M. E. KELLOGG.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
In recent years, discoveries of fragments of writings have been made of very great age, presumably of the second century after Christ, containing his reputed sayings. The credence that is given these by scholarly critics has raised the question whether there may have been earlier writings containing the history of Christ’s work on the earth than any that we now possess. The apostle Paul quotes an expression of Christ, “It is more blessed to give than to receive” (Acts 20:35), which is not recorded in any of the four Gospels. Other expressions, not in the Gospels, but found in the writings of Clement and Polycarp, lead critics to believe that there was a writing of ancient date containing at least some of the sayings of Christ, which was known to Paul and to others; and that they quoted from it.
This may be true; but the further deduction of the critics—that the writers of the four accepted gospel narratives drew their information from some previous history—does not necessarily follow. Matthew, Mark, and John were eye-witnesses of Jesus’ miracles, and heard his teaching; Matthew and John were intimately associated with him; while Luke “had perfect understanding of all things from the very first.” Furthermore, the Holy Spirit guided them in their writing. We are therefore fully satisfied with the divine authenticity and inspiration of the record of Christ as we have it. There can be no earlier records than those written by men who were “eye-witnesses of his majesty.” 2 Peter 1:16.
Yet at the same time due reverence for Him who spake as never man spake before or since, should incline us to treat with respect any words that appear to have emanated from him, testing them always by comparing them with his known words.
These latest found sayings ascribed to Christ were discovered in Egypt. They have all the signs of a very great antiquity. Most of these expressions are similar to those found in the accepted Gospels. One of them refers to the Sabbath, in which no one, since all admit that Christ kept the Sabbath, can fail to be interested. The saying reads thus: “Jesus saith, Except ye fast to the world, ye shall in no wise find the kingdom of God; and except ye keep the Sabbath, ye shall not see the Father.”
If this be accepted as a veritable saying of Christ, it is a plain direction that the Sabbath should be kept. The fourth commandment itself is not a clearer command than this. Furthermore, it is in perfect harmony with Christ’s practise and teachings as set forth in the Gospels. None but the Pharisees ever dared to accuse Christ of breaking the Sabbath, and they could bring the charge only by blending their own notions and traditions with the Sabbath law, and demanding the observance of them. Christ’s statement, “I have kept my Father’s commandments,” and his reply to those who accused him of Sabbath-breaking,—that if they had known the meaning of a certain scripture, they “would not have condemned the guiltless” (Matt. 12:7),—are sufficient proof that he kept the Sabbath.
But since the majority of professed Christians have, in their doctrines and practises, departed from Christ’s example and teachings in this respect, and, like one of old, have chosen another day, of their own devising (see 1 Kings 12:33), it can not be expected that they will change their course should there be found other sayings of Christ, which are opposed to their practises. So, immediately upon the discovery of this supposed saying of Christ, the critics and theologians who believe that it is a real saying of Christ, make haste to declare that it does not mean just what it says!
For instance, Prof. J. R. Harris, of Cambridge University, who is a firm believer in the authenticity of these sayings, declares of those we have quoted, “They have nothing to do with fasting or keeping the Sabbath in the common sense”! He further says: “The idea that it involves the obligation of fasting and Sabbath-keeping is the exact opposite of the truth”! And that is simply to say that if Christ said this, he meant the exact opposite to what he said!
Let us suppose for a moment that these sayings read differently,—that they were directly opposite to what they do say: “Ye need not fast, and ye need not keep the Sabbath,” would these zealous and learned critics, who are now so eager to prove that Christ did not mean what he said, reason in the same way as now, and urge that we must fast and keep the Sabbath? If not, why not?
The professor goes back to some of the writings of the early “Fathers” of the church, and finds them inculcating the idea that Christians need not fast nor keep the Sabbath, and so he would judge the meaning of the words of Christ by the words of these Fathers. Would it not be better to judge the meaning of these reputed sayings of Christ by his own accepted words upon similar subjects? Shall we allow Christ’s words to be explained by Justin or Clement, rather than by himself?
We would now ask, What did Christ teach in regard to fasting?—“Then came to him the disciples of John, saying, Why do we and the Pharisees fast oft, but thy disciples fast not? And Jesus said unto them, Can the children of the bridechamber mourn, as long as the bridegroom is with them? but the days will come, when the bridegroom shall be taken from them, and then shall they fast.” Matt. 9:14, 15.
Those days soon came, and the bridegroom was taken from them. He is gone from his people now, and will be gone until he comes the second time. Are not these days, then, days of fasting? The early church practised fasting. See Acts 13:2; 14:23; 1 Cor. 7:5; 2 Cor. 11:27. It may be that Justin Martyr, and others of the so-called “Fathers,” did not fast; but it is absolutely certain that Paul, and others under his direction, did fast. It is also certain that Paul kept the Sabbath. Acts 28:17. So, contrary to the opinion of the learned critics, we must come to the conclusion that if these are genuine sayings of Christ, they mean just what they say, and are in harmony with the received Gospels, which also mean what they say.
I base nothing upon these sayings. The one referring to the Sabbath is not needed to prove that the Sabbath should be kept; nor do we need the one in regard to fasting to prove that fasting is a religious duty. But I do affirm that, taking the sayings I have quoted as they read, and according to their obvious sense, they agree with the custom and teaching of Christ in regard to the Sabbath (Luke 4:16), and his teaching in regard to fasting.