THE READING OF FICTION

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 16, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 33.

Read the full edition

THE READING OF FICTION.

In the Arena for May, George Clark, Ph. D., has an excellent article entitled “The Novel-Reading Habit.” He truthfully says that “the preponderance of fiction in the literature of the closing decades of this century is the most salient feature in the literary history of our times.” He might have said more: it is one of the most salient features in the history of our times; for without this enormous appetite for fiction on the part of the people, there would be no preponderance of fiction in literature. This class of reading-matter is one of Satan’s most successful devices for putting people to sleep during these “perilous times.” It is hard to imagine a person more thoroughly asleep to eternal realities, or even to the realities of this life, than one who is engrossed in this literature. He who, like Daniel, makes the word of God his highest instructor, and at the same time improves the opportunities given him to become intelligent in all lines of learning (see Special Testimony on Education, page 135) will have no time for such trash.
We give below some of the most pointed statements in the article referred to, not because they add any force to what the Testimonies have told us on this subject, but because they are the truth, and show that it requires only an investigation to see that the Testimonies have described the thing exactly. Compare pages 185–188 of “Christian Education” with these extracts:—
“In order to understand and enjoy a novel, there is no need of any previous special training or unusual mental capacity, so that the novel appeals to a wider circle of readers than any other kind of literature.
“The power which we have of sympathizing with others in their ambitions, joys, and sorrows—that gift of the imagination by which we are enabled to contemplate the careers of others with a personal interest by identifying ourselves for the moment with them—supplies us with a means of obtaining a sort of happiness by proxy, while our own attitude is entirely passive. It is by furnishing this kind of happiness that the novel has won its immense popularity.
“As imagination is the faculty chiefly exercised both in the creation and in the enjoyment of fiction, it might be supposed that fondness for this kind of reading is an indication of a strong imagination and a superior type of mind. But this is far from being true.
. . . An indiscriminating love of fiction, which accepts with avidity anything in the form of a story for the sake of dispelling ennui, is the mark of an indolent, unpractical, resourceless mental character.
“A mental faculty can be cultivated only by effort and exercise, and the effort required of the imagination in order to picture to itself scenes and situations of which the complete material is furnished to it, is so slight as to be of insignificant value. . . . The constructive and creative imagination of the reader is allowed to lie torpid. Fiction has, therefore, special attractions for persons who are deficient in mental energy and creative powers. It is true that many really great minds have found pleasure in reading novels; but it has always been the pleasure of relaxation, and not to be compared with the intense enjoyment which they have derived from the activity of their mental powers.
“The effects of novel-reading have been well compared with those of indulgence in opium or intoxicating liquors. While we are under the influence of a novel, especially one of the ‘sensational’ variety, our cares and anxieties are for the time forgotten, and our reasoning faculties are allowed to rest, while our imagination is delighted with a succession of fancies and visions. But this sort of indulgence is attended with danger; for frequent repetition of it will produce a habit and craving. . . . In this way the novel comes to be regarded as an unfailing resource for idle hours, and the habit of resorting to it may be formed as readily as the craving for narcotics or stimulants.
“In popular estimation, historians, essayists, and poets are almost ignored unless they have made their immortality sure by writing a novel.
“If our main object in the training of our children were to render them dependent for their intellectual entertainment on works of fiction, we could hardly pursue any method better calculated to produce that result than the plan at present followed. . . . One might almost suppose the greater part of juvenile literature was deliberately designed to reduce the minds of the boys and girls who read it to a fit condition for the subsequent reception and enjoyment of the trash brought out for adults in the form of novels. It is tolerated on the ground that ‘any reading is better than no reading.’ . . . It is an error to suppose that the reading of trashy books will eventually lead to reading healthy literature.
“The mental and moral interests of mankind would have little loss to record if all the books of this class that have been or are to be written should be suddenly swept out of actual or potential existence.”
Amen!