MR. GAMBLE'S SUPERFICIAL READING.
By Alonzo T. Jones
The readers of the REVIEW are somewhat acquainted with the efforts of Mr. S. W. Gamble in telling what he does not know about the Sabbath coming annually each week. Last May he followed up his efforts in this line by telling a good deal that he does not know about me. I have not cared enough about what he has told, of what he does not know, about the Sabbath coming annually once a week, to take any notice of it since his publication of it, about two years ago, in the Christian Endeavorer as a “great discovery,” which was to take away from Seventh-day Adventists all reason of existence. And I do not care enough about what he does not know about me, even to mention it, except for the fact that he makes this a basis for employing and emphasizing a few sentences that I have written,—utterly perverting the plain meaning,—to bolster up and make acceptable what he does not know about the Sabbath coming annually once a week. However, what he has published of what he does not know about me is a splendid illustration of the value of the theory which he has propounded, and of what he has written upon it, as to his great discovery of the Seventh-day Sabbath coming annually every week. What he has said about me is as follows:— While Brother Smith assails me upon the correct interpretation of Lev. 23:15, 16, I will meet this argument by proving that my interpretation is true by the highest authority of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. In the debate before the Senate Committee when the Blair Sunday Rest bill was under consideration (a bill asked for by seven million actual petitioners, and defended by W. F. Crafts, the National W. C. T. U., through Mrs. J. E. Bateham and others), Alonzo T. Jones succeeded in crushing the same, and causing the committee to report unfavorably upon the bill. Thenceforward he has ranked among them as one of their best debaters. Encouraged by their victory, the Advents put forward this new champion of Sabbatarianism to write against what they call the strongest books in the English language upholding Sunday as the Sabbath. Dartmouth College offered a prize of five hundred dollars for the best book in defense of Sunday sacredness, and the prize was awarded to a manuscript by Elliot,—“The Abiding Sabbath.” This was followed by the American Sunday-School Union’s offering one thousand dollars for the best book on that subject, which was awarded to “The Lord’s Day,” by Waffle. The Adventists reasoned that these rewards had drawn out the strongest arguments on the Christian-sabbath side, so they put up the new champion of their ranks to write a review of these books. In getting at the meaning of the word “sabbath” in the verses I am criticized about by Mr. Smith, I have only to quote Mr. Jones, now his editorial colleague, in vindication of my claim. He says (paragraph 67): “On the morrow after this fifteenth day of the month—this sabbath—the wave-sheaf of the first-fruits was offered before the Lord; and with that day—the sixteenth day of the month—they began to count fifty days, and when they reached the fiftieth day, that was Pentecost.” Paragraphs 66, 67, he says: “The word ‘pentecost’ signifies the fiftieth day, and was always counted, beginning with the sixteenth day of the first month. It is also called the feast of weeks, because it was seven complete weeks from the day of offering of the first-fruits, which was the second day of the feast of unleavened bread, the sixteenth day of the first month.” . . . This same champion gives us the correct name for these seven sabbaths in his most favored child, “Rome’s Challenge.” The International Religious Liberty Association publishes the most carefully guarded doctrinal literature of that church. At the General Conference, 1893, they decided that “no literature shall be published or circulated under the name of this society by any of its officers or members until it has been endorsed by the executive committee of the association.”—Art. 2, By-laws of the Association, General Conference Minutes, page 126. Alonzo T. Jones was the editor of the official organ of the association. He edited “Rome’s Challenge” from four articles published in the Catholic Mirror in September, 1893, by Senex, and caused it to be examined by the committee elected by the General Conference of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, and after its approval, he had it published as one of the International Religious Liberty Association Library periodicals, and pushed its sale until in a short time it had reached a sale of over 500,000 copies, thus making it the most soundly doctrinal tract, and at the same time the most popular tract, of the association and of the church. On page 17 he says: “Pentecost is the fiftieth day after the Passover, which was called the Sabbath of weeks, consisting of seven times seven days; and the day after the completion of the seventh weekly Sabbath day.” You notice here that he makes Abib 15 the weekly Sabbath; and the next seven weekly Sabbaths of fixed date, and places the day of Pentecost on the next day after the completion of the seventh weekly Sabbath. We return now to his prize review, page 66, where he says: “And everybody knows that the Pentecost came on each day of the week in succession as the years passed by, the same day as does Christmas or the Fourth of July, or any other yearly celebration.” So that it is very clear that since Pentecost came the next day after