Sociology Students and the Lack of Historical Knowledge
THE following vigorous passage, by the editor of the Interior, is as richly deserved as it is vigorously written; and is worthy of sober consideration by our own teachers and students:— A number of the Sociological Magazine lies upon our table, and we have turned over its pages with much interest and some curiosity. A boy from our high school lately entered the Blank University; and, in answer to our inquiry as to what course he would pursue, he told us that he intended to “make a specialty of political economy and sociology.” We said little, but thought a good deal. The thing that puzzled us was how a lad who had never so much as heard of Gibbon or Macaulay or Motley or Irving, who absolutely knew as little of the great tides and mighty currents of the world as a yearling and calf, could make much out of a study which troubles historians and confounds philosophers. We have ever since suspected that “a plentiful lack of knowledge” is one of the prerequisites of sociological confidence; and this little pamphlet confirms that supposition. For we notice in it, what we never saw in any magazine before,—a “glossary,” containing the pronunciation and definition of such unusual and recondite terms as “metaphysician,” “plebian,” “patrician.” It seemed to us a long step from algebra to sociology, but it is a longer one from Mother Goose to Guizot and Buckle. The attempt to “solve all mysteries” before a class that does not know how to pronounce “cosmopolitan” strikes us as a difficult task, which suggests something wrong in the make-up of the teacher as well as of the taught.