AdventAI

THE OLDER BROTHERS OF JESUS.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 38., September 20, 1898

Since the issue of the August SUPPLEMENT to the REVIEW AND HERALD, we have received a daily shower of letters making inquiry concerning a certain passage therein quoted from the forthcoming book, “The Desire of Ages.” The passage relates to Jesus, and reads as follows:—

“All this displeased his brothers. Being older than Jesus, they felt that he should be under their dictation. They charged him with thinking himself superior to them,” etc.

All these inquirers want to know how this can be. None of them believe it. Some want to know if it is not a misprint. Others suggest something else; and yet others, still something else.

The point in this quotation at which all these folks stumble, is where it is said that “his brothers, being older than Jesus,” etc. By not believing it they “can not understand” how this could possibly be, when the Bible says always that Jesus was Mary’s first-born son.

We suppose these inquiries are sent to us under the impression that perhaps we may have access to other writings from the same author on the same subject, that might make the matter plain to those who are disturbed over it. For surely this matter, being the statement of the Spirit of prophecy, no one would suppose that any but the Spirit of prophecy could explain it, provided it needs explaining at all.

We are not at all displeased at receiving so many letters; we enjoy it; besides, it shows that not only is the REVIEW read, but its supplements also. So we shall do our best to help our inquiring friends.

First, we do not see how there can be any misprint in the sentence. Of course misprints do occur sometimes; but in such cases the mistake is always in misprinting a word, which changes the sense of the sentence. It is not possible that that could be the case here. The word here upon which the whole subject turns, and where the misprint would have to be if there were any, is the word “older.” But to say that this should be printed “younger” instead of “older” would take all the substance out of the subject as it is in the two sentences.

If it were printed “younger” instead of “older,” it would present the incongruous and even unnatural situation of his younger brothers feeling “that he should be under their dictation;” and of his younger brothers charging him with “thinking himself superior to them.” If they were indeed younger than Jesus, then there could be no possible ground for his being under their dictation. If he was indeed older than they, in the very nature of things, as well as by all the provisions of the Levitical law and the unvaried custom of that whole people from their beginning, he would be superior to them, and would be so recognized; and that being so, there could be no possible ground for their charging him “with thinking himself superior to them.”

But with the sentence as it stands,—“His brothers being older than Jesus,”—it was also natural enough that they should feel “that he should be under their dictation.” And when they found that he would not be so to their satisfaction, it was also perfectly natural that they, “being older than Jesus,” should charge him “with thinking himself superior to them.”

Therefore as the sentences in all their parts are intelligible and consistent only as they stand,—“his brothers, being older than Jesus;” and as that is the way the sentences stand in the book from which the passage in the SUPPLEMENT was taken, the suggestion of misprint is certainly excluded. Everything about the passage bears positive evidence that it is printed as it was originally written; and that it was intentionally written as it stands, saying that the brothers of Jesus were older than he.

The theory of a misprint being excluded, the real point in all these letters of inquiry is, “Is it true?” It is perfectly plain, from the letters themselves, that the inquirers do not believe that it is true. Some of them, indeed, say flatly that they want nothing to do with the book that says such a thing. One in particular says, “If that is the book that is for sale, I do not want it;” and then in the very same letter, says, “Please send the latest Special Testimonies to Workers and Ministers.” But it is difficult to see what he can want with the Special Testimonies, or any other Testimonies, when he rejects a whole book that comes from the same source as do all the Testimonies, special or other. The Testimonies can do no good to people who do not believe them; for “prophesying serveth not for them that believe not, but for them which believe.” 1 Cor. 14:22. A person can not believe the Testimonies, and at the same time reject a whole book of the Spirit of prophecy. He may think he believes them; but he does not truly believe them; he believes them only so far as hep. 606 can approve them, only so far as they agree with his own opinions.

And just this, we are sorry to say, is the difficulty with many of those whose inquiries we are now considering. They know that the book, “The Desire of Ages,” comes from the Spirit of prophecy; they profess to believe the Spirit of prophecy; and yet the instant they find a statement from that book which they can not endorse,—a statement that does not agree with their own views,—they do not believe it, and “do not understand it,” and want an explanation of “how it can be.” When the angel told Zacharias a certain thing, and Zacharias said, “Whereby shall I know this? for,” etc., the angel told him, “Thou believest not my words.” Luke 1:13-20. Do we believe the Spirit of prophecy, or not? If we do, when that Spirit speaks, we shall believe what is said, whether we understand it or not. What the Spirit says is the truth; and believing it, we believe the truth and know the truth, even if we do not understand it so we can explain just the “how” of it.

So it is with this passage that has called forth so many inquiries: by every evidence the passage was intentionally written to tell, and does tell, that the brothers of Jesus were “older” than he. This, being the statement of the Spirit of prophecy, is the truth. He who believes it, believes the truth, and knows the truth, whether he can explain it or not. Of course any one who does not believe it can never understand it, even though the Spirit himself should explain it. But to those who believe it, all is easy enough.

1. He knows that it is the truth.

2. He knows that the place where he read it is in a very brief extract from a book of more than seven hundred pages; and he knows that it is possible, and altogether likely, that somewhere in the complete work, something is said to make it all plain and perfectly satisfactory.

3. He knows that even just as it stands, it in no way contradicts the Bible. For though the Bible says always that Jesus was Mary’s first-born son, this passage from “Desire of Ages” does not say that he was not her first-born son. Though the passage from “Desire of Ages” does say that the brothers of Jesus were older than he, that passage does not say that he was not her first-born son.

4. He knows, just as certainly as he will think, that Jesus could be Mary’s first-born son, and yet that his brothers could be older than he; for he knows that such things are common everywhere. There are families everywhere in which the wife has brought forth her first-born son; and yet in that same family there are brothers older than this first-born of his mother. In other words, he knows that there are numberless instances in the great human family, in which a man with children has been left a widower, and has married a second wife, and that this second wife has brought forth her first-born son in a family where there were children older than he; and that they all call him brother, and he calls them brothers and sisters, because that is what they are. Surely when such things are familiar in every neighborhood, it must be a peculiarly persistent sort of unbelief that gets into difficulty and confusion over a statement in a book, that in a certain family there were brothers older than the first-born son of his mother; and will reject the book because it says so.

But some of these may ask, Does the book say that this is how it was? Outside of the passage here under consideration, we do not know that it does, because we have not seen the whole book. But this passage itself says it; because there is no other possible way in which there can be, in the same family, brothers older than the first-born son of his mother.

However, we have seen, on another page, the following sentences, which suggest the same thing that the passage under consideration tells:—

“By her [Mary’s] vindication of what she knew to be right in his conduct, she herself was brought into trying positions. She looked upon the associations of the home, and the mother’s tender watch-care over her children, as of vital importance in the formation of character. The sons and daughters of Joseph knew this; and, by appealing to her anxiety, they tried to correct the practises of Jesus according to their standard.”

As a matter of fact, this passage tells nothing more, and indeed nothing else, on that subject, than does the other passage; but it does tell the same thing that the other tells. It is possible that when we shall have access to the whole book, we may find yet more, and perhaps more plainly, said. But whether we do or not, the passage that has called forth the inquiries is plain just as it stands to every one that believes it.

We hope this incident will have aroused such an interest in that splendid book, “The Desire of Ages,” that not one of our readers will rest until he has obtained and read it, and knows just what it says on this and every other subject upon which it speaks.