“IF’S” AND “WHY’S.”—NO. 2.
WM. P. PEARCE
(Goshen, Ind.)
MODE UPHELD BY NUMBERS.
IF Chrysostom immersed three thousand in Constantinople, April 16, A. D. 404; IF, according to Dr. Todd (“Life of Patrick,” page 442), twelve thousand were baptized in one day; IF Paulinus baptized ten thousand in the River Swale (Brit., Vol. III, page 257, London, 1806), and three thousand in one day in the Pool of Harbottle, Northumberland, A. D. 627; IF, according to Dean Stanley, Vladimir ordered the people of Kieff to be baptized, and on a “set day” thousands obeyed the command (“Eastern Church,” page 291); IF Dr. Clough, in Ongole, India, in 1878, with six assistants, only two baptizing at a time, baptized two thousand two hundred and twenty-two in six hours,—WHY could not Peter, with his eleven companions or the one hundred and twenty disciples, immerse three thousand in one day? “And . . . Peter stood up in the midst of the disciples, . . . (the number of names together were about an hundred and twenty).” Acts 1:15.
MODE SUSTAINED BY CLIMATES.
IF climates, because cold, should make a difference in the mode of baptism, as so many teach, WHY does the Greek Church of Russia, without variation to this day, immerse all candidates seeking church membership, and all infants belonging to the families of that church?
MODE BEYOND DOUBT.
IF there is a doubt in immersion,—which certainly there can not be to an unbiased Biblical and historical student, for, as Professor Stuart says (“Christian Baptism,” page 72), “The passages which refer to immersion are so numerous that it would take a little volume merely to recite them,” he himself quoting fourteen,—WHY is it that no immersed person ever leaves his church because he is dissatisfied with his baptism, while thousands of sprinkled persons do? If there is no doubt about sprinkling or pouring, as pedobaptists assert, WHY, then, do multitudes question the validity of sprinkling and pouring?
SPRINKLING NOT BAPTISM.
IF sprinkling, or affusion, is baptism, WHY can not the beautiful symbol of death and resurrection, which Paul describes in Col. 2:12,—“Buried with him in baptism, wherein also ye are risen with him,”—be derived from this? WHY was sprinkling not instituted in the North African Church before the third century? WHY was it not until the year 1311 that the council held at Ravenna declared immersion or sprinkling to be indifferent? (“Edinburgh Encyclopedia,” Vol. III, page 236.) WHY was it not introduced into England before Elizabeth’s time, and why did the prayer-book of 1552 demand immersion? WHY did the assembly of divines at Westminster in 1643 vote on baptism, which vote stood twenty-five for sprinkling and twenty-four for immersion? WHY do the Catholics of Milan, the Greek Church of Russia, and several other societies demand nothing but immersion to-day?
“CLEAN WATER” NOT BAPTISM.
IF the passage in Eze. 36:25, referred to by pedobaptists as a proof of baptism by sprinkling,—“Then will I sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean,”—has reference to baptism, WHY did the priest mix the ashes of a red heifer or the blood of a dove with it, preparing, according to a divine ritual, in the words of the ceremonial law, “water of purifying”? Num. 8:7. WHY does the heifer, red in color, led in a public procession, slain without the camp, consumed by fire, typify Christ in his march to Calvary, and man’s justification from sin, IF it has any reference to any mode of baptism? See Numbers 19. IF the “clean water” refers to baptism, WHY did the priest take the dove, and over a vessel of water slay it, allowing the blood to drop therein? WHY did he take a second dove, and plunge it, head, wings, feet, and feathers, into the blood-dyed waters, and then restore it to liberty, IF it was not a type of a sinner to whom a Saviour’s merits are to be imputed,—an image of a pardoned soul on his path to glory? WHY try to prove baptism from a mediational and purifying subject that has naught to do with it, when IF it had, Jesus would have been the first to recognize it?
CIRCUMCISION VERSUS BAPTISM.
IF baptism takes the place of circumcision, as many advocate, WHY are not infants baptized on the eighth day? “And he that is eight days old shall be circumcised among you.” Gen. 17:12. WHY not named on that day? “And it came to pass, that on the eighth day they came to circumcise the child; and they called him Zacharias.” Luke 1:59. “And when eight days were accomplished for the circumcising of the child, his name was called Jesus.” Luke 2:21. WHY not make the rite compulsory, and demand it only of one sex? “And he that is eight days old SHALL be circumcised among you, every man child in your generations.” Gen. 17:12. WHY were Jesus and John baptized after circumcision, and why was Timotheus circumcised after baptism? Luke 2:21; Matt. 3:13. “Took and circumcised him because of the Jews which were in those quarters.” Acts 16:3. WHY should not all Christians be placed again under the law, IF baptism takes the place of circumcision? “For I testify again to every man that is circumcised, that he is a debtor to do the whole law.” Gal. 5:3.
RABBINICAL DEDICATION NOT BAPTISM.
IF Christ’s blessing children has reference to baptism (“And he took them up in his arms, put his hands upon them, and blessed them.” Mark 10:16), WHY does it not state something regarding it? WHY does it omit the mentioning of water? WHY did not Christ deviate from a Jewish custom, which attributed high value to the blessing of a person distinguished for age and piety? Gen. 48:14. WHY did not Christ deviate from the rabbinical custom of dedication on this occasion? “And brought him unto the house of the Lord in Shiloh: and the child was young. And they slew a bullock, and brought the child to Eli. And she said,” etc. 1 Sam. 1:24–28. IF this beautiful instance of Christ’s blessing the children refers in any sense to infant or child baptism, WHY can no trace of such be found in the whole of the New Testament? WHY should Professor Stuart say: “Commands or plain and certain examples I do not find”? (“Biblical Repository,” 1833, page 385.) WHY did Dr. Neander write: “The practise of infant baptism was unknown to the apostolic age”? (“Church History,” Vol. I, page 311.)
SUBJECTS OF BAPTISM.
IF baptism is not a rite only for persons who have reached an age capable of thinking for themselves, WHY should the requisites be so rigid and far-reaching? First, repentance. “Repent, and be baptized.” Acts 2:38. Second, belief. “If thou believest with all thy heart, thou mayest.” Acts 8:37. WHY should Jesus Christ say: “Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them” (Matt. 28:19), IF he had reference to any one incapable of being taught regarding contaminating influences of sin, repentance of the same, and belief in One who can save from such? WHY is it, in the words of Mr. T. Boston, a pedobaptist writer (Works, page 384), that “there is no example of baptism recorded in the Scriptures where any were baptized but such as appeared to have a saving interest in Christ”?
NO BABY BAPTISM.
IF baby baptism is Biblical, WHY is it that such can not be substantiated by giving chapter and verse where found? WHY are not babies taught, as Jesus commanded in the disciples’ commission? Matt. 28:19. IF incapable of being taught, WHY are they not incapable of receiving a higher ordinance? WHY do not they repent? Acts 2:38. IF they have nothing to repent of, WHY need they the rite of baptism? WHY not have them believe in Christ? Acts 8:37. IF unable to think in any degree consecutively, WHY bestow upon them the initiatory to church relationship, which rite is a visible evidence of an inward and spiritual grace through faith in Jesus Christ?