THOSE “MILLENNIAL DAWN” DATES AGAIN

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 20, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 29.

Read the full edition

THOSE “MILLENNIAL DAWN” DATES AGAIN.

BY W. S. BUTTERBAUGH, M. D.
(Ontario, Kan.)
MANY readers of the REVIEW will remember two articles by the Editor, bearing date of January 26 and May 4, the first being a reply to the query of a correspondent, and the other a reply to the Watch Tower, which had attempted a refutation in its April number. These articles were concerning the dates of the seventy weeks, the fifteenth year of Tiberius Cæsar (Luke 3:1), the date of the baptism and crucifixion of Christ, and the end of the seventy weeks in A. D. 34, the REVIEW maintaining that the beginning of the seventy weeks took place in 457 B. C., and the crucifixion in A. D. 31, which position is unassailable.
It will be remembered that the Watch Tower maintains that the foregoing position is incorrect, from the standpoint that Luke is supposed to have dated from the sole reign of Tiberius Cæsar on the death of Augustus in A. D. 14, which position the REVIEW has shown to be incorrect; nevertheless there are a number of Tower advocates who will not yield to the plain facts of the case, but persistently maintain that their positions are correct. The writer of this article proposes to put their positions to the test, and after having forced the advocates of this theory to stand upon the logic of their position, we will turn on the great search-light of sacred and profane history, and behold them without any position whatever! This done, they will be left to sink amid the sands of supposition without chart, rudder, or sail. This can be done; and if the reader will carefully follow up the existing facts as they are introduced, he must certainly be convinced that the position taken by the Tower is erected upon the foundation of supposition, amid the quicksands of uncertainty.
Before the introduction of evidence, it is only justice to say that there are many honest souls among the Tower advocates, who are being led into error on this question from the fact that they fail to take in connection all the facts of scripture as compared with other scripture, which would lead them out of the domain of darkness into the glorious light on the sanctuary question.
First, we will investigate the facts surrounding the dates of Nehemiah’s commission, as is understood by the author of a publication known as the “Millennial Dawn;” and if we find his position respecting the date of this commission to be self-contradictory and suicidal, we must therefore conclude that his chain of evidence is incorrect in this one particular, and is likewise incorrect in every particular. If by the use of the Scriptures alone we can prove the utter weakness of this one link, showing that it cannot belong where he places it, then we have proved the complete disarrangement of his entire theory. In order that all may have an exact understanding of his position, and in justice to all who may cherish his views, it is proper to state that he attempts to figure backward from Luke 3:1 as the basis of the claim that Luke dates from the sole reign of Tiberius Cæsar, which date is easily ascertained, and in which particular there is no discrepancy among scholars. Taking this as his basic standpoint (which question of joint or sole reign is more a matter of supposition with himself than with historians), he reckons backward to find the date of the beginning of the seventy weeks (Watch Tower, April 1, page 105), and finds that if Nehemiah’s commission can be made to date from 454 B. C., then all is in harmony with his theory.
We now introduce into evidence his statements as found in Vol. II, page 67, of “Millennial Dawn,” the author of which is the editor of the Watch Tower:—
But there was another decree granted to Nehemiah in the twentieth year of Artaxerxes to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem, which at that time were still unrepaired (Neh. 2:3-8; 6:15; 7:1), and it is from this decree to restore and build Jerusalem that this prophecy of Daniel should be dated. . . . The date of Nehemiah’s commission is ordinarily stated to be B. C. 445. But Dr. Hales’s work on chronology (pages 449, 531) and Dr. Priestley’s treatise on the “Harmony of the Evangelists” (pages 24-38) show this common view to be nine years short, which would give B. C. 454 as the true date of Nehemiah’s commission.
Compare the foregoing statement by the same author in the April number of the Watch Tower, page 104:—
“The beginning of the seventy weeks (490 years) of Israel’s favor (Dan. 9:24) was so obscure and indefinite that the Jews could not and did not know positively when to expect Messiah. [Italics mine.]”
How can the Tower contend that the commission of Nehemiah should date from 454 B. C., and afterward claim that it is “indefinite,” not “positive,” and still continue to assert, with a positive assurance, that his reckoning from Luke 3:1, according to his interpretation (sole reign of Tiberius Cæsar), is correct? If the sole-reign theory is correct, how can the other be doubtful?
The facts involved in Nehemiah’s commission are as follows: It was merely a verbal permission for him to visit Jerusalem. Persian decrees were put in writing. Dan. 6:8. The “letters” that the king granted to Nehemiah were issued to the “governors beyond the river, that they may convey me over [assist him to pass through without molestation].” Neh. 2:7. He then visited Jerusalem. “The rulers knew not whither he went. He had not told it to the Jews or to the priests, nobles, or rulers, nor to the rest that did the work.” He requested of the Jews that they “build the wall.” They undoubtedly supposed that such procedure would not be allowed, inasmuch as it was not mentioned in the decree granted to Ezra; hence they had not as yet undertaken the task, fearing lest they arouse the jealousy of the governors of the surrounding provinces, and it be reported to the king that they were fortifying their city with the intention of returning to former hostility. (See Neh. 2:17-19; 6:1-7.) The wall was finally completed in fifty-two days. Neh. 6:15.
