THE MURDER OF THE MODERN INNOCENTS.
By Mrs. Lew Wallace
Mrs. Lew Wallace, in Ladies’ Home Journal. [The following most telling, and most true, article was printed in the Ladies’ Home Journal for February, 1899. It is of such merit that the editor of the Home Journal stepped aside for the occasion, and gave it the editorial page entire. He says that “no words which he might have written could compare in importance with the sentiments so well expressed below.” That this true and noble appeal may reach as wide a circle as possible, we copy it, and send it on, with thanks to the Ladies’ Home Journal and to the author.—EDITOR REVIEW AND HERALD.] Bethlehem was little among the thousands of Judah. We are told that probably not over thirty children fell under the order of Herod. The murder of the innocents of the nineteenth century is a march to untimely graves, not by order of a wrathful king, but under what is claimed to be the finest free-school system in the world. Go into any public school, and you will see girls pallid as day-lilies, and boys with flat chests and the waxen skin that has been named the “school complexion.” Every incentive and stimulus is held out,—dread of blame, love of praise, prizes, medals, badges, the coveted flourish in the newspapers,—and the strain never slackens. Watch the long lines filing past, each pupil carrying books—three, four, five—to be studied at night in hot rooms, by fierce, sight-destroying lights. Time was when spectacles went with age. They are no sign of age now. Many must wear glasses to help eyes worn prematurely old by night-work. Said a thoughtful father: “My children have no child-life. They are straining up a grade, talking about examinations. When is their playtime, if not now? and what has become of the light-hearted boys? School is never out. Even in the fields the butterfly and the tree-toad are turned into object-lessons, and the grasshopper is torn to pieces in order to be instructive. When I was a boy, and school let out, we were gay and free. We studied in schooltime, and in playtime there was no thought of anything but play.” I do not undervalue education; it is greatly to be desired: but over-education is slaying its thousands. The burden is books. The tasks imposed on the young are fearful. The effort seems to be to make text-books as difficult and complicated as possible, instead of smoothing the hill so high, and so hard to climb. SAID a mother, “Two and two are what?” “Surely you know that two and two make four.” “Yes, mama; but I am trying to remember the process.” A child of nine years is required to define and understand such words as these: aphocrasis, apocope, paragoge, paraleipsis, diocrasis, synocrasis, tmesis. There are famous speakers and writers who never saw them. Lest the gentle reader be as ignorant as the writer, I mention that these, and more of the same sort, may be found in many modern English grammars. One day Mary was bending over a tablet, writing words on both sides of a straight line, like multiplied numerators and denominators. “What are you at now?” asked grandma. Mary answered, with pride, “I am diagraming.” “In the name of sense, what is diagraming?” “It’s mental discipline. Miss Cram says I have a fine mind, that needs developing. Look here, grandma, now this is the correct placing of elements. ‘Fourscore’ and ‘seven’ are joined by the word ‘and,’ a subordinate connective copulative conjunction. It modifies ‘years,’ the attribute of the proposition. ‘Ago’ is a model adverb of past time. The root-word of the first clause is——” “Why, that’s Lincoln’s speech at Gettysburg! I keep it in my work-basket, and know it by heart.” “Indeed! Well, ‘our’ is a simple personal——” “That’s enough. If President Lincoln had been brought up on such stuff, that speech would never have been written. He called a noun a noun, and was done with it.” One day Mary came home at noon too sick to eat dinner. What had happened to the darling?—She had seen a cat dissected in class. Are our daughters being trained for surgeons? Other noons she was required to find who was the author of “I sat by its cradle, I followed its hearse,” and what caused the fall of the feudal system, and bring back the answers for the afternoon session. She was too hurried to eat anything but a banana while making a dive at the reference-books, and said, “I only remember these answers a few days. There’s so much more coming on all the time.” Of course by far the greater portion must be forgotten as the waves of yesterday. “MENTAL discipline”?—Not any more than a Chinese puzzle—merely so much rubbish under the attic. The mathematics superstition is strong in the land we love to call our own; children of thirteen are in algebra. Undertake the tasks laid on girls in their teens for one year, and then write to me how you like the “system.” We need no physician to tell us that the number of nervous diseases on the increase is appalling. Even paralysis has crept in on the young; a leading physician of our State had three new cases in 1896. There is too much of everything except what is contained in Judge Baldwin’s admirable answer to the question, “Should manners be taught in our public schools?” Four, or at the utmost five, hours are a full day’s study, if one is to have health in this exhaustive climate. Under our forcing system, the time demanded is nearer ten hours. Foreign children may study harder; but they do not come of fathers consumed by ambition, and mothers trying to do the impossible. THE girls break first, because of greater capacity for suffering in nerves alive and quivering, which, with boys, are insensible as telegraph-wires. Besides, girls are more tractable, and take to music, embroidery, and