OPPOSITIONS OF SCIENCE FALSELY SO-CALLED.
THE papers all over the country are making much ado over Professor Hyslop’s espousal of Spiritualism. Whole columns—two, three, or four—of the papers, daily or weekly, religious and secular alike, are devoted to this subject. This Professor Hyslop is professor of ethics and mental science in Columbia University, New York City, and he declares that “he has positively demonstrated the life after death of men and women, and this in the most rigorously scientific manner, using all the methods of the laboratory, and exercising that extreme caution and repetition of experiment so severely demanded by the inductive method.” And in what way, suppose ye, did he conduct this “most rigorously scientific” investigation?—Precisely as all such investigators have from the beginning of the world—simply through a Spiritualist medium. To what, suppose ye, did he apply “all the methods of the laboratory”?—Only to a Spiritualist medium. And all that was accomplished by these “most rigorously scientific . . . methods of the laboratory” was simply and only to discover that the medium herself was not a fraud; that she was honestly the channel of the communication of intelligences. That is all. And by this he satisfied himself that there are intelligences outside of humanity. The way it is stated in the report of the result of these “rigorously scientific” methods, is that the investigators “have been convinced that through the mechanism of Mrs. Piper’s body it has been proved that there is in man a subtle something which survives after death, preserving the intellectual faculties that manifest themselves through the organs of the body.” That is to say that, from all he was able to discover, he concludes that the manifestations of intelligences through this medium were by the spirits of men who had lived on the earth and died. But this is simply logic by a leap. It is the result merely of his own reasoning. It is a total forsaking of the inductive method; for it is sheer deduction; because when he finds indisputable evidence of intelligences beyond mankind, it does not necessarily follow that these are the spirits of men who have died; and this for the simple reason that there are multitudes of spirits who never were men. There are angels of God, and there are “angels that sinned,” and they are all spirits. So it is altogether a gratuitous conclusion that these scientific men express,—that the intelligences of which they have found evidence, and with whom they have communicated, are the spirits of dead men. And this simply illustrates the fact that the science that is applied and extolled as science in connection with Spiritualism and its manifestations is not science at all; that when it comes to the crucial point, the grounds of science are abandoned, and only the natural reasoning and credulity of the investigator are employed. And what did the professor find in his investigations? One thing particularly that he found is that one of the principal spirits who communicated “was frequently caught telling lies; and when confronted with proofs of his mendacity, would laugh, and say: ‘One must have one’s joke.’” And this was so common in the case of that particular influence that one professor investigator declared: “Whatever the medium is, I am convinced that this influence is a preposterous scoundrel.” And another professor said that “it by no means follows that the trance personality is as honest as the waking one. Indeed, all analogy would be against the assumption.” And the general statement of the whole subject is that “there are foolish as well as wise spirits, vain as well as humble ones; in a word, the spirits of men are no different from men themselves. Naturally, when such an excellent medium as Mrs. Piper is found, all spirits wish to communicate through her. Such direct communicators as Pellew and Phinuit were often overpowered by numerous other spirits, who interjected their own influences, thus producing an unintelligible jumble in the communications. Until the arrival of ‘Imperator,’ whose earthly name is known only to Mr. Myers, of London, the medium was the sport of every vagrant ghost flying hither and thither on the winds of the spirit world.”445 The case, therefore, stands thus: Professor Hyslop and his fellow investigators, by their “rigidly scientific” methods, got into a nest of lying spirits; and these spirits told the investigators that those spirits were the spirits of certain men who had lived in the world; and these “rigidly scientific” investigators believe what the lying spirits say, and publish it to the world as a “great discovery,” “positive demonstration,” etc., etc. Now, how do these investigators know that those spirits are the spirits of men, when they do know that the spirits are “preposterous scoundrels,” and inveterate liars? This again shows that the conclusions which these investigators have drawn “in the most rigorously scientific manner,” have no science about them. Scientific grounds are utterly abandoned, and their conclusions are drawn altogether from the statements of spirits of whom all that the investigators know is by what the spirits themselves say, except that the spirits lie. So that the sum of it all is that the two single results obtained from all their “rigorously scientific” investigation are, (1) that there are intelligences beyond mankind, and (2) that these intelligences do lie. The investigators, indeed, can know that, in certain instances, these intelligences tell the truth; for the investigators can test the statements, and discover whether they be statements of fact; but in all such instances the evidence that what the spirits said is true, rests not upon what the spirits said, but solely upon the existence of the facts themselves. But the crucial question, namely, Who are the intelligences that communicate?