AdventAI

A POOR RULE.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 51., December 20, 1898

It is said to be a poor rule that will not work both ways. Judged by this standard, most of the arguments for the observance of the first day of the week in place of the Sabbath must be poor; for if there are any rules which persist in working in only one direction, we find them here.

To illustrate, we find an article in the Detroit Sunday News Tribune of November 27, which presents a long and labored attempt to prove that the Sabbath, as set before us in the Bible, was given only to the Jews; and that the law by which it was enjoined could not be applicable to all men in all places, and under all circumstances. There are certain situations in travel, and conditions of the industrial world, for instance, which, it is claimed, can not be suspended to make way for a day of rest in the brief interval of seven days. Would a steamship, the writer asks, in its course across the ocean, lay by, midway in its course, and endeavor to drop anchor in mid-ocean, or drift helplessly about, for twenty-four hours, to accommodate the law of the Sabbath? Could foundries and paper-mills, whose success depends on the unbroken continuity of their operations, suspend work one day in every seven, without destroying the very existence of their enterprises? He argues that the Sabbath law can not possibly apply to such conditions; and hence it follows that God did not know that such conditions were to exist in this world, or that he did not design the Sabbath law to be of universal application. He endeavors to place trip-hammer emphasis on these propositions, for the purpose of erecting great barriers of impossibility behind which to hide his fondly cherished conclusions. And what are these conclusions?—Simply that a sabbath is an impossibility; at least that this is so as far as the particular seventh day enjoined in the Scriptures is concerned; all of which is claimed to show that that day must have been designed for the Jews alone, and to be observed only on one particular meridian of longitude.

But does he believe, or design to teach by this, that there is no Sabbath now?—Not at all. There is a sabbath still, just like that of the Jews; but it does not come on the same day, and is therefore, by some sublime hocus-pocus, relieved of all the embarrassments that cling to the former. But hold! it must come every week, and must appeal for its authority to the fourth commandment, which is the only warrant, in nature or in revelation, for a weekly Sabbath. But that commandment, if it means anything, requires the observance of the seventh day in regular succession as a period of rest.

But how does the newly ordained sabbath avoid or overcome the giant bugbears conjured up to drive out the old? How can a regularly recurring first-day sabbath, no matter if it is merely a seventh part of time, or a church institution, or on whatever ground it may rest,—how can this, if there is a particle of obligation to it, adapt itself to the demands of travel or business any better than the seventh day can?—It surely can not.

This theory, then, is only a complete abandonment of the whole Sabbath question; for the objections named stand precisely as much against any regularly recurring day that comes within the period of seven days, no matter what day of the week it may be, as they do against the seventh day, which the Bible specifies. Then if our friend will stick to his rule, which he seems to think is so good against the seventh day, away goes his first day as well. Whatever reason may be given for the introduction of such an institution, it is too loose on the handle to be a sabbath, and can maintain no appeal to the fourth commandment. Just as this rule works on the seventh day, so it works also on the first day; and as its working on this latter destroys its working on the former, it is shown to be worthless for the service required of it.

While it is true that it is a poor rule that does not work both ways, it does not follow that it is a good rule if it does work both ways; for, as in this instance, it may work nothing good in either direction. No man can succeed with it in creating an objection against the seventh day. Suppose there may be circumstances where necessity requires, and mercy demands, a continuance of work on the seventh day; these in no wise interfere with the Sabbath law. The same authority that endowed the Sabbath law with its power has plainly stated its limitations. Christ, in healing the impotent man on the Sabbath day, and by his instruction in regard to the sheep and the pit, and by what he said about David and the priests on the Sabbath day, showed that the rights of mercy and necessity are not to be trenched upon by any other service whatever. With all the claims of mercy, even the Sabbath law is in harmony. If a rule not only spoils the theory of some one else, but, when reversed, and working in just as legitimate a way, spoils our own, it had better be abandoned. U. S.