An Important Decision

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 16, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 7.

Read the full edition

An Important Decision.

February 1 the United States Supreme Court handed down one of the most important and far-reaching decisions ever made by a court in this country. It is that each State has the right to tax the capital stock of interstate corporations doing business within its limits. The causes which led to this decision may be briefly stated. The States of Indiana and Ohio have levied taxes on the business of the Adams Express Company within their borders. Previous to 1893, the Adams Express Company and certain other telegraph and telephone companies had been taxed in these States for their personal property in these States, and for the volume of business done there; but the third attempt to tax them on a portion of their capital was resisted, and the cases have been carried successively through the courts of these States to the highest court in the nation, which now has affirmed the validity of these State laws, and the consequent right of a State to assess a general tax upon such companies as are doing business within its limits.
To illustrate: the whole capital stock of the Adams Express Company may be supposed to be one hundred million dollars. This money is not invested in great buildings, as no manufacturing is done; but by a concession from the government, the business is carried on by the railroad companies all over the United States. Thus the business of this company has no local place, but is diffused all over the country. For this reason the State of Ohio computes the amount of business done by this company in that State, and assesses the capital stock of the company for the amount which is represented by the volume of business done there. This has been done by both Ohio and Indiana, and now, as we have said, the Supreme Court has affirmed the validity of the action of those States. Justices Field, Harlan, and White gave dissenting opinions.
It will be seen at once that unless New York State, where the company offices are located, and where they have heretofore been taxed for the full amount of their capital stock, will not remit taxes on that portion of the capital stock of the Express Company taxed in other States, it will amount to double taxation; and it is largely upon this view of the question that the dissenting justices based their objections. On the other hand, it may be said for the decision that a business so generally diffused, which has no large investments in one place, and whose money is drawn from every part of the country, should pay its taxes where it does its business. Other States will undoubtedly now fall into line, and this company and other companies of a similar nature will be obliged to pay their taxes in the States where they do their business, in proportion to the volume of business done in the several States; and one State will no longer be able to draw taxes from business done all over the United States.
Should New York remit that portion of the taxes on the companies which are assessed in the different States, as it will probably be compelled to do, it is still likely that the whole amount of taxes paid by such companies will be larger when thus distributed than before; for often these very wealthy companies, by ways best known to themselves but suspected by others, avoid assessment for the full value of their property,—something they will find it very difficult to do in so many States. But should they be compelled to pay higher taxes because of this decision of the Supreme Court, they ought not to complain. The wealthy men who own the stock in these great companies have, during the past year, affirmed their belief in the absolute infallibility of the Supreme Court. When the income-tax decision of the Supreme Court removed from them the nightmare of a tax on their wealth, they were ready to exclaim, “A Daniel come to judgment!” and now that a decision from the same court bids fair to draw upon their purses, they should not complain, but stand up and take their medicine without a grimace, like little men, remembering that in this life the bitter is often strangely mingled with the sweet.
M. E. K.