A French Catholic writer, in a late work entitled, “The Church and Modern France,” which book is approved by the pope, referring to the relations of the Catholic Church to the government here, makes this very significant confession: “Assuredly he [the pope] is far from approving the principles of the American Constitution, with its absolute separation of church and state in matters of religion.” No doubt this statement is true. Popes never have relished freedom of religion; it would be the greatest folly to say that they have ever done so. This being true, they cannot favor the establishment of governments where this principle is established. How, then, can a genuine Catholic—one who believes in the church and the pope—be a loyal supporter of the United States Constitution? He may give it a quasi support; but would a Catholic support it against the pope, if that pontiff should think a favorable time had come to change it so that it would more nearly represent the traditions and practises of the infallible (?) church?—Evidently he would not. With him the constitution is but an expedient, a makeshift, which is allowed to exist until something better, something more in harmony with the church, can be obtained.
The present pope has said that the Catholic Church here is “unopposed by the Constitution and government of the nation, fettered by no hostile legislation, protected against violence by the common laws, and free to live and act without hindrance.” But is he satisfied with the liberty of the Catholic Church here?—No, indeed! He exactly agrees with the French priest whom we have quoted; and he further says: “The church would bring forth more abundant fruits if, in addition to liberty, she enjoyed the favor of the laws and the patronage of the public authority.” (See encyclical of 1895 addressed to American bishops.) Would he not be glad to see “more abundant fruits”?—Surely he would; and this is but another way of saying that he would be glad to see the religious liberty clause struck out of our Constitution; and if he desires it, why would not all his followers, who look upon him as an infallible guide and counselor, also desire it? M. E K.