painting, while boys play ball. In sanitariums, rest-cures, water-cures, and other refuges, forlorn wrecks of women lie on beds of pain, swallowing cod-liver oil, malted milk, and beguiling “foods” and drugs, in order to “build up.” But there is no foundation to build upon. There are limits to geography; since literature has possessed the public mind, there are no boundary lines. To be sure, it is a fine thing to read Browning at sight, and to know what Carlyle means by a “hell-queller,” but these delights may be reserved for mature intellects: something might be left undone in the schools. A pupil must read “Paradise Lost,” and write an essay on the poem, within six days—a composition for scholars, and one that few scholars do read. I learn with pain that Dante has been added to the course in some States. The dead cat lasted only a day; Dante goes through a whole term. Let the great poets come in later years, royal guests, not task-masters appointed to afflict us with burdens. Be sure if your children want Milton, they will find him,—and oh, do not make a study of “Childe Harold”! Back of all, and harder than unbending rules, is the merciless ambition of parents. American children must do, be, and have everything. Propose to cut down, drop the least congenial study, and there is an outcry: “Why, then Mary could not get her diploma!” What will she do with it if she does get it?—Lay it away in a forgotten top drawer, or frame and hang it in the guest-chamber,—a costly document, bought with a great price. Said a tender mother to me, “The air of the schoolroom is so foul that my boys’ heads smell of it.” “And you continue to send them?” “Oh, yes; you know they must pass.” The mother of a girl with lips as colorless as her forehead declared, “I have a high standard of education for Julia.” “But health—if she leaves that in the textbooks, though she speak with the tongues of men and of angels, it profiteth nothing.” “I mean,” determinedly, “for her to have advantages; when she gets her diploma, she can rest.” So she sums along till she can multiply three figures by three figures in her head, day and night thinking and thinking. One soft Sunday afternoon, when even the day-laborer was having his leisurely stroll, I asked why she was not out with the rest of the family. She was at home, writing an essay on Gray’s “Elegy.” “Oh, it’s no trouble for her to do it. I don’t see how she writes so easily. This is her last year; she has seven studies; then comes the finishing school at New Haven.” “Sometimes she talks in her sleep” (again the proud look); “it’s Latin I think.” She was already in the finishing school: and what she now says in her sleep we shall not know till we learn the language of the dead. That is not the only house where there is a drawer scented with tuberose and heliotrope, and opening it is like opening the grave.87 Easy for her to have seven studies under seven different teachers! Try it yourself. SAID one of my neighbors, “Here are two diplomas; they represent my two daughters educated to death.” Death by freezing is easier. One of the most foolish sights I have ever seen was a feeble country girl, who expected to earn a living, she hardly knew how, puzzling over Cicero’s orations. Latin is part of the treadmill stairs all must climb. Well has it been said of the Romans that had they been obliged to learn their own language, they never would have been able to conquer the world. The dull girl pulls through grades high and low; and when the time comes to take a teething baby through dog-days and nights, how goes the battle?—Down with nervous prostration, she would give Euclid, Cicero, even the seventh book of Thucydides, for a day’s release from the pangs of neuralgia. Baby is predestined to be one of the never-sleeping sort, doomed to nerves tense as fiddle strings. To get through in a given time, the rate of speed is like the French woman’s, who, at dinner, whispered to the philosopher, “Now, while the plates are changing, be quick, and tell me the history of the world.” I knew one type of a class. She mastered various sciences and languages, had seven years of music, and in mathematics went so far as to carry the surveyor’s chain. She started in evanescent beauty, rose-bloom and snow, and faded as certain sea-shells lose color lying in the sun. The last time I saw her, she said, with angelic patience, “My children are wakeful at night, and I suffer a good deal.” She drooped without complaint; and one day the black horses came to the door, and bore away the young mother to the city of the silent. There is a school not a thousand miles from Indianapolis, where little children go three hours in the morning and three in the afternoon, and are punished for the least restlessness. Naturally, the prisoners are too exhausted to make much racket when released; so the houses where they live are kept “quiet.” Among women I have known, the one loveliest where many were lovely, had little book-learning. It is not what she knows, but what the woman is, that makes her charm. This one kept household accounts with exactness, wrote pleasant letters, spelled perfectly, wrote a readable hand. She knew that the verb must agree with its nominative, and that the nose is not an organ of speech. Her voice was so sweet I hear it yet, though years have fled since it was hushed in eternal silence. She lived to old age, and to the last the banner over her was love; yet she never heard of the differential calculus, nor knew that man is a magnificent efflorescence of protoplasm! It is urged that every American is a possible president,—that he should be well equipped, a many-sided person, equal to any fortune, and so on. True, but do not forget that our greatest— “the noblest man
