THE CHRISTIAN ENDEAVOR CONVENTION OF 1897.
By M. C. Wilcox
The United Societies of Christian Endeavor held their annual international convention this year in the city of San Francisco, Cal., July 6–12. In order to secure the convention, it was necessary for the California friends to guarantee $25,000. This was done, the convention was secured, and the Christian Endeavorers came—twenty thousand, thirty thousand, forty thousand strong—upon the city of San Francisco. They were heartily welcomed. San Francisco had decorated for the “Glorious Fourth” with more than usual elaboration, and to all this she added an abundance of gold and purple bunting. Christian Endeavor banners and the symbolic E were everywhere in evidence. Establishments of all kinds were decorated, and even wine-rooms and saloons held out the welcome to Christian Endeavorers. A magnificent golden arch, abounding in incandescent lights, was erected on Market street, which, in the night, was an object of uncommon beauty and brilliancy. From its keystone hung the symbolic letters in purple and gold. On each side was a broad shield in the Endeavor colors, and from over the arch blazed in electric splendor the word “Welcome.” The two great pavilions of the city, Mechanics’ and Woodward’s, were transformed by bunting, flowers, and other decorations into palaces of barbaric splendor. The former of these seats 10,000 people, while the latter seats half as many. Both were crowded to their utmost capacity, and other halls and large churches were called into requisition. In point of numbers and enthusiasm the convention was a grand success. But the numbers well-nigh swamped the one railway of California. It is estimated that, all told, fifty thousand persons came West. The registration books of the convention contained the names of twenty-six thousand, and then material and badges gave out. Many of the delegates, and fully half of the 50,000 visitors, did not reach California till after the convention began, and twenty-six train-loads came in during the last two days. The baggage was piled up into miniature mountains, and some persons did not obtain theirs until the convention closed. The first meeting was opened with a grand chorus of two thousand voices. Ten thousand listened to the two thousand, and thousands were turned away, so that the chorus was repeated at the close of the convention. Much superior music to what this, at the best, could have been, would not have “drawn” one-half the audience. I mention this merely as an item showing the influence of enthusiasm and great numbers. THE MAGNITUDE AND SCOPE OF THE ENDEAVOR MOVEMENT.
The magnitude of the movement, so far as surface and numbers goes, is enormous. Beginning as a local society under the pastorate of Dr. Francis E. Clark, in Williston church, Portland, Me., in February, 1881, it has grown until now it numbers 50,780 societies in all parts of the world, with a membership of three million. The scope or field of the society is rapidly growing. Formerly it was almost exclusively the Young People’s Society of Christian Endeavor, but now the organization has, besides, its Senior, Intermediate, Junior, and Mothers’ departments. Starting out as a purely religious society, the work of which lay in the field of Christian endeavor, it now embraces politics as well as religion. Against the foundation principles of the society, but little criticism can be brought, except the general one of doing Christian work by a pledge working from without in, and in this way coming to trust in the pledge instead of the life of Jesus Christ. Here is the— Trusting in the Lord Jesus Christ for strength, I promise him that I will strive to do whatever he would like to have me do; that I will make it the rule of my life to pray and to read the Bible every day, and to support my own church in every way, especially by attending all her regular Sunday and mid-week services, unless prevented by some reason which I can conscientiously give to my Saviour; and that, just so far as I know now, throughout my whole life, I will endeavor to lead a Christian life. As an active member, I promise to be true to all my duties, to be present at and to take some part, aside from singing, in every Christian Endeavor prayer-meeting, unless hindered by some reason which I can conscientiously give to my Lord and Master. If obliged to be absent from the monthly consecration meeting of the society, I will, if possible, send at least a verse of scripture to be read in response to my name at the roll-call. In a little tract by Dr. Clark on the society and its constitution, we are told that the society “is simply an organized effort to lead the young people to Christ and into his church, to establish them firmly in the faith, and to set them at work in the Lord’s vineyard. The main point upon which the constitution insists is the weekly prayer-meeting.” “These rules concerning the weekly prayer meeting are imperative; without them, there cannot be a true society of Christian Endeavor.” And this is true; for the very life of the Christian is dependent upon prayer. Again: “The purely religious features of the organization shall always be paramount.” In all the committees or officers suggested by the constitution, by-laws, or other information given in connection therewith, there is neither committee nor officer for political work of any kind. In its relations to the respective church in which it is organized, all the officers of the church, if not active members, are considered as honorary members of the society, the pastor is an ex-officio member of the nominating committee, and the election of officers is subject to revision or veto by the church, so that “in every way the society shall put itself under the control of the official board of the church,” and shall report to the church as often as the church may direct. Thus loyalty to the church is strongly emphasized. All this study of the word of God, work for God, loyalty to the church of God, and deference to those who are older, and upon whom God has laid the