That Prof. Charles A. Briggs, D. D., of Union Theological Seminary, whose extravagances in “higher criticism” and “salvation after death” have caused much discussion in the last three or four years, is now advocating prayers and sacrifices for the dead. Not only this; but he declares that he finds “a considerable amount of such prayer for the dead unconsciously, yet logically and no less truly, offered in funeral addresses and prayers by the most radical Protestants.” He says:—
A Christian who thinks that the initial stage of salvation must begin in this world before death, will limit his prayers for the dead to their growth in grace and holiness; but a Christian who thinks that salvation may begin after death, will naturally extend his prayers so as to include the conversion and regeneration of the dead. In his prayers for the dead, each Christian will make his practise of prayer conform, in a measure at least, to his theory of salvation. Thus, prayer for the dead is a privilege and a duty for all who practise prayer for the living; and sacrifice for the dead is a duty for all who practise sacrifice for the living. The dead saints and the living saints are so united in one holy communion that in all religious activities all saints share alike.
But where is the sense of talking about these “dead saints” who are said to be so much alive that they can be converted, and can pray in return for those who pray for them? If all that is true, they are not dead at all; but are more alive than they ever were before. To such nonsense and inconsistency are those led who respect the doctrine of the immortality of the soul.
No; “the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not anything.” Eccl. 9:5. The living know something; but the dead know nothing. The living are alive; the dead are not alive—they are dead. “Thou shalt die, and not live,” says the word of God; but behold, these moderns will have it that people die and live both at once. It is sheer paganism; and paganism is sheer deviltry.