AdventAI

THE REFORMED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH.

By M. H. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 29., July 20, 1897

REFERENCE has been before made in these columns to the fact that the Reformed Presbyterian Church, or Scotch Covenanters, by a vote at a late synod held at Beaver Falls, Pa., condemned the course of Dr. McAllister, editor of the Christian Statesman, for writing certain articles on church unity, which for some time have been appearing in that paper. The Reformed Presbyterian Church is evidently afraid that Dr. McAllister is becoming too liberal in his views of what constitutes the church. The Reformed Presbyterian Church believes in national reform,— that this nation should be made a Christian nation by law,— but while it seeks the assistance of Christians of other faiths than its own to carry out its ideas, it wants it distinctly understood that this work must be done under the lead and direction of the Reformed Presbyterian Church. It has the medicine that is warranted to cure the nation, but it advises its patrons that no medicine advertised for this purpose is genuine unless the bottle containing it has the letters “R. P.” blown in the glass! Nothing else will cure. The synod above referred to has the same feeling toward other organizations, which it seeks to use as allies, as one individual Scotch Covenanter had toward the members of his own local church. Said he: “There are only two Christians in our church,— myself and Sandy,— and sometimes I have my doots about Sandy!” Dr. McAllister has evidently grown too broad for the circumscribed bounds of Reformed Presbyterianism, and the body of his church is beginning to have “doots” about him. The doctor himself, in his defense and explanation, says:—

For a number of years, through unhappy circumstances, an antagonism has been growing up in the body against many forms of associated Christian effort. A strong tide of ultra-conservatism has been growing—a flood-tide since 1891. Co-operation with brethren of other churches, before encouraged, is now condemned. An exaggerated sense of responsibility for the convictions and practices of other portions of the church of Christ is shriveling the broader sympathies that heretofore have characterized the leaders of the old Covenanter Church. A spirit of intolerance toward everything that does not square with certain convictions and interpretations is developing to such an extent that it not only makes a denominational protest against Christian brethren of other denominations the test of loyalty to Christ, but the same spirit also requires conformity with its narrow construction of the principles of the Covenanter Church as a test of loyalty to them.

This condition and trend of the Reformed Presbyterian Church, as described by Dr. McAllister, is not at all surprising. The whole bent of that church appears to be to compel others,— gaining and using the force of civil law if need be,— to think and practise precisely what it thinks and practises. If it reaches out, and tries to ally itself with other Christians for the carrying out of the so-called reforms which it proposes, it desires to use them rather than to co-operate with them. The chief trouble with the Covenanter Church, and with all the host of those who wish to make this nation Christian by such legislative enactments as they conceive to be necessary, is, to use the very words of the doctor, “an exaggerated sense of responsibility for the convictions and the practises of other portions of the church of Christ.”

Christians of any denomination may believe that the particular organization with which they are united is the one nearest right, but this should be coupled with the belief that there are also Christians in other denominations. When a Christian draws a line anywhere around one denomination, or around half a dozen denominations, and excludes all the others, he is wrong. More than this: if upon those outside of this circle of his own drawing, he endeavors to bring the power of the civil law to compel their assent to his creed, he has not yet learned either the spirit or the methods of true Christianity. He is following the papacy. And this, to our mind, is precisely what the Reformed Presbyterian Church and its allies have been attempting to accomplish. But the spirit of narrow bigotry, for a time partially eliminated by the formation of a wider union, has concentrated upon itself; and Dr. McAllister is feeling the effects of it.

Our sympathies, it is needless to say, are with the doctor in his trial. Still he has no reason to complain. His church is only administering to him a little of the medicine, in a very mild form, that he, his church, and his allies, are trying to give to others. His mental and spiritual horizon is a little larger than theirs, but he excludes good Christians from his scheme of church unity. He draws a little larger circle than does his church, but there is much that he has not taken in yet, that is just as good as what he has included. We congratulate the doctor that he is able to see beyond the narrow limits of the Reformed Presbyterian Church, and would assure him that there are “regions beyond,” which even his eagle eye has not yet penetrated.

M. H. K.