responsibility of guiding in his work, are good; and every truly broad-minded Christian cannot but wish this part of the work Godspeed, and pray that God may, by this means, lead all these enthusiastic young hearts to the full knowledge of Jesus Christ and his truth. Another good feature of the work is that the purely business features are not accorded much prominence. “Sharp parliamentary practice and long or heated discussion should be discouraged.” It is plainly said that the society “is not a debating society.” The aim is to do all this work through executive and other committees. It was so at this great convention. No legislative work was done before the convention, but it was transacted in the great committees.484 So much for the general plans and principles upon which the organization was founded. It could be devoutly wished that it had so continued. But in an evil day, so-called “National Reform” elements crept in, and obtained a hold in this growing organization. First, those who hope to secure a holy day by civil law began the endeavor to enlist the enthusiasm of these youth for the “American Sabbath,” and the next thing sprung upon them was the soul-destroying, country-destroying, and church-destroying fallacy of “Christian Citizenship,”—the reforming of society and the government by the ballot. All this mighty host are not yet enlisted in the movements of civil Sunday laws and “Christian Citizenship.” If each one could be examined personally in the light of the gospel, we believe the majority would repudiate these so-called “reforms.” We have reason to believe that some of their more spiritual leaders deprecate the incoming of these political leaders. Many of the talks and sermons were diametrically opposed to the methods involved in the Sunday law and “Christian Citizenship” movement. These instructions were full of the gospel of Jesus Christ, rich in spiritual suggestion, and were accompanied by an unction which showed that the speakers had “tasted the good word of God.” Yet, notwithstanding this, notwithstanding the hearty response which some of these talks met, we were profoundly convinced that unless God shall interpose with some miracle, this whole Endeavor movement will be, by Satan’s craft, perverted, and by a deceived leadership, swung over to the side of a religio-political regime, the effect of which will prove to be ruin to both church and state. Some of the reasons why I believe this are the following: The great mass of the Endeavorers are lacking in vital Christian experience. It is much easier for them to understand the things of the world than the things of God. And even though their leaders on both sides of this controversy are equally able, eloquent, and earnest, the general mass understand and heed the language of the politician when they do not mind the deep things of God, which would save them. Furthermore, the spiritual-minded leaders do not oppose the political-minded, while the political-minded are earnestly endorsing what is said by the spiritual, at the same time declaring that Christianity and citizenship are convertible terms. It was stated over and over that the best citizen is the best Christian, and that the best Christian is the man who takes an active interest in politics; in fact, that the man who does not do this is not a good Christian. The young women were exhorted to work for the ballot, that they might exercise the rights of citizenship, and so be helpers in giving the nation and the world to Christ. Political pomp, political power and prestige, and political methods may be and are understood by the unconverted, the superficial, and the half-hearted professor; and so if the efforts of these leaders do not receive the open endorsement of all in the society, they receive the opposition of none, and therefore will carry the great host into the ranks of antichristian forces. The “Sabbath Observance Committee” held a meeting to consider some of the best ways of conducting “Sabbath reform.” President Reid, of California, stated that “three hundred Lord’s day committees” had been organized in this State since last March, and they had won the banner offered by Mr. Crafts for the State which earned the most “points.” He said, “The societies can be depended upon to do what they are asked to do.” The plan, in general, has been to circulate a general petition, and obtain the signatures of the majority of the people not to trade on Sundays; then to go to the merchants, and petition them not to sell on Sundays. In this way the stores and shops of some towns have been closed. Other petitions against open post-offices, bicycling on Sundays, and Sunday newspapers were mentioned. This was thought to be the most effectual way of molding public sentiment. Even Jews had succumbed to it and closed their stores. In this way one gets the influence of neighbor and name upon others, a quite effectual political way, but not God’s way. Only those can observe his day who observe it to him alone. One delegate drifted into a discussion of the respective days, the seventh and the first, and the change from one to the other, but to this the chairman objected. All believe, he said, that “the Sabbath must be maintained,” and all stand upon the “ground that Sunday, the first day of the week, is the day for which the Christian Endeavor societies are striving to obtain rest.” On the Sunday afternoon of the convention at Mechanic’s Pavilion, the question was presented before a great audience by Miss Matilda Kay, of New York, on “Woman’s Part in the Work;” Rev. W. H. G. Temple, of Washington, on “Modern Forms of Sabbath Desecration;” Rev. Josiah Strong, on “The Civil Sabbath;” and Rev. Robert Johnston, of London, Ontario, on “The Claims of God; Keep It Holy,” Dr. Francis E. Clark presiding. The chairman, after saying that there was “no more important subject” on the program, called attention to the “significant fact” that the convention where the Sabbath question “was emphasized the most was the California convention of ’97.” It had been talked of at other conventions, “but