PRESBYTERIANS, SUNDAY, AND WAR

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 31, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 22.

Read the full edition

PRESBYTERIANS, SUNDAY, AND WAR.

At Winona Lake, Ind., the one hundred and tenth General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of the United States was lately held. On May 20 the report of the Committee on “Sabbath Observance” was presented; and for two hours there was, from all accounts, a stormy time. The report embodied a series of resolutions of a more radical character than had ever been presented to the General Assembly. One clause called upon all members of the church to abstain from the purchase and reading of Sunday newspapers, the riding of bicycles, or driving for pleasure, recreation, or business on Sunday. It also placed a ban on all forms of amusement, unnecessary work and visiting, and Sunday excursions. Another clause requested the directors of the trans-Mississippi Exposition, which is about to open at Omaha, to close its gates on Sunday.
But the resolution that brought forth the most pronounced feeling was one requesting the President to avoid any unnecessary use of the army and navy on Sunday. No sooner was it read than a dozen men were clamoring for recognition. Finally Rev. W. H. Hudnut, of Brooklyn, N. Y., spoke, moving that the resolution be stricken out. “For,” said he, “if Dewey had not struck the blow in Manila Bay on Sunday,—and I claim it was a holy act,—he might never have—”
The conclusion of the sentence was lost in the applause that followed. When quiet was restored, Rev. J. A. Green, of Negaunee, Mich., waved his hand for recognition, and said:—
This assembly can not afford to go on record as instructing President McKinley in the direction of the army and navy. It would be improper at this time. I am sure that we, as a church, have every confidence in his ability to direct the armed forces of the nation in this war for humanity’s sake.
This brought forth a volley of cheers and applause, that shook the auditorium. It was just as significant as a formal vote endorsing the President’s war policy. There was much of this kind of talk, but at last the resolution was laid on the table.
Commenting on this incident, the Detroit News-Tribune remarks:—
There are a good many “open questions” relating to Sabbath observance. But religious people strangely fail to see that these questions relate to their own conduct; and not that of other people. There is not the slightest objection to any man’s observing the Sabbath as the Puritans observed it. The News-Tribune would be out of its sphere if it were to scoff at the way the Adventists, Presbyterians, Roman Catholics, or any other religious body, choose to limit their own action on the first or seventh day of the week. The News-Tribune has not only a right, but a duty, to resist the efforts of any of these religious bodies to dictate the manner in which the rest of the world shall observe this ceremonial part of life. Sabbatarians always fail to see this point. They fail to see that what is law to them is not necessarily to be forced on other people. If the gentleman who proposed to induce the Presbyterian Assembly to ask the President not to begin any battles on Sunday, had simply proposed that “We, Presbyterians, resolve not to do any fighting on Sunday,” the resolution would have been all right if the Assembly had adopted it. But to impose this rule on seventy million fighting people is too absurd to turn into a respectable joke.
W. E. C.