the weekly Sabbath, and came on every day of our week in succession as the years passed by, the Sabbath, “the weekly Sabbath,” which was the day before, did the same thing. Having proved the case by the highest Sabbatarian authority in the world, I will omit the scores of better witnesses which might be produced to prove that the word “sabbath” in Lev. 23:15 was a day of fixed date,—Abib 15,—and that the seven Sabbaths were seven successive Sabbaths of fixed dates. The most of this will be news to every Seventh-day Adventist in the world. That I am, or ever was, the highest authority in the Seventh-day Adventist Church; that I have ranked among them as one of their best debaters; that I succeeded in crushing the Blair Sunday Rest bill; that, encouraged by this victory, the “Advents put forward” me, “this new champion of Sabbatarianism, to write against what they call the strongest books in the English language, upholding Sunday as the Sabbath”—all this will be news to all the Seventh-day Adventists. And it will all be especially newsy because it is all so far from being true,—at least as far as Seventh-day Adventists know.74 I am not, and never was, either the highest or any other authority of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. That I succeeded in crushing the Blair Sunday Rest bill, and causing the committee to report unfavorably upon it,—if it be true,—is far more than I know; and I never heard of such a thing before, except from an old lady Covenanter of Washington, Iowa. I did not believe it then, and do not believe it now. True, I was there, and had something to do with it; but that I did all that, is a good deal more than I, or all the Seventh-day Adventists in the world, have claimed, or ever can claim. That since the discussion of the Blair bill with Senator Blair, I have been ranked among the Adventists as one of their best debaters, is also news to all of us. I never had but four debates in my life; three of these were before this occurred. Two of these were merely local occurrences where I happened to be preaching. For the other one—the only one the brethren had anything to do with—I was the last choice and was taken then only because they could not get any others wanted. The other debate, though after the discussion of the Blair Sunday bill, was sprung suddenly by a gentleman’s rising in the congregation where I had made a speech, and asking for a discussion of a certain point. The requested discussion was arranged off-hand, right there, and occurred accordingly; it was merely a local matter, with which the church had nothing to do in arranging, endorsing, or ranking me as one of their best debaters. But now I come to one of the strangest points in this whole matter. Mr. Gamble, referring to this crushing of the Blair bill by me, says that, “encouraged by their victory, the Advents put forth this new champion of Sabbatarianism to write against what they call the strongest books in the English language, upholding Sunday as the Sabbath;” then refers to these two prize essays,—the “Abiding Sabbath” and “The Lord’s Day,”—and continues: “The Advents reasoned that these rewards had drawn out the strongest arguments on the Christian-sabbath side, so they put up the new champion of their ranks to write a review of these books.” Now the discussion of the Blair bill occurred Dec. 13, 1888. My review of both these prize essays was written, and first published, between Jan. 15 and June 3, 1886. Now the mind that can make out that because of my opposition to the Blair bill, Dec. 13, 1888, Seventh-day Adventists chose me to write a review which was written and published two and one-half years before that,—well, it ought not to be difficult for a mind that could do that, also to make out that the seventh-day Sabbath occurs annually every week. But more than this, that the Seventh-day Adventists chose me to write that review, even when I did write it, is not true. I did that altogether myself, and nobody knew of it until I began to write it. It came about thus (this I know; for I was there): in January, 1886, I was one of the assistant editors of the Signs of the Times. The Dartmouth College prize essay, “The Abiding Sabbath,” by Elliot, came to my notice. I read it, and decided to review it. I was absent from the Signs of the Times, teaching in Healdsburg College. Not even the other editors of the Signs of the Times knew anything of it until I had written my first instalment, and sent it to the office as copy. While I was writing the review of this essay, the thousand-dollar prize essay by Waffle came to my attention. When I had finished reviewing the five-hundred-dollar prize essay, with an interval of only a week I began the review of the one-thousand-dollar prize essay, just as I began the other, without anybody’s knowledge or initiative but my own. And as before stated, it was all done, written, and published, between Jan. 15 and June 3, 1886. Then the Pacific Press Pub. Co. decided to print the articles in pamphlet form, which they did in the latter part of 1886. But this was done by the publishing committee, merely as such, without any action by, or any knowledge of, the denomination as such. This is the straight truth of the writing of that review of the prize essays. And the facts in this matter demonstrate that Mr. Gamble is a very superficial reader. And anybody who has read his scheme respecting the Sabbath knows full well that this matter is a fair illustration of his superficial reading in that