That ever lived in the tide of times”— had what would now be called a meager education, cared nothing for books, and was without a library. It is doubtful if any one of our chiefs walked through the valley of the shadow of Dante while a schoolboy. Few are born great; and if greatness is to be achieved, it will not be by piling books on the top of one’s head till the brains can not move. President Lincoln taught us that if a man loves learning, he will have it, though he live in a wilderness. If your boy’s tastes are not scholarly, you may make him miserable trying to force a love for learning. He will go through the books, and the books will go through him; there is no assimilation. There is no reason why our little people should be bound under the same rigid rule as the heads of the Flathead Indians—why eighty should learn what perhaps six will need. As the English say, in their straightforward way, if your son is to be a tradesman, give him a tradesman’s education. The man who, under happy stars, might excel as an architect or a machinist may be a poor lawyer, and sentenced to it because his father was bred to the law, and there was a judge somewhere among his ancestry. The founders of our free-school system (I hope they rest in peace!) little dreamed of the latitudes and longitudes that would grow out of their idea of a sound English education accessible to all; or where, as General Grant sensibly wrote, “every child in the land can have the opportunity of a good common-school education, unmixed with sectarian, pagan, or atheistical tenets.” Their idea has been elaborated into a toilsome course, sapping the strength of the strongest. German, Latin, music, drawing, and studies whose names I do not know, are brought in. A girl of seventeen, who determined to do or die, said to me, with effusion, “I want to know—just everything.” At last accounts, she was making eyes at a handsome youth, who may rescue her from impending lexicons. AFTER all, what are our children being educated for?—The boys are to be breadwinners—that is decided. They must hurry through, and “hustle for a living.” The girls—let us believe it—are the future homemakers. The word “helpmeet” is obsolete; it was left behind with the woman who made Eden paradise. Constantly the question is being brought up, “Shall this and that be added to our public schools?” But who asks, “Can the scholars endure any more?” They have no protest nor petition; they must stand, like human vessels, ready to be filled to the brim with mixtures of facts. I plead for a childhood of the soul as well as of the body,—for the free air, the blessed sunshine, the moderate task ended at the schoolhouse. This night young heads are leaning against their mothers, tired as no young things should ever be; and it is a sorrowful sound to hear a child waking from what might be the sound slumber of a light heart, beating to healthful music, to ask, in a troubled voice, “Do you think I can make the pass grade?” It is said that they like to go to school. Yes, and they would like it twice as well if there were half as much to learn. Many children have I known, but not one who loved study for its own sake. Companionship is what lures them. Instead of wandering up and down the wilderness of wintry facts, let them loiter a while among the dear illusions. The Happy Valley of Childhood is but narrow, where the golden water babbles to the talking bird and the singing tree, where the sun always shines, and all the years are summers. Those who adjust the load that presses so heavily on the springs of life, have much to account for. Boston has been shaken by a solemn protest from the city physician against the ruinous manner in which children are overworked,—not the orphans in factories, nor the poor in the tenements, but in the handsome schoolhouses where the well-to-do send their sons and daughters. On the long-suffering teachers I can hardly trust myself to speak; no nobler army of martyrs ever marched to chambers of torture. Said one, “I begin the weekly reports Monday, before the lessons are recited, else I should never have them ready by Friday-night.” I have seen teachers carry home piles of manuscript to be corrected, often spending Saturday and Sunday at their desks. Most dismal of tasks; no wonder the professional reader of manuscripts goes crazy. Said another: “I am so tired I do not go to church. Unless I lie around and rest on Sunday, I can not be ready for Monday. It seems that to teach anything, we must know everything. We have to write essays on subjects that do not touch our studies, and there are the long meetings and the institutes.” “What about the institutes?” I asked. It was at the close of one of the hottest days of our tropical summer. “We must meet and hear compositions on basic thoughts, cosmic entities, the concept of ideality, and Mr. Nobody, from Nowhere, reads ‘Locksley Hall.’” “Can’t you read ‘Locksley Hall’ for yourself?” “Yes, if I have a chance. My back ached so that I could not listen; and sometimes I am so hurried, I feel as if I should lose my wits.” At one time there was a regulation that teachers should stand during recitation. When a number had dropped on the floor, the order was revoked. AFTER much hesitation this cry goes out,—a petition to lighten the load of the overladen, that may not reach the hearing ear. I should not have the courage to send it, had I not been entreated: “Speak for us; write for us: you have nothing at stake. We dare not complain; we should lose our places; there are many waiting for vacancies.” Pathetic appeals from the helpless! So, watching their unconquerable work, what I have written I have written.