AdventAI

France, Germany, and the Disputed Alsace-Lorraine Territory

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 39., September 27, 1898

It is universally agreed that the settled determination of France to recover Alsace and Lorraine, is a positive barrier to the success of the czar's proposal for disarmament. And one point in the discussion now going on is as to what can be done with Alsace and Lorraine, that will satisfy France, which is determined to have them, and Germany, which already has them. This is a good illustration of how persistently men and nations will blind their eyes. All the territory west of the Rhine was formerly Roman Gaul. When, in the fourth and fifth centuries, the Roman Empire was ruined, and taken possession of by the German nations, the first permanent inroads were made by the Franks and the Alemanni. The Franks took the territory north of the River Moselle. The Alemanni, who then were, and still are, the Germans, took the Gaulish territory south of the Moselle to Basel, which is now Alsace and Lorraine. This they held in their own right nearly two hundred years. Then Clovis, the Frank, extended the Frankish power over it. In 843, by the treaty of Verdun, it again became independent German territory. In 1648, at the close of the Thirty Years' War, by the treaty of Münster, a large part of it, and later all of it, again became French territory. In 1871 it again fell to the Germans, to whom it originally belonged. Yet France claims it as tenaciously as if it had been originally French. And doing so, how can France blame the Germans for holding fast to it, when it did originally belong to them?