more conspicuous attention had been given to it here than at any other,” and this because California friends desired it. And while California has no Sunday law, it is in California that this “movement is most vigorous,” and he thought that “the wave of influence for this great reform starting here,” “may turn backward, and overflow with its blessing all the East.” Miss Kay’s speech was an appeal to woman to do her part, and she recited an all-comprehending pledge which she asked them all to take. Dr. Temple said: “The last thing that a speaker ought to be called upon to defend in this Christian country is the Christian Sabbath. And yet we have to stand guard over it with drawn swords, lest some new form of iniquity put its hoof upon this sacred institution, and defile it.” This statement ought to have been sufficient to show that neither Sabbath nor country is Christian; for if the country were Christian, the people would honor all things Christian; and if the Sunday were Christian, Christ would defend it. Dr. Temple would not return to the Puritan Sabbath; he would float from secular to sacred time on the wings of sleep; but he believed that on Saturday evening at sundown the preparation for the Sabbath should be made. He “would have Saturday evening spent around the fireside, with the hush of the anticipation of the Sabbath in it.” Thus, while ignoring God’s law, he would borrow a portion of its fashion to honor a false Sabbath. Among its chief foes he mentioned “a godless rationalism,” “the hand of greed,” “the American saloon,” and “unsanctified pleasure.” He would not prevent the workman from getting a breath of fresh air on Sunday, nor would he close the public libraries or the museums. Man could go to these if it would “do him any good; but he must have the purest motives in so doing,” yet Sunday picnics must not be held. He said: “If you destroy the American Sabbath, you strike directly at the foundations of this nation.” “I adjure you, by the most solemn vows you can take, to preserve the integrity as well as the entirety of this nation, and see to it that it shall have a Sabbath that shall come to it with its holy hush upon its great multitudes.” Josiah Strong endeavored to show that the civil and religious Sabbaths were “quite distinct in their origin, their authority, and their character.” They become confounded because “these two Sabbaths are coincident in point of time.” And both the opposers and defenders of Sunday laws hold this misconception. And yet before Dr. Strong finished, he defended the civil Sunday laws, not only from a hygienic standpoint, but on the ground of “public morals” and a religious basis. He said that “there are certain amusements which are hostile to the morals because they are hostile to the religious observance of the day. The holiday Sabbath has been found to be subversive of religion, therefore subversive of morals, because religion is the tap-root of morals.” Thus did Rev. Josiah Strong, president of the Evangelical Alliance, show the fallacy of his own illogical claim of two distinct Sabbaths out of one Sunday. The whole thing rests upon the religious Sunday. He said that it was “the hope and aim and present plan of the Evangelical Alliance of the United States to secure the co-operation of all these young peoples’ organizations in this reform. If these young people, as they could, would “sow the State with literature showing the character of the civil Sabbath, the value of the physical Sabbath, the intellectual Sabbath, the spiritual Sabbath, they would so prepare the minds of the people that they would be enabled to get a workable Sabbath law. We are only beginning to appreciate the value of co-operation. Our individual influence may be light as air, but with these young people in a mass moving together, we can shake the continent.” Of course the outcome is to be a universal Sunday law, but this is not the evangel of Christ. Rev. Robert Johnson made a plea for the Sabbath from the religious side,—an eloquent, earnest plea, from the Bible standpoint,—all of which was meant for Sunday, but which applied to one day, and one alone,—the seventh day. He mentioned the commandment, the foundation of the Sabbath in Eden, the fall of the manna, and Christ and his apostles. Said he of Christ:— Never, by word or deed or inference, did Jesus Christ detract from the holiness, the sacredness, of that day as a day that was to be the Lord’s and spent Godward. The apostolic example follows in the same line; and so from creation down through the ages of the Old Testament and the New, we have one line of testimony, as if God by every avenue through which he could reach man’s soul would write this word on his heart, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.” There is much more of interest, but I must draw this long report to a close. In nearly all that was said there was appeal to patriotism and to loyalty to Sunday as a mark of that patriotism; and this was by many heartily applauded. I could have wept if it would have done any good, as I thought of the millions of brave young hearts deceived by quaffing the wine of Babylon,—the evil doctrines of church-and-state union,—and my prayer was that God will pour out of his Spirit mightily upon his people, that these millions may be enlightened. This will not be by cold argument; they will not be reached by the naked presentation of theoretical truth, but only by the power of God in the tender, sweet presentation of the blessed gospel in word and deed, by the printed page, and more, by “living epistles” of Jesus Christ. Our message is, “Fear God, and give glory to him.” O, the power of men over men to lead them into the by-paths of error! Let the people of God exalt Christ and his word. It is only by knowing his truth, knowing it in heart and life, that we may be saved from the great delusions of the last days, and be able to save others. Blessed is he who turns from all the distillations of human knowledge, from all the brewings of men, and drinks daily and only from the fountain of life.