VERY CONFLICTING

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 27, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 52.

Read the full edition

“VERY CONFLICTING.”

SPIRITUALISTS find themselves in an embarrassing position when they lay their own feelings by the side of some of their teaching. For instance, such is the malignity of Spiritualism toward Jesus Christ that its promulgators find it impossible, in their platform utterances, to omit any opportunity to cast a slur upon his name, or even to deny his existence, which seems to suit them better still.
A correspondent of the Banner of Light asks why it is that Spiritualist lecturers so often publicly deny the existence of Christ, when noted mediums claim that they have seen him, and conversed with him, in the spirit-world. Here is a poser. Speakers must be deprived of the privilege of denying the existence of Jesus Christ, or else the messages of those mediums who profess that they have seen him must be set down as a fraud. Which shall it be? In this quandary the correspondent appeals to their best authority, the Banner of Light, for help. In their reply the editors say that the best scholarship in the spiritualistic school adheres to the doctrine that there was and is such a being as Jesus Christ, as will be shown in a forthcoming symposium; and that their public speakers do not help their cause by denying it.
But some messages from the supposed departed spirits have themselves denied Christ’s existence; and the correspondent refers to this, saying: “The testimony furnished by spiritualistic witnesses . . . is the only testimony worth considering.” To this the Banner replies: “As the testimony of spirits through different mediums is very conflicting, each is forced to accept the conclusion of his reason.”
This is a frank admission of the worthlessness of the spirit-communications of Spiritualism. Their testimony is “very conflicting,” and every one must accept the conclusions of his own reason. What, then, becomes of the proud and high-trumpeted claims that Spiritualism has come as an angel of light, to be the world’s great teacher, to impart lessons of truth which could not otherwise be attained? No very important truth nor clear lessons can be imparted by “conflicting” testimony. And if we are obliged to fall back at last, and as the final resort, upon the deductions of our own reason, all this hubbub and flurry about spirit-communications, with the fraud and ill-concealed abominations that have attended the movement, might, without any loss, but a good deal of profit, have been omitted.
To those Spiritualists who are so dead sure that they are right, and are willing to risk their all, for time and eternity, on what the spirits teach, we commend the foregoing admission that the testimony is “very conflicting,” and, of course, can not all be true. More than this, many Spiritualists emphatically concede that it is impossible to identify the spirits. You can not tell what intelligence has you under its power. It will pretend to be one thing, but may be entirely another. But when it pretends to be the spirit of any one who has ever lived here, as a member of the human family, no matter who, and now claims to have come back in a disembodied condition, the Bible at once stamps upon it the brand of Ananias and Sapphira. It comes under the name of what does not exist, and is consequently a forgery and a lie. No one, then, with a mind morally well-balanced, can fail to place it in its proper category.
But with all the fog-bank of uncertainty in which it is enveloped and hidden; with all the evil that has accompanied it, which is open to the light of day, what counter-balancing influence can it show on the other hand? What good has it done? What new truth has it introduced? What new principle has it discovered? What philanthropic agency has it set in motion? What burden has it lifted from the poor and oppressed? How many more hearts has it healed than it has broken? What pledge has it fulfilled? What plea can it urge in its own behalf?—None that will stand alone. The world would soon behold it flying through a gate marked “exit,” did not men love darkness rather than light. U. S.