DAVID PAULSON, M. D.
I am asked to write a short paper on the subject of the history of the developing of courses and degrees in the educational world; but I see little advantage in going back into the dim and dusty pages of the past to ascertain how this custom was borrowed from the heathen, and gradually developed during the reign of the papacy, which made the Dark Ages. It matters not so much to us who developed or used that which we handle to-day; the great question is, Is it right in itself? Is it good? Does it furnish the highest incentive and the best opportunity for our young men and women to be prepared to take their places in this closing age of the world’s history?
We have been told that we should let the students “advance as fast and as far as they can; let their field of study be as broad as their powers can compass.”—“Special Testimonies on Education,” page 216. We are also told (Id., page 213) that each student should feel that, under God, he is to have a special training, an individual culture. These two statements have impressed me as furnishing the key-note on the subject of courses and curriculums. The individual student is not to be hampered with a stereotyped mold, into which he must be placed, no matter how bright and shining he may come out when he has finished. He is to be allowed to advance as far and as fast as his own individual capacity will allow him. On the other hand, he is to have, under God, a special training, an individual culture; this presupposes that the teacher who works in harmony with God will endeavor to carry out that plan with reference to the student. It becomes clear that the student can never be put through a stereotyped course that has been marked out years in advance, which he must follow unquestioningly, as the water of the river follows the river-bed, and yet work in harmony with the Teacher who has enunciated these simple principles.
Professor Dewey, of the University of Chicago, gives the same idea in the following language:—
Our study is to find out what the actual interests of the child are; what it is, in the world of objects and persons, that attracts and holds the child’s attention, and that constitutes for him the significance and worth of his life. This does not mean that these interests, when discovered, give the ultimate standard for school work, nor that they have any final regulative value. It means that the final standard can not be discovered nor used until this preliminary inquiry is gone through with. Only by asking and answering such questions, do we find out where the child really is; what he is capable of doing; what he can do to the greatest advantage, and with the least cost of time and strength, mental and physical. We find here our indicators, or pointers, as to the range of facts and ideas legitimate to the child. While we do not get the absolute rule for the selection of subject-matter, we do most positively get the key to such a selection.—Educational Review, April, 1897.
Any one who has had any experience in teaching, or in the schoolroom, knows that a large percentage of students take a number of studies merely because they belong to a certain course; and can assign no other legitimate reason for so doing. It is not enough to say that it is a good thing that the students are made to take these studies, as they will need them afterward; for it is a common experience that a study which has been pursued with no higher object than this does not prove to be the right kind of discipline to the mind, so that it can be used to any particular advantage in afterlife.
“The pursuit of knowledge merely for its own sake, diverts the mind from devotion to God.”—“Special Testimonies on Education,” page 366. If studying merely for knowledge is wrong, and brings results so disastrous, how much worse must be the result of studying not even for the sake of learning facts, but for the sake of finishing a stereotyped course! Is it not possible that much of the sad backsliding in our schools may be traced to this very thing? God does not give light for us to ignore it; and we can not ignore it with safety.
Almost akin to the subject of finishing a fixed course, is the matter of bestowing the so-called “degree” at its completion. We have been told that we should ever keep before the students “how much they can accomplish; they should be encouraged to reach the highest standard of rectitude.”—Id., page 97. Again: “Self-discipline is made agreeable by the results that are seen. The reward of eternal life is the great incentive to a thorough training of all the powers that may be of the highest service for God.”
Here is given the principle that underlies all proper stimulus in a schoolroom. But those who have had any experience in college work know that there is a kind of agreeable stimulus in holding before the student the idea of receiving a degree. A writer in the Educational Review describes this principle in the following words:—
It is also sometimes urged that a “stimulus” is needed. This is the same argument which, a few generations ago, justified the use of the rod. A vigorous boy needs no stimulus to eat his dinner, an active man requires none to enjoy a brisk walk. There should be the same keen enjoyment of mental as of physical exercise; and there would be, if rewards and punishments could be eliminated from the educational system. A college student once apologized for the system, on the ground that a stimulus for work was needed, and naively added, “In college one has so many things to do that he lets the work slip if he is sure of getting his degree.” In order to consider this question, we have to recognize what degrees have come to mean. Outside of a few professional degrees,—which are really a recognition of the profession in which the man is,—they are worn as a recognition of what a man has done, rather than of what the man is.