It must be remembered that the prophecy allows “seven weeks,” or forty-nine years, for the complete restoration of the city; while Nehemiah’s principal work occupied but fifty-two days. It is quite apparent that Nehemiah’s work did not meet all the requirements of the prophecy. Ezra’s decree granted all Jews who would return, the privilege of returning, and was general in its stipulations, granting: “Whatsoever Ezra the priest, the scribe of the law of the God of heaven, shall require of you, it be done speedily.” Ezra 7:21.
According to the reckoning of the author of “Millennial Dawn” for the date of the commission of Nehemiah; namely, 454 B. C., the “troublous times” must have their beginning with Nehemiah’s commission, which is not true, as the building of the temple and city had been in progress during thirteen years prior. (Compare Ezra 7:7 with Neh. 2:1-9.) Between the 20th of Artaxerxes and the 32d of Artaxerxes—a period of twelve years—Nehemiah was at Jerusalem. Neh. 13:4-6. He cleansed the chambers of the temple of unsanctified assistants, and brought thither again the vessels of the house of God (Neh. 13:9), which Ezra had taken to Jerusalem twenty-five years before. During all this period was being fulfilled the “troublous times” dating from Ezra’s decree up to and including all of Nehemiah’s experiences.
On page 66 of “Millennial Dawn,” Vol. II, I read:—
Most writers on this subject have commenced to count this period from the seventh year of Artaxerxes, when a commission was given to Ezra, etc.
It should be remembered that the commission granted to Ezra is spoken of as a decree (Ezra 7:21), while Nehemiah’s grant is neither spoken of as a decree nor as a commission, but simply as a request. Neh. 2:4. In view of this we will now consider the following facts:—
This permission was granted to Nehemiah in the 20th year of Artaxerxes (Neh. 2:1), or thirteen years later than the decree granted to Ezra, which was in the seventh of Artaxerxes. Ezra 7:7. The author of “Millennial Dawn,” having chosen 454 B. C. as the date of Nehemiah’s commission, must now admit the truth of the following logic, as erected upon his own basis: Nehemiah’s commission being granted in 454 B. C., or thirteen years later than the decree given to Ezra,—difference 20th Artaxerxes (Neh. 2:1), minus 7th Artaxerxes (Ezra 7:7) leaves 13 years,—he is forced to admit, while contending for his 454 B. C. standpoint, that Ezra’s decree was granted in 467 B. C.; thus, 454 + 13 = 467. Since he is either compelled to admit this fact or to renounce his 454 B. C. date, we will now examine another point upon a different hypothesis.
Artaxerxes began to reign B. C. 464. (Prideaux, Con., Vol. I, page 222; Smith’s “Comprehensive Dictionary,” art., Artaxerxes.) From the “Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia” I quote: “Artaxerxes Longimaeus reigned from 464-425 B. C.” We now gather the following facts: Ezra’s decree was granted in the 7th of Artaxerxes (Ezra 7:7), and Artaxerxes began to reign in 464 B. C.; therefore, 464—7 gives us 457 B. C. as the date of Ezra’s decree. If this be true, it proves, beyond any reason of doubt, that Nehemiah’s commission was granted in 444 B. C.; thus, 457—13 = 444 B. C.
Is the author of “Millennial Dawn” still willing to contend for the 454 B. C. date of Nehemiah’s commission? If so, we will now force him to assume a still more absurd standpoint, the truth of which he cannot deny, or else renounce his 454 B. C. position. It is as follows: (1) Since his own logic forces him to admit that Ezra’s decree was granted in 467 B. C.; (2) since there is an intervening period of thirteen years between the decree granted to Ezra and the commission of Nehemiah; and (3) since the reign of Artaxerxes began in 464 B. C.; (4) therefore, he is forced to conclude that the decree granted to Ezra by Artaxerxes (Ezra 7:7) was not granted by Artaxerxes, as is stated, but three years prior to the reign of Artaxerxes! Thus the difference between 467 B. C. (according to his logic as the date for Ezra’s decree) and 464 B. C., the date of the beginning of the reign of Artaxerxes, is a period of three years, which gives him no scripture or history with which to substantiate his position! Will he abandon his position, and submit gracefully to the truth? or will he still persist, in the face of all these facts, to attempt to contradict and disarrange all facts of Bible and history in order to establish the year 33 A. D. as the year of our Lord’s crucifixion? How much more reasonable it is to conclude that Luke dates from the beginning of the joint reign of Tiberius Cæsar, which is in perfect harmony with all facts of history, than it is to surmise that he dates from the beginning of his sole reign, which finds him in contradiction with the Bible itself respecting the date of the beginning of the seventy weeks, as well as all facts of profane history.
In order for the editor of the Tower to refute the 457 B. C. date, he is necessarily compelled to disarrange the entire astronomical evidence of the canon of Ptolemy as well as a host of historians, leaving him nothing to build upon but the sole-reign supposition, which is purely supposition, and not supported by a single fact of history, and in direct contradiction to the facts of sacred history.
Thus it is that we are forced to conclude, in the words of another, with more emphasis than ever: “These dates and eras are absolutely unassailable, and can never be overthrown.”