In the United Presbyterian of June 16 we find this item in reference to W. E. Gladstone:—
“William Ewart Gladstone was laid to rest in Westminster Abbey.” So writes one in speaking of the burial of the great English statesman. Rather, let us say, His body rests in the grave, but his soul is with Christ in paradise.
If any wish to express their belief that Mr. Gladstone will have a part in the first resurrection, and so in the blessings of eternal life in the world to come, it is their privilege to do so. That point is not here in question; but why say that his soul is now with Christ in paradise? Of course allusion is made to the words of Christ to the thief on the cross, “Thou shalt be with me in paradise.” But Christ did not say to the thief that he should be with him in paradise that very day. He only gave him the promise that day; but the fulfilment of the promise looked far over into the future, when Christ should come in his glory. This is shown by the fact that the thief did not die that day (John 19:32, 33), so the supposed soul of the thief did not leave the body, and go to paradise that day; and the third day after the crucifixion, Christ himself declared that he had not then been to paradise. John 20:17.
It is claimed that when Christ said, “Thou shalt be with me in paradise,” the pronoun “thou” must mean the thief’s soul, the real man. Very good. But couple with this the fact that over four thousand years before these words were uttered, God had pronounced a sentence upon this same “thou,” in the circumstance of death, conveying an idea very different from that of its going to paradise. In pronouncing sentence upon Adam, after his sin, God said: “In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” Gen. 3:19. Here is the original sentence upon all that is represented by the pronoun “thou,” as the result of death. Then why say that Mr. Gladstone’s soul went to be with Christ in paradise, instead of saying, as the writer quoted did say, that Mr. Gladstone was laid to rest in Westminster Abbey?
If the Bible had anywhere brought to view any such thing as a soul, according to the popular conception, capable of existing without the body, and which, in a conscious, intelligent state, left the body at death, to ascend to heaven, or otherwise entertain itself in a disembodied condition, there might be some ground for the suggestion which the Presbyterian recommends. But while no such entity is even hinted at in all the Scriptures, and no instance is given of a soul’s going to be with Christ in paradise at the death of the body, why make such a claim in the case referred to? We heartily endorse the exhortation as far as to the words, “Let us;” but we would finish the thought by saying, “Let us” adhere to Bible statements and Bible representations on this and all other questions, and not to the theories and traditions of antediluvian and medieval theology. U. S.