The New York Independent of Feb. 9, 1899, prints this: “Twelve years ago, Charles Burrell, a boy living in Chicago, was struck on the head by a playmate. He became insane, and was placed in an asylum. On February 1, the X-rays having revealed a growth on the inner surface of his skull at the point where the blow was received, Burrell was subjected to an operation. The growth was removed, and he was put to bed. The next day he awoke in full possession of his faculties, and his first words were: ‘Why did you hit me?’ The twelve years had been a blank, and he resumed the life of a rational being, at the point where it had been interrupted.” Yet the claim of the immortality of the soul is that if that blow had destroyed all consciousness in that boy,—that is, if it had killed him,—he would have known more than ever before! What a fraud and an imposture the theory of the immortality of the soul, the consciousness of the dead, is, to be sure! And how aptly this case illustrates the Scriptural truth of the sleep and resurrection of the dead. Life as a rational being is resumed exactly at the point where it had been interrupted. That is the truth.
Boy's Twelve-Year Blank and the Dead's Sleep
From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 9., February 28, 1899