matter. A second edition of my review of the prize essays was issued by the Pacific Press in 1889. Mr. Gamble may say that it was this edition that he had, and that he was misled by the date 1889. Yet if he does make any such plea, it only the further demonstrates his superficial reading; because the edition of 1889 is dated January 8, in plain print on the face of the cover. Jan. 8, 1889, is just twenty-six days after Dec. 13, 1888. The discussion of the Blair Sunday Rest bill shows that I was in Washington City, Dec. 13, 1888. Therefore in order for that review to come out in twenty-six days, the Seventh-day Adventists must, after the discussion of the Blair bill, choose me to write the review of the prize essays; I must study the prize essays sufficiently to be able to review them intelligently; I must write matter enough for one hundred and seventy-three pages, or about fifty-two thousand words; it must be sent to Oakland, Cal., which would take at least five days; the type be set; the printing all be done, and the pamphlet issued,—all inside of twenty-three working days. By all human consideration that is an impossible thing, and demonstrates that there is no possible refuge for Mr. Gamble in any plea of being misled by the date 1889. So that the whole matter, from beginning to end, demonstrates his superficial reading. Now he has cited all these things that are not so as the basis of a quotation from my review of the prize essays, referring to Pentecost, that “on the morrow after this fifteenth day of the month—this sabbath—the wave-sheaf of the first-fruits was to be offered before the Lord: and with that day—the sixteenth day of the month—they were to begin to count fifty days; and when they reached the fiftieth day, that was Pentecost.” The expression “this sabbath” in that statement does not refer at all to the weekly Sabbath. It was never intended to, and never did, refer to it. The statement refers solely to the fifteenth day of the first month, the first day of the feast of unleavened bread, which, according to Lev. 23:7, was an annual convocation, feast-day, or sabbath. It is this first day of the feast of unleavened bread—this annual sabbath—that is, and always was, referred to in the quotation made by Mr. Gamble. I said “this sabbath,” not “the Sabbath.” I said “this sabbath,” with a small “s,” not the Sabbath, with a capital. I never use a small “s” in writing or printing the Sabbath, but always a capital “S.” The whole passage reads as follows:— The word “pentecost” signifies “the fiftieth day,” and was always counted, beginning with the sixteenth day of the first month. It is also called “the feast of weeks,” because it was seven complete weeks from the day of the offering of the first-fruits, which was the second day of the feast of unleavened bread, the sixteenth day of the first month. On the fourteenth day of the first month, all leaven was to be put away from all the houses. They were to kill the passover lamb in the evening of the fourteenth; and with it, at the beginning of the fifteenth day of the month, they were to begin to eat the unleavened bread, and the feast of unleavened bread was to continue until the twenty-second day of the month. The first day of the feast—that is, the fifteenth of the month—was to be a sabbath; no servile work was to be done in that day. Ex. 12:6–8, 15–19; Lev. 23:5–7. Because of the putting away of the leaven on the fourteenth day, and the beginning to eat the unleavened bread on the evening of that day, it is sometimes referred to as the first day of unleavened bread; but the fifteenth day was really the first, and was the one on which no servile work was to be done. On “the morrow” after this fifteenth day of the month—this sabbath—the wave-sheaf of the first-fruits was to be offered before the Lord; and with that day—the sixteenth day of the month—they were to begin to count fifty days; and when they reached the fiftieth day, that was Pentecost. This again demonstrates Mr. Gamble’s superficial reading. But if this is so by all that we have examined so far, what shall be said of what follows? He refers to “Rome’s Challenge,” and says that I edited it. That, at last, is one thing that he has said that is true. As is well known, the text of “Rome’s Challenge” is matter reprinted bodily from the Catholic Mirror, and was written by a Catholic. What the editor did was to attach occasional notes; and of these notes there are nine, and every one of them is signed “En.” All but one are in small type at the foot of the page: the other one, being something over two pages in length, is inserted in brackets, with the side-head “Note,” at the beginning, and signed “En,” at the end, on pages 27 and 30. Now Mr. Gamble professes to quote what I said in “Rome’s Challenge.” He quotes from page 17; but lo! he quotes from the text, the words of the original Catholic writing; and not a word of mine at all. And this, too, in the face of the fact that on that same page, referring to this very point, stands a note by the editor signed regularly “En.” Assuredly, after this, nothing is needed—this certainly caps the climax—in demonstration of Mr. Gamble’s superficial reading. And when that is so fully demonstrated, and in so little space, this will be satisfactory evidence to every thoughtful reader that the whole scheme of his great discovery of the seventh-day Sabbath coming annually every week is but the result of the same sort of inexcusably superficial reading of the Scriptures.75