AdventAI

THE ORIGIN OF LOGIC.

By J. O. Corliss

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 51., December 20, 1898

J. O. CORLISS.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

The tendency of the human mind is to reject every proposition not sustained by the clearest evidence. In other words, every doctrine to be received must be an unquestionable conclusion, reached by the most direct line of logic. If for some reason any mind is obscured, so that the deduction is not the most convincing, the whole thing is rejected as an idle fancy. Men insist that they must see the thing, in order to accept it. Indeed, this is considered so important a matter that schools of logic are established, where the most subtle lines of reasoning are taught; and every question, however simple, is settled by the law of human deductions.

By those who are educated to any degree in this line, even the positive statements of Inspiration are submitted to the process of “logical analysis;” and if any one of the statements is not by this process rendered discernible to the natural mind, it is at once discarded as untenable. Thus many feel justified in the position that they must not receive anything that they can not clearly see, forgetting that in things spiritual one is to walk by faith, and not by sight. 2 Cor. 5:7. This method followed for a time, human reasoning becomes the basis of what many suppose to be faith, though it is as far removed from faith as heaven is from the earth.

In fact, what the world now terms “logic” is responsible for the present terrible condition of the world. All the suffering, of every kind, now known to the human race, is traceable to man’s fall from his original estate. Created in the image of his Maker, and knowing nothing of evil, he was prepared to receive every statement from Heaven without question. In that condition, implicit faith was all the evidence needed of God’s faithfulness, and there was therefore no vacancy for logic to occupy.

Had man maintained that attitude, no place would ever have been formed for distrust and questioning. The basis of logic is distrust in some certain existing proposition, and is therefore a supposed necessity by which to test the stability of any proposition under consideration. But had nothing ever entered man’s mind to create distrust in God, logic would have been a thing unknown.

Distrust is the fruit of suspicion, or unbelief; and these are but synonyms of hostility, or resistance. To suspect and distrust another in anything, is really to oppose him in that thing. So when the first pair were placed in their Eden home, and the test of loyalty was given, by which they might retain their first estate, their quiet faith in God’s word was destroyed by a suggested suspicion that he was not true to them. The word of the Eternal was, “Neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die,” referring to that test which would prevent the race from receiving the admixture of good and evil. Up to this time the terms “good” and “evil” were unknown to them, because their simple faith and trust discerned only the power of God’s love and faithfulness. Had they remained true to the test given, the antagonistic conditions represented by these words would never have been known to the race of which our first parents were the earthly head.

When questioned by the representative of Satan concerning this test, the woman’s simple, unaffected answer showed that she was in perfect harmony with the mandate from heaven, as if there was no other way. The attempt of Satan was, therefore, to create distrust in her mind, which would be to array her against the restriction of the test. So he said: “Ye shall not surely die.” This was a plainly contradictory statement to the one made by God; and unless in some way substantiated, it would, to the mind of the woman, fall to the ground before that word which her faith had taught her to revere.

The only way to do this was to array logic against the simple word of God; so the word from Satan was that the Lord had uttered an untruth, which could be easily proved by a little reasoning. This was to the effect that God, knowing that the mind of the woman was capable of great expansion, even to the attainment of infinite understanding, had restricted her freedom, in order to prevent the unfolding of her powers. By this process of treating the divine injunction, suspicion of God’s integrity was produced in the woman’s mind, and became a fixed determination to oppose what was made to appear to her an unwarranted restraint of freedom. In other words, the woman was made to see, by the logic of Satan, that God’s word to her was not only untrue, but that the requirement it enjoined was a hardship to be renounced.

Thus self was exalted, and the word of Jehovah was dethroned in the inclination of the earthly race. This was the entrance of sin, by which the whole lineage of God’s creation was corrupted and lost. Ever since that era the natural man has placed every statement of God under the microscope of human logic, with the result that few now follow, or even believe, the word of Inspiration beyond the point of selfish convenience. In fact, much of the ancient volume known as the Bible has, by the aid of the “higher criticism,” been rendered obsolete; and the world is left to formulate countless theories based purely upon logic, which was invented by Satan for the purpose of introducing sin, and the consequent destruction of God’s image in his earthly representatives.

The less, then, that one argues with another concerning those things which have been forever settled by the word of God, the more Christlike he will be in all his deportment. But the immediate results of arguing on these things will be noticed in another paper.