ROYALTIES

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 17, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 33.

Read the full edition

ROYALTIES

The term “royalty” is used to indicate the money paid to the owner or author of an article by the party that undertakes to develop the article and to place it on the market. One who invents some useful object frequently makes an arrangement with a manufacturer by which the latter shall manufacture the article, sell the same, and pay to the patentee a certain per cent. of the proceeds, which payment is called a royalty. In writing a book it is usual for the author either to sell to a publisher the manuscript with the right to publish the book, or to agree with the publisher to receive a per cent. on the sales of the book, and this per cent. is a royalty. As the question of the payment of book royalties is a live one with our publishing houses, and one in which the friends of these houses are interested, it will not be out of place to tell our readers how the matter is regarded in this Office, and, as far as we know, in all our offices; And what is being done in the way of paying royalties.
Upon the point of propriety there will be no dispute. It is perfectly evident to all that a book produced by a writer is his property as much as any other object is the property of the one who produces it. An author not only puts into his book the time and labor of writing and preparing it for the press, but a well-written book represents an amount of labor of which the work of actual writing bears but a small part. Years of study and of experience, and much costly knowledge, are contained in most books.
The author necessarily assumes a risk in the production of a book, for he cannot well judge of the reception which it may meet, and his best judgment will often be seriously at fault. Past experience shows that it generally errs on the costly side. It is easy for an author to see more in his book than the average reader can see in it.
The books issued by our publishing houses do not, as a general rule, meet with a very extensive sale, for reasons that are apparent to all. They are not written in the popular strain. They are not sensational; and in many cases the truths they teach are not congenial to the average reader. Our writers have not the object to tickle the public ear, or to gain popular favor. They write on the lines of truth that are needed in a time like this, and leave the matter to find its way to candid readers, here and there, who are searching for something upon which their souls can feed. For this cause neither writers nor publishers find our work as profitable in money matters as many other classes of writers and publishers find theirs to be. We all reckon that this is a work with which sacrifice, in a worldly sense, is associated. Consequently, as a general thing our workers have been called upon to work for less considerations than the world holds out for the same class of talent.
Though in some cases authors and publishers have agreed upon a price for the manuscript, yet the way generally preferred by both is the royalty plan. The amount paid is never large as compared with that paid in other lines of literature. The amount varies with circumstances. Where the book is certain of a wide sale, the matter is more easily adjusted, as both parties are likely to be remunerated for their work. But where the sale is destined to be limited, neither the author nor the publisher can hope for a satisfactory result, if financial success be the only thing aimed at. From five to twenty per cent. is therefore paid in royalties, and though the latter figure is seldom reached, yet, in rare instances, it has exceeded that.
Perhaps there is no writer among us in whose royalties our readers will take more interest than in those of Mrs. E. G. White. Though the arrangement is necessarily an entirely private one, and we have not had any opportunity to consult her in reference to making it known, nor received any permission from her to do so, it seems not out of place to allude to it. The royalties paid to Mrs. White vary with different books. On those books that are sold by the trade exclusively, and have but a limited circulation, the royalty paid is ten per cent.; on her other books, those sold extensively and by canvassers, an average of about five per cent. is paid; so that the average would be not more than six or seven per cent. But in the case of Sister White the author is to the expense of thoroughly preparing the matter for the printer, setting the type, and making the plates, as well as providing illustrations, so that her books are prepared for the press at the expense of the writer (an unusual thing), and this large expense must be met before the writer receives any benefit financially. When this is taken into consideration, it will be seen that the royalty is exceedingly small, and that the financial burden is almost exclusively borne by the writer. There is almost no risk assumed by the publishers, who simply furnish the material, and do the mechanical work on the books as fast as there is a demand for them. This is substantially the arrangement that has stood for several years, so that previously she has not received more than now.
That none of our authors are waxing rich through their literary work is so apparent that it hardly needs to be said. As to whether an author should receive a royalty while he is at the same time receiving a salary for his time, depends upon several considerations. Where a person sells his time for the purpose of writing a book, then his work is the property of his employer. Where a person takes the time for writing his book from the time for which he is paid, and the writing of the book detracts that much from the quality or quantity of his work, then he is in that degree wronging his employer. The same is true of any other business. A man who is employed to conduct business for another, and neglects his employer’s work for his own interests, wrongs his employer. But in a case where an individual does faithfully and well the work assigned him and expected of him, and in addition gives to the world a book, the writing of which does not interfere with the discharge of his duties, and the material of which he does not draw from his employers, but from his own resources, then the case is different. The employer can have no claim on a book thus written. And it is thus that many of our books are written. Our laborers gather up the material, study their subjects, and ponder the matter for years before the book appears. They work at its production often when other people are at rest, and their own quota of other work is more than done. Who will, under such circumstances, deny to them the little pittance their work shall bring them?
Taking the case which we have already referred to for an illustration, let us look at the circumstances. It is true that Mrs. White receives an ordinary salary from the General Conference. But who will say that her place is that of a sinecure? Who does not know something of the intensity of her labors? And yet how few there are who really understand how heavy they are! The Lord has placed upon his servant a burden in connection with every feature of this work; and in addition to this are innumerable personal matters for which she gives her time and the strength that, in a remarkable manner, is given her day by day. In addition to this, her books are written. How they are written is the wonder, but we know that word by word her own pen traces those volumes. She does not write by dictation, but with her own hands; and in those writings no changes more than those of a verbal nature are made by the copyist and editor.
In a letter to the publishers of her works, just received, Sister White says: “The means I hoped to receive has not answered my expectation, and yet I must do all I possibly can to help in various ways the cause in this missionary field. I have hired (for the benefit of the cause here) and am paying interest upon one thousand pounds from one, one hundred pounds from another source (over $5000), and have loaned the conference one hundred pounds without interest. I wish to use that money at once in building a meeting-house. I wish to invest all that I possibly can in the advancement of the work in this country. What is done should go forward without delay. I do not want my brethren to feel that in crowding down the royalties on books issued from the offices over which they preside that they are doing God service. I am straining every nerve to advance the work in this country, that God may be glorified. I am not seeking to hoard money or to live extravagantly; and I call on those in responsible places to co-operate with me all that they possibly can to make the work God has given me to do a success.
“How soon these large sums of money will be called for I know not. I have to pay my workers to prepare my books and pay for the publishing, and I want no more than is fair and right. But I do not want my brethren to think that they must be sharp with Sister White, and that the end justifies the means. All that kind of sharpness robs destitute fields. These will have all that she can receive from the sale of her books. I am hoarding up nothing. No one could spread a more economical table, and yet supply nourishing food.”
This was not meant for publication; but coming from her own pen, it states in part what, from personal knowledge, we know to be the facts in the case. Sister White has a large heart, full of sympathy for the poor, as well as for the cause at large. Continually she is dispensing here and there of her means, even before it is actually received. She has not accumulated wealth, nor does she live with any such purpose.
In view of the circumstances, it seems proper that our people should have at least some understanding of a subject that has not been understood, but has in some cases been a source of perplexity. If on the part of any there has been a suspicion that these matters are not being conducted as they should be, it is our earnest hope that this statement of the case will be helpful to such.
G. C. T.