THE REFLEX EFFECT OF IMPERIALISM

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 31, 1899

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 5.

Read the full edition

THE REFLEX EFFECT OF IMPERIALISM.

WITH the politics or the candidacy of Hon. W. J. Bryan, or anybody else, we have nothing whatever to do. But in the fundamental principles — the Protestant and republican principles — of this nation, we are deeply concerned; for in the preservation or abandonment of these principles by this nation is involved the weal or the woe of the world. And the following remarks of Mr. Bryan at Cincinnati, Jan. 6, 1899, are wise and weighty; and are worthy of serious consideration: especially the point which he makes as to the reflex effect of imperial rule in the Philippines. Every time this imperialism is examined, the more plainly appears the fact that in it this nation is on the high road to the repudiation of every principle of its Constitution as a republican government:—
The forcible annexation of the Philippine Islands would violate a principle of American public law so deeply imbedded in the American mind that until a year ago no public man would have suggested it. It is difficult to overestimate the influence which such a change in our national policy would produce on the character of our people. Our opponents ask, Is our nation not great enough to do what England, Germany, and Holland are doing? They inquire, Can we not govern colonies as well as they?
Whether we can govern colonies as well as other countries can is not material; the real question is whether we can, in one hemisphere, develop the theory that governments derive their just power from the consent of the governed, and at the same time inaugurate, support, and defend in the other hemisphere a government which derives its authority entirely from superior force. And if these two ideas of government can not live together, which one shall we choose?
There is an old saying that it is not profitable to buy a lawsuit. Our nation may learn by experience that it is not wise to purchase the right to conquer a people. Spain under compulsion gives us a quitclaim to the Philippines in return for $20,000,000; but she does not agree to warrant and defend our title as against the Filipinos. To buy land is one thing, to buy people is another. Land is inanimate, and makes no resistance to a transfer of title; the people are animate; and sometimes desire a voice in their own affairs.
But whether, measured by dollars and cents, the conquest of the Philippines would prove profitable or expensive, it will certainly prove embarrassing to those who still hold to the doctrines which underlie a republic. Military rule is antagonistic to our theory of government. The arguments which are used to defend it in the Philippines may be used to excuse it in the United States. Under military rule much must be left to the discretion of the military governor; and this can be justified only upon the theory that the governor knows more than the people whom he governs, is better acquainted with their needs than they are themselves, is entirely in sympathy with them, and is thoroughly honest and unselfish in his desire to do them good. Such a combination of wisdom, integrity, and love is difficult to find.
If we enter upon a colonial policy, we must expect to hear the command “Silence!” issuing with increasing emphasis from the imperialists. When the discussion of fundamental principles is attempted in the United States, if a member of Congress attempts to criticize any injustice perpetrated by a government official against a helpless people, he will be warned to keep silent, lest his criticism encourage resistance to American authority in the Orient. If an orator on the Fourth of July dares to speak of inalienable rights, or refers with commendation to the manner in which our forefathers resisted taxation without representation, he will be warned to keep silent, lest his utterances excite rebellion among distant subjects. If we adopt a colonial policy, and pursue the course which excited the Revolution of 1776, we must muffle the tones of the old liberty bell, and commune in whispers when we praise the patriotism of our forefathers.
We can not afford to destroy the Declaration of Independence; we can not afford to erase from our constitutions, State and national, the Bill of Rights, we have not time to examine the libraries of the nation, and purge them of the essays, the speeches, and the books that defend the doctrine that law is the crystallization of public opinion, rather than an emanation from physical power.
But even if we could destroy every vestige of the laws which are the outgrowth of the immortal law penned by Jefferson; if we could obliterate every written word that has been inspired by the idea that this is a “government of the people, by the people, and for the people,” we could not tear from the heart of the human race the hope which the American Republic has planted there. The impassioned appeal “Give me liberty, or give me death,” still echoes around the world. In the future, as in the past, the desire to be free will be stronger than the desire to enjoy a mere physical existence.