AdventAI

OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

By G. C. T.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 30., July 27, 1897

At the recent meeting of the National Teachers' Association in Milwaukee, the question of the character of our public schools was raised and discussed with animation. Some speakers went so far in their unsparing disapproval as to assert that the public schools are a failure in their legitimate purposes, and a menace to progress and civilization. Some contended that the godless, secular character that is maintained unfits our schools for the work of educating and training our youth. It was hardly to be expected that such sentiments would be heard in a convention composed of those who have the public schools of our country in their hands. It is true that they did not meet with general approval; but the fact that they were entertained by some, and broached and discussed in open meeting, composed of thousands of educators, is significant, and is well calculated to arrest attention.

There is no class of people to whom this question is more pertinent and vital than the readers of this paper. It is one to which every Christian parent should give earnest attention.

Our vast public-school system gives employment to a host of men and women of culture and refinement. To say that in every individual case these are all that they should be, would be an unnatural statement. But to say that as a class the teachers and managers of the public schools are earnest, conscientious, devoted, and intelligent, is but to say the truth. Every effort is being put forth by this class to reach the highest point of excellence in their work; and to claim that they are not succeeding in this direction would be to take an unwarranted position. When we try to compare the facilities which were employed thirty years ago with those now in use, or compare the methods and qualifications of the instructors of these two periods, the advancement made in our school system begins to appear.

These schools are established, supported, and promoted by the state. This being the case, it is but natural and right that they should be conducted for the state. But what object can the state have in securing the education of children?—The single object of producing good citizens. The object is a worthy one, necessary for the welfare of society and the preservation of our public institutions. The state that would neglect the education of children, allowing them to grow up in ignorance and its concomitant vices, would pursue thereby a short road to destruction. Therefore, laws compelling the attendance of children upon means of education are wholesome and appropriate from the standpoint of good civil government, and they are wholly within the functions of the state.

Admitting, then, the superior excellence of our public schools, and admitting the vital relation they sustain to the public good, which we gladly do, shall we as Christian parents be satisfied with what they can do and are doing for our children? Can we commit to teachers who may or may not know or care anything about eternal issues, or who, knowing and caring for them, have not the privilege of inculcating them, so sacred and important a trust as the culture and training of the minds of our offspring?

The education of children and youth is not only a civil expedient, but it is a moral and religious duty as well. The Bible admonishes us to “bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.” Our public schools bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the state. It is true that the qualities of good citizenship are in harmony with those of good religion. It is also true that while a Christian is necessarily a good citizen, a good citizen is not necessarily a Christian at all. Then, if our children receive the impression that the public school can do for them all that they need by way of education, they must conclude that Christian principles are no essential part of education, and hence are of no necessity in practical life. When a child or youth is convinced that he can live just as successfully without religious requirements or principles, and that they will be an encumbrance to his prosperity, he will shun them. He is brought into contact, in the public school, with teachers who fear not God, and do not keep his commandments; and yet they are models of civility. They occupy leading places in society, of which they are worthy members. They have winning ways and strong personalities; the youth looks upon them day after day, and comes to admire them, studies their ways, observes their success, and emulates the same. But he hears from the lips of such teachers no words of Christian counsel or admonition. The word of God is ignored; its statements are questioned, its truths discounted; and science, falsely so-called, is exalted above the plain Scriptural story.

Children exposed to such influences walk in a dangerous road. And the greater the power of the school or the teacher to attract, the greater is the danger; so that in many cases the excellence of secular schools gives to them their greatest power for the misleading of our youth. Parents who place their children under such constraints need not be surprised to see their confidence in God undermined, and their love for his truth taken away. A character that is built without God, an education that ignores faith and discounts the Bible, are defective in their most essential features. They jeopardize the salvation and the usefulness of the unfortunate youth to whom they are imparted.

In the development of true manhood or womanhood we recognize three lines of work,— the physical, mental, and moral faculties. In common usage we provide for these in the home, the school, and the church. The parents undertake to care for the bodies of their children, the state provides the school, and the minister keeps up a church. The parents toil early and late to provide food, clothing, shelter, and creature comforts; and as soon as possible, push their children on to the school teacher and the Sabbath school. When they are thus provided for, the majority of parents are well content with the provision they have made. Each of these three factors in education and training is permitted to carry on its work independently of the others. The home takes no interest in the schools; the day-school and the Sabbath school work on different lines. Instead of a symmetrical plan, in which all unite, each works for the ascendancy, and often they work counter to each other, so that the child is distracted, his mind unsettled, and he has to choose between the contending influences as to which shall lead him. If home work is drudgery, and the atmosphere unkind and at variance with the religious principles he hears at the church, he repudiates those, and chooses his public school and its teachers as the genius of his future life.

The only way to avoid such unhappy results—results that are very common—is for the home to become what it should be, the controlling, responsible factor in each department of the education of the child. Let the parents decide what, by the help of God, they desire and purpose to make of the child. “Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honor, and another unto dishonor?”—Yes, indeed. And while God is the divine Potter, the parent is an earthly potter, in whose hands children are placed as lumps of clay. It is proper that the parent should call to his aid such help as will work on the plan he has chosen. But who would entrust a delicate and valuable work to an agent who would not or could not work on lines of which the master could approve? He would prefer to have the work undone rather than to have the object ruined. If, then, a parent decides to have his child trained and educated to fill a place of usefulness in God's cause on earth, and become an heir of God in the world to come, will he resign the mental training of his child to those who, though of superior qualifications in civil training, will mar or neglect his spiritual nature, and fill his mind with doubts and distrust of God and his word? Would it not be better that the parent should refuse to expose his precious child to influences that will weaken the power of the home over the life of the youth, and by economy of time do all he can for the mental child at home? Better still, would he not seek the help of such a school as would supplement his own efforts, and work in harmony with the plan he had marked out?

There is plenty of ground for the assertion of Holy Writ that if we bring up a child in the way he should go, when he is old he will not depart from it. But to secure this end, the bringing up should be consistent and harmonious. With a Christian home, with a church guided by the Spirit, and with a school that works harmoniously with the home and the church, the safety of the child is well secured. But in our public schools the essential element of such a training is lacking, nor can it be supplied; for the state cannot inculcate religion. G. C. T.