia can therefore begin the game of disarmament, and the question of her sincerity will thus be put to the touch without delay. The young emperor is an amiable and kindly man, overwhelmed with a sense of responsibility, and surrounded by a ring of astute and determined advisers, who are not publicly known to have accepted the sermon on the mount as their practical guide in life. Lacking decision of character, and being in poor health, the czar is at the mercy of his advisers, who quarrel among themselves with a vigor that would do no discredit to countries blessed with constitutional systems of government. When the advice given him is good, the czar’s policy is creditable. The advice of M. Goremykine, the minister of the interior, an enlightened and capable statesman, as a rule reflects credit on the sovereign and his government. When the advice received is evil, as in the case of foreign affairs, the results are evil. Count Muravieff is brilliant, but superficial. No far-sighted diplomatist could have made such a needless exhibition of Russian perfidy as Count Muravieff and his agents have done since he succeeded Prince Lobanoff. Prince Ouchtomsky, a private friend and adviser of the czar, and his traveling companion in India and the Far East, is a bitter Anglophobe, and, according to his own written statements, is intent on building the structure of Russian power in Asia on the ruins of England. The czar has chosen to accept the advice of Count Muravieff and of Prince Ouchtomsky. He will reap what he has sown. England is not at heart with Lord Salisbury. “The rescript, so far as it is not the result of the czarina’s good heart, is doubtless due to M. Witte’s representations as to the incapacity of Russian finances to support the strain involved by Count Muravieff’s foreign policy. The manifesto, therefore, however Christlike636 in its language, is Machiavellian in fact; it appears at an opportune moment for Russia. The perennial famine is even worse this year than usual. The peasantry will need help. The attempt to plant a gold standard on an agricultural country already shakes the structure of Russian credit to its foundations. War with a first-class power during the next five years might easily expose the divine figure of the North with theatrical results. Its hands may be of iron and its forehead brass, but the feet are of clay. After a full meal in China, a period of repose is opportune. Russia is as one who says grace over stolen mutton. The pious of all lands burn with admiration and approval of the grace. They forget the origin of the mutton. I believe the reason of this to be our indifference as a nation to the teaching of history.”