A Curious Fact About Indians and the Plea of Not Guilty

50%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 25, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 43.

Read the full edition

A Curious Fact About Indians and the Plea of Not Guilty

A WRITER in the Chicago Times-Herald relates it as “a curious fact” that many of the Indians “object to pleading ‘not guilty,’ when tried in the United States Court”—when they know they are guilty. He says, “They do not understand” that the plea “not guilty” “is only a phrase.” He then cites an instance in which an Indian pleaded “guilty;” but the United States commissioner, “knowing him to be a pagan, and believing him to be drunk,” entered for him the plea “not guilty;” whereupon the Indian exclaimed, “I am guilty! Any man who says he is not guilty, when he is guilty, is a liar”! Now is it, indeed, a curious fact that an Indian, “a pagan,” should be able to understand that a lie is something more than “only a phrase”? And since it seems to be the accepted view of those who consider themselves not pagans (what are they?), that a lie “is only a phrase,” should not this, rather than the other, be considered the curious fact? If it is indeed a fact, curious or otherwise, that it is only the pagan who insists that a lie is more than only a phrase, then it is high time that those who are not pagans, whatever they are, should be taught what simple honesty is.