—this the investigators never can know, because the persons whom these spirits profess to personate as having lived in the world are dead, and the investigators can not learn from these whether the spirits are telling the truth. Consequently, the only thing that the investigators can certainly know, upon the word of the spirits themselves, is that the spirits do lie. It is therefore literally true that when the investigators reach the crisis of the investigation, all scientific ground is abandoned, and only credulity and natural reasoning are followed—and this in the face of their own knowledge that the spirits are tricksters, liars, and “preposterous scoundrels.” And these deductions drawn by natural reasoning through credulity from such sources, are set forth as thoroughly competent scientific evidence and authority “so severely demanded by the inductive method.” So much is made known so far. Yet the world is promised more, and is asked “to wait for the startling report promised for a year hence by Professor Hyslop.” However, he is willing, while the world is waiting a year, to give “a few hints of what they have learned concerning the one subject that interests every one; that is, the nature of the spirit world.” And the first of these “hints” is that “the disclosures made by the spirits themselves of the sphere inhabited by them will shock all good Christians.” And what are these “disclosures,” for which all good Christians as well as all other persons are asked to wait a year for the full statement of, and to be shocked with? Here they are:— - “The first revelation that comes to the spirit [after entering the other world] is that there is no hell, no heaven, no purgatory.”
- “Spirits do not know more of God than men on this earth know; but they seem to be conscious directly, in a general way, of the continual, imminent presence of a supreme, beneficent power, felt rather as light and warmth than as personality.”
- “The unjust are not punished for their sins committed on the earth. ‘There is no division there into goats and sheep,’ says the professor.”
- “What we call wickedness is usually mere ignorance of those higher laws which insure individual happiness even on earth.”
- “Men can not be held responsible for their ignorance.”
- “A knave simply has some defect of vision which makes him see awry, so that he can not recognize what is best for his own selfish interests.”
- “The law of the next life is progress.”
- “In the spirit world . . . they know that Christ was not God, but a great and a good man.”
From all this it is perfectly plain that, although modern Spiritualism has made many changes in the phases of its manifestations, it has not changed a hair’s breadth in character. It is the same essentially immoral and atheistic thing that it was in its first manifestations more than fifty years ago. It denies the revelation of God, who is essentially good, and puts forth revelations of its own, which are essentially evil. It sets aside human responsibility and moral accountability, thus opening the way for all manner of evil to go unchecked. And all this is commended to the world as “the law of progress.” Now, by simply believing the Bible, all that has been discovered by this so-called “rigorously scientific” investigation of these high-standing university professors could have been learned by them without one hundredth part of all this trouble; without being obliged to trust to their own credulity, and to the deductions of their own natural reasoning through their credulity; and without being landed by it into a vortex of universal and essential deviltry. The Bible tells all people that there are intelligences beyond mankind; that there are “angels of God” and “angels that sinned;” that there are “God and his angels” and “Satan and his angels;” and that these lying, scoundrelly, atheistic, and essentially immoral spirits are the “spirits of devils, working miracles, which go forth unto the kings of the earth and of the whole world.” Rev. 16:14. But, lo, with all these “rigorously scientific” professors, the believing of the word of God, the Bible, and resting on what it says, is credulity, when, as a matter of fact, that word being the very ultimate truth itself, it is the highest possible science; and this because the evidence of its truth rests not upon something else, but is inherent in itself. Then, in the place of this ultimate truth, the highest possible science, which they count credulity, they put what they call science, even the most rigorously applied science, which, at the ultimate, is plainly only sheer credulity, the utter abandonment of science, and the certain launching out into a deep totally unknown except as to the questionable, and even degraded character of the spirits that inhabit it. It is not at all necessary for the world to wait a year for “disclosures” in this connection, “that will shock all good Christians.” What is already made known by Professor Hyslop and his fellow investigators is sufficient to shock not only all good Christians, but also all other people, good or bad. “And when they say to you: Consult the ghosts and the familiar spirits that cheep and that moan, give this answer. Should not a people rather consult its God? on behalf of the living should men consult the dead? [Polychrome translation.] To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isa. 8:19, 20. “Keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings [‘unintelligible jumbles’] and oppositions of science falsely so-called, which some professing have erred concerning the faith.” 1 Tim. 6:20, 21.