Another writer has well said:—
From his first introduction into the school, to the taking of his final degree, teachers, parents, and doting friends conspire in their efforts to stimulate the boy to get ahead of some one else. Men wear degrees as women wear fine bonnets, jewels in their hair, rings in their ears and on their fingers, and gay ribbons flaunting in the breeze. Consider, for example, the ornamental value of A. M., M. S., Ph. D., or the social value of such a tremendous decorative combination as that enjoyed by Mr. James Brown, A. M., Ph. D., LL. D., D. D. Each one of these titles costs as much as a diamond of moderate size, or a large pearl [not the Pearl of great price], and is worn for practically the same reason. It does not necessarily indicate anything. John Smith, tailor; James Brown, blacksmith; Mr. Jones, surveyor, are examples of titles which produce in the mind something more than the mere decorative effect. These indicate the trade or profession by which the man gains his livelihood. Each is an advertisement for business of a sort with which the individual represents himself to be familiar, for work which he considers himself competent to perform. No significance ordinarily attaches to the title conferred as the reward of a classical or scientific course in our colleges. No one imagines that a man who writes A. M. after his name holds himself in readiness to act as interpreter for some one who wishes to converse with some resuscitated native of ancient Greece or Rome; or even to read at sight a passage from some newly discovered Latin or Greek authority. It means, in nine cases out of ten, and probably in a much larger proportion of cases, simply that at some time the possessor of this title was able to conjugate with more or less familiarity a number of Greek and Latin verbs, and to dig out, with the aid of a lexicon, his daily lessons in the so-called classics.
Another writer, speaking of the same subject, says:—
It is also said that the fact that a student has won an honor is of service to him in securing a position in business or in teaching. But the mere fact that the student has gained an honor does not of necessity commend that person to a stranger: the test applied in business life is not, What does he know? but, what can he do? If a student has been truly educated, if he has had his intellectual powers trained and developed, if at all times he has command of himself, then he will stand the test; if he has acquired information rather than an education, then he may fail.
The owner and managing superintendent of one of the largest establishments in Kansas told me, a few months ago, that he invariably refused a position to a man who told him that he was a college graduate, as he had learned from experience that a man who has graduated and received his degree has been crippled,—has been hobbled, so to speak,—and is unable to deal with life at its fiercest. He also told me that there is not a man at the head of a large and successful concern in Kansas who is a college-educated man. The statement of this man, who has built up a colossal fortune, and has had a wide opportunity for observation in private as well as public life, is significant.
Of the large number of eminent men whom I have met at the Sanitarium during the last few years, I have been surprised to see how few have been college-bred men. I have been interested in this question for several years; and as soon as I become sufficiently acquainted with this class of patients, I invariably seek to learn what opportunities they have had in the way of education. I have found that the men who have made a success—who have, as it were, their finger on the pulse of the business world—are the men who are educated by their environment rather than in college halls.
The Lord has certainly given us light that we are to prepare men and women to fight the battles of life. He has told us that if we do not have schools carried on on an ALTOGETHER DIFFERENT basis, there would be no need of adding more schools; that “teachers have congratulated students on their advancement, and encouraged them to take one degree after another, even though they were less qualified to do the work of God than they were before they entered the school.”
Has not the time come when the question of fixed courses of study and college honors and degrees deserves a careful study by all our educators? Should not our schools, as far as their capacity will allow them, teach the different lines of study upon which God has set his approval? Ought there not to be faithful teachers, who can sit down with the students when they enter the school, pray with them, and explain to them what is involved in each one of these studies? If they counsel together, the Spirit of God will illuminate the mind of both teacher and student as to where the student should begin. But let only such a line of study be urged upon the student as it is clear he has the ability to handle, and will be able to make use of. As he goes forward into the field, and is anointed for service by God, he will thus receive the true degree.
At the Sanitarium the question has been raised as to the propriety of taking a class of our students, after a stated period, and publicly handing them diplomas certifying that they are medical missionaries. We can not read the heart; and it has seemed clear to us that the only course to pursue is to allow the students to go out and demonstrate their missionary spirit in grappling with the world; and as God puts his stamp upon them, they will not need a human stamp. If they are placed where they need recognition of the work they have done here, a statement of the same can be placed in their hands, with their regular missionary credentials, rather than the time-honored diploma.