AdventAI

EATING GAME THAT IS “HIGH.”

From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 7., February 14, 1899

The following from the New York Tribune “Illustrated Supplement” of Sunday, Jan. 29, 1899, gives points that are valuable in themselves, and emphasize what we have already said on this subject: especially the statement of Dr. Morris that there are in meat alcoholic products, and that these are increased by the “aging” of the meat:—

Two conundrums have occurred to thoughtful people since the discovery that some of the beef offered by contractors to the Commissary Department of the Army last summer was not fit to eat. One is, How far does the condition of that meat differ from that of a good deal of mutton and game that is knowingly eaten by persons in a position to choose for themselves? The other is, Why do no injurious results attend indulgence in game that is kept until it is “high”?

Butchers and marketmen tell stories, that to the uninitiated are rather startling, about the way in which meat and birds are kept before being eaten. Some of the practices in question are more general in Europe than in America, but they are sufficiently common here to be beyond dispute. Beef is not considered fit to eat until it is three or four weeks old. Mutton is often kept for six and even for twelve months after killing; the only precaution observed, in some instances, being to protect it from flies. No special pains is taken to keep it in a cool place. Of course, there is a marked difference in mutton in this respect. The flesh of some sheep will dry and shrink away if exposed to the open air, whereas other mutton may hang for months without losing weight, but will distinctly gain in quality meantime.

Venison is treated in much the same way, except that here in New York the laws afford so short a season in which deer’s meat may be kept and exposed that it is not subjected to so severe a test. But in regard to hares, rabbits, and birds, one hears still more remarkable statements. Woodcocks and pheasants, for instance, are sometimes kept for weeks—and not in cold storage, either—before being served. The feathers are left on, and the birds are not dressed. Thus the natural moisture remains in them. If dressed like ordinary poultry, they would shrivel and waste. It is asserted that in some of these birds decomposition sets in, affecting only certain parts that are not to be eaten, and that then the remainder—more especially the legs and breast—is in just the best possible condition for eating. And of hares it is solemnly declared that they are never so appetizing to the gourmand as when there is danger of blood-poisoning from the operation of skinning them, and the flesh is so tender that it falls apart at the touch.

But when one investigates this subject carefully, he learns that the chief purpose for which mutton, beef, and game are kept is to render them tender. The choicest cut from a fat young steer would be as tough as leather if it were served within twenty-four hours after the creature was killed. The main reason for which any meat is kept for weeks or months after killing is that so doing makes it easier to eat and extract the juices therefrom.

Dr. Robert T. Morris, who is an expert in such matters, as well as a famous sportsman, talked in an instructive and entertaining way to a Tribune man one day last week. He said, substantially:—

“The flavor of meat has two sources. First, there are certain volatile products—mainly sulphur alcohols and sulphur ethers—that are formed in the flesh by the chemistry of the animal itself. Secondly, various kinds of bacteria produce another set of substances, which, perhaps, are not very different chemically from the first, but are formed more abundantly. The latter are more agreeable to the taste.

“An excellent illustration of this phenomenon is afforded by the ripening of some of our choicest cheeses. The manufacturers introduce into these cheeses specially chosen species of bacteria. In a general way it may be said that all cheeses that have strong and peculiar odors have been the media for the culture of selected bacteria. And however much tastes may differ as to the appetizing character of such articles of food, no one questions their healthfulness.

“With meats, as with cheeses, a flavor that is agreeable to one person may be offensive to another. The edibility of a thing, within certain limits, depends on the individual taste. But beyond a certain point; in the case of meats, it is possible that the products of bacterial action may be poisonous. Eventually, a class of substances is formed, known as toxins, or ptomains, that are likely to make some persons sick. People differ greatly in their susceptibility to these agents. Hence it is difficult to speak with precision on this point. I am inclined to think, however, that when any meat, whether beef, mutton, or game, offends the taste and smell of an individual, it has become unsafe for him; but it may still be harmless for others to whom it has not yet become offensive.

“I can think of one set of circumstances that appear to be especially conducive to the production of ptomains. Ordinarily there are several kinds of bacteria in meat, working in the manner described. These keep up such a warfare with one another that no one species gains an ascendancy over the others. But when meat is put into a cold-storage warehouse, the low temperature checks activity on the part of most of the bacteria. It does not kill them, but merely inhibits manufacturing operations. But at least one species appears to remain comparatively unaffected by the cold, and unfortunately this is capable of producing toxins that are likely to make mischief. Hence, a certain amount of danger attends the use of game that has been kept in this manner.”

From these and other facts that might be enumerated it would appear that the line which divides actual decomposition and a certain other stage of ripeness is not easily defined in the unscientific mind, and that a good deal of game has in the past been eaten, with comparative impunity, which had undergone so great a change of flavor and odor as to provoke suspicion, yet which had not really developed any appreciable quantity of poisonous ptomains. The nose of an epicure may tell him that a woodcock has just reached a condition that will be particularly agreeable to his palate, and he may deceive himself into thinking that a necessity for disinfectants exists when such is not the case. It would be going too far, perhaps, to insist that such a statement covers all indulgences in game that has been pronounced “high.”