PASSING EVENTS

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 30, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 35.

Read the full edition

PASSING EVENTS.

A Quiet Revolution.

At Saratoga, N. Y., last week, there was held a great convention to discuss matters of national interest, particularly what would be the best thing for the United States to do with respect to Porto Rico, Cuba, and the Philippine Islands.
Upon this particular question the chief interest was centered in the speeches of Carl Schurz, of New York, and Judge Grosscup, of Chicago. Mr. Schurz insisted that according to the Declaration of Independence, the life principle of the government of the United States, this nation could not rule subject peoples; that as “governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed,” for the United States to undertake to govern the people of these places, without their consent, or against their express wish, would be to repudiate the fundamental principle of the government of the United States; and this nation would therefore cease to be a free republic. He argued that for the United States to treat these peoples in any other way than as “created equal,” and as “endowed by their Creator with” the inalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, would be to renounce the living principle of American Republicanism; and that by pursuing such a course, the American Republic would fail and cease to be such.
Judge Grosscup did not attempt any direct answer to these points; but he dwelt on what the nation should do,—how she should not only retain the power over the whole Philippine group, but should even extend it into China,—and all for wealth and glory: principle was not considered.
And the report of the convention, while admitting that Mr. Schurz had the force of the argument, makes it plain that the weight of sentiment was with Judge Grosscup.
This occurrence is only an illustration of the situation all over the country. And by this it is perfectly plain that there is a great and most dangerous revolution going on before the very eyes of the American people; and they are even helping it on, while they do not discern it.
Under the false impression that revolutions can be accomplished only by violence and visible upheaval, the American people are even now passing through a revolution, and are in danger of finding themselves in the clutches of a new and strange power before they realize that any such thing is going on at all.
We have already shown the course of the Roman Republic, and how the American Republic is going over the same ground precisely. And just now it should not be forgotten by any member of the American Republic, that the Roman Republic passed through the despotism of two triumvirates, the second far worse than the first, each ending in the despotism of one man, and then passed into the “furious and crushing despotism” of the Roman monarchy, all in the name of the republic. All this occurred inside of forty years, before the eyes of all the people, while they were pleasing themselves with the fancy and the name that they were still a republic.
Even when Augustus had become emperor, this fiction was played by him before the eyes of the people; and the people were pleased with it. For, as Gibbon most pointedly remarks: “Augustus was sensible that mankind is governed by names; nor was he deceived in his expectation that the senate and people would submit to slavery, provided they were respectfully assured that they still enjoyed their ancient freedom.” Upon this safe assumption, he accordingly deceived “the people by an image of civil liberty, and the armies by an image of civil government.” He was eminently successful, and both people and armies congratulated themselves upon the greatness, and the new and wonderful career, of the Roman Republic!
With these facts in mind, the following extract from the speech of ex-Attorney-general Harmon, to the Ohio Bar Association at Put-in-Bay, Ohio, July 12, are intensely suggestive to citizens of the American Republic:—
Mere expansion is not growth; it is only swelling. We may push across the seas, but we can not grow there. Elephantiasis is not an unknown form of national malady, and has always proved fatal. There are still chapters of English history to be written.
We should have to change both the name and the nature of our nation to admit any State out of America, especially if it be populated by alien races. Few, if any, are now bold enough to advocate this. To get dominion over strange peoples for the mere purpose of governing them, not admitting them as equals in a family of States, stretching into permanency for that purpose a power meant to be temporary and occasional only, and for that reason left unrestricted, is rightly called an “imperial policy.” It would belie and discredit the Declaration of Independence, and convict us of hypocrisy. We can not, under our system, govern any people without letting them help govern us. The reaction would be swift and sure. We should see what Patrick Henry meant when he said, in his famous resolutions of 1765, that such government of the colonies by Great Britain “has a manifest tendency to destroy British as well as American freedom.”
An imperial policy will as surely some day lead to an emperor. He may assume some softer name if our sensitiveness survive, as is often the case. But an imperial policy and a republic make a contradiction in terms. The policy must go, or the emperor in some new form must come.
It is not pleasant to play Cassandra. It is easier to join in the shouting and the dancing of those who seem to think the past is dead and the future assured. But one’s duty to his countrymen is to give warning of evil when he believes he detects its approach.