Sunday-School Times.
THE Scriptures speak encouragingly, under certain circumstances, of those who change their lives,—who turn about, reverse all their previous conduct, and become, as it were, new creatures, thus making their after-life wholly and radically inconsistent with what it was before. Thus it appears that “consistency” has, in and of itself, no value. If the consistency is nothing better than a steadfast course of error and wrong-doing, it is most lamentable and disgraceful. The man who persists in believing an error when he is shown a better way, from a pride of “consistency,” and because he is ashamed of the reproach of being a changeling, is both weak and wicked. We praise the man who has the moral courage to say, “I was mistaken.” The world owes much to such men. Paul was such a one. He confessed himself ashamed of opinions that he once honestly held. He renounced them, and accepted their opposites; and both by his example and by his altered course became a benefactor of the race.
And yet, in a higher sense, Paul was consistent even in this change. As a fanatical Pharisee he lived in all good conscience before God and men. He was consistent in that he intended to be right, follow conscience, and, as he understood it, to please God. When he was destroying God’s saints, he verily thought that he was doing God service. When he was enlightened, he did not change this radical purpose, but only saw that he had been mistaken as to the nature and character of that service, and sought to accomplish it in a wiser and better way. This was the higher consistency. In following out this purpose, he dared to become quite inconsistent; and in this he showed his true greatness. Free from all men as the servant of Christ, he was willing to become all things to all men, that by all means he might save some. In his magnanimity and condescension, he was willing to become a Jew, that he might gain the Jews; to be a Gentile, that he might win them; to the weak, to become as weak, that he might gain the weak. And all this he did for the gospel’s sake. Here was the true center around which he gathered up and harmonized the lower conflicts and contradictions of his life. He was inconsistent in his sublime and unselfish consistency as an apostle of Christ and the servant of men.
Some have thought it a reproach to Luther, the great leader of the Saxon Reformation, that he may be quoted by the most variant parties in the Protestant churches as favoring their views. Accordingly, they have tried to maintain the thesis that thus and thus did Luther teach. The result has been that his views are shown to have been at different times quite variant, and often confessedly contradictory. Is this to his dishonor?
Luther did not claim to be an oracle of infallible wisdom. In opposing papal infallibility he did not assume himself to be pope. He urged men to search the Scriptures; and counseled them, if his writings stood in the way of the Word, then to burn his books. He dared to be inconsistent in his higher consistency of being an earnest and honest student of the truth of God. Whether Luther could be harmonized with himself was to him a matter of little consequence; but whether Luther could be harmonized with Christ and his gospel was of supreme importance.
The truth, and that alone, together with the character formed by it and in harmony with it, is the only consistent thing worthy of human aspiration and applause. Let us dare the mortification of being found inconsistent with ourselves for the honor and joy of being found in harmony with Christ, who is the life, the truth, and the way.
But now, having found this life, truth, and way, we need to be very careful that we do not cause others to stumble over our conduct as inconsistent professors and followers of our divine